News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by refurb on Monday December 26, 2022 @08:22PM (#34143866)
Great article to read if you want to know how the "sausage was made" at Twitter. Unsurprisingly it's not pretty.

As expected, the folks doing the policing of "disinformation" were entirely unqualified for the role (I love the banning of a Harvard Prof who said "vaccines are for people at risk") and ended up making decisions that were "politically expedient" rather than focusing on the truth.

This article perfectly proves why campaigns against "disinformation" are bound to fail - inevitably factual and important information gets censored because it's inconvenient to the people in power.

After reading this article I'm reminded of Rand Paul's quote "Do you know who the greatest propagator of disinformation in the history of the world is? The U.S. government."

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by fortran77 on Monday December 26, 2022 @09:27PM (#34144333)
> Amazingly this news goes over like a wet rag at HN. Which is shocking considering the "hacker ethos" about not bowing down to authority.

This user (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34142326) think's you're "feral" for disagreeing. Hacker News has a knee-jerk reaction to some writers who dare question some (unrelated to this) topics.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by est on Monday December 26, 2022 @09:50PM (#34144462)
> folks doing the policing of "disinformation" were entirely unqualified for the role

Sounds like how Stackoverflow works. 5 people have no clue about the technical question decides to close it entirely.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by andrew_ on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:01PM (#34144507)
It's what many of us thought was going on based on what we could see. It's nice to have it out in the open and verify/confirm what some of us were told was plain old paranoia.
Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by gsatic on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:06PM (#34144536)
Hacker ethos is to solve problems not rant, rave and cry about them and hope grandma shows up with a solution.
Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by laidoffamazon on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:10PM (#34144562)
Yeah. Seems to me that Twitter did a pretty good job overall!
Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by RockyMcNuts on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:17PM (#34144603)
it's a hard tradeoff between false positives and false negatives. it's like being a soccer referee or a judge, you can be almost perfect but the screwups are all anyone remembers. short of putting everyone away for life, some convict is going to get out and do something, and some tabloid is going to question why this person was on the street. You do the best you can subject to the Constitution, the laws, and common sense.

there is so much absolute garbage bad faith BS on social media that is poison to a civilized society and a democracy, that there is no choice but to do the best we can to try to spread less of it. you don't get to throw up your hands and say, there is no perfect arbiter of truth and decency so let's say, anything goes. of course that's what all the worst burn-it-down extremists would like to see.

A lot of US institutions were exposed as unfit for purpose by the pandemic and we have to do better. But I'm not sure Twitter would be near the top of the list.

And somehow, the new regime seems able to make everything worse.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by _-____-_ on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:37PM (#34144775)
If it's such a hard tradeoff then maybe don't make the trade in the first place. Just don't censor speech. Problem solved.

Insisting on censoring speech in this case is what's known as a Hegelian dialectic: there is a problem, we need to solve the problem, here's how we solve the problem.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by PartiallyTyped on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:41PM (#34144816)
This is such a bad take.

You are obligated to censor certain kinds of speech. If you don’t want censored speech, go to 4chan and the likes, observe the cesspool that is “free speech”.

If you are running a social media platform for the masses, you have to censor certain things, and you have to abide by all regulations. You can’t just X.

We have already seen that musk’s pathetic approach via free speech absolutism does not work.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by ryanSrich on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:50PM (#34144875)
> If you are running a social media platform for the masses, you have to censor certain things, and you have to abide by all regulations. You can’t just X.

Legally speaking yes. You absolutely have to censor a decent amount of content. Outside of what is legally required (at least in the US), I’d be in favor of allowing the community to block and mute to curate their own experience. It seems a losing battle to rely on the whims of the people that run the business of Twitter/Facebook/etc. to be the deciders of what should and should not be allowed.

> We have already seen that musk’s pathetic approach via free speech absolutism does not work.

Is this tongue and cheek? Musk’s policies are the antithesis of free speech.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by PartiallyTyped on Monday December 26, 2022 @11:03PM (#34144983)
The only way such a platform would work is if it is non-profit, or people pay for it.

If you rely on advertisements, you have to make the content brand-safe, exhibit: twitter.

> Is this tongue and cheek? Musk’s policies are the antithesis of free speech.

I merely referred to the increase in abuse, hate speech and everything that makes parler and 4chan a cesspoool, with major brands and advertisers leaving the platform.

I had a look at some suggested/promoted tweets the other day, and by all means the content was garbage. Just republicans getting triggered over whatever is bothering them du jour.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by PartiallyTyped on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:24AM (#34146996)
To the people who downvote this, care to point what your issue is besides your fee-fees getting hurt by somebody on the internet who explained why your opinion of how social media should run is juvenile?
Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by RockyMcNuts on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @11:51AM (#34150436)
You have the power to choose, but no power to escape the necessity of choice. If you choose to do nothing you still have made a choice.

Life doesn't require anyone to confront bad stuff that only grows worse if it is tolerated.

Life does, however, require everyone to live with the consequences of our choices.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by int_19h on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:31AM (#34147413)
Speaking of making everything worse...

I'm far left politically. I found COVID very concerning, I'm fully vaccinated, and I still wear a mask indoors.

And yet, after seeing some of the tweets that were labelled as "misleading", I believe that the way the govt and Twitter moderators handled this was a disaster that makes me extremely unlikely to trust anything that either will have to say on any contentious topics in the future.

And if I'm not the only one, what do you think this lack of trust will do to "civilized society and democracy"?

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by RockyMcNuts on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @08:55AM (#34148634)
Someone saying, this looks misleading, here's why, if there is room for good-faith argument about it, it helps me trust them.

Certainly more than suspending journalists on trumped-up pretexts.

I'm less worried about a possibly incorrect 'misleading' tag than I am about weirdo elected officials who make false claims about things I can see with my own eyes, say everyone else is lying, say anyone who disagrees is un-American or a traitor, push divisive conspiracy theories and call for imprisoning our own medical professionals. And given all their other claims and agitprop, it's hard to take seriously a claim that the label violates their First Amendment rights.

Re:How Twitter Rigged the Covid Debate by jklm on Monday December 26, 2022 @10:23PM (#34144649)
Campaigns against disinformation are bound to fail because everyone has a different interpretation of the truth and assumes that everything else is “disinformation” (with quotes this time).

Much like social media generally, disinformation is now one of the chief scapegoats across the aisle for all that’s wrong in the world.