News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Talking to Strangers by cpach on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:42AM (#34118467)
I’m quite the chatterbox and I love talking to strangers. Even if I will never see them again. I do it quite often. I feel it really adds more fun and meaning as I navigate through my little town, or the big city, doing everyday things that could otherwise be quite boring. So at least to me this article rings true.
Re:Talking to Strangers by gausswho on Saturday December 24, 2022 @01:28PM (#34119586)
I also seek out interactions with people I don't know. I'm quite practiced at making it natural and unscary for the other person. Usually never see them again, and that's ok and even desired. There's something very satisfying about it, like I'm sharing a moment with the same person each time but in a different recombination of the whole of us. I strive to keep a regular flow of such interactions coming and I find myself getting ambiguously down if they start to dwindle.
Re:Talking to Strangers by flappyeagle on Saturday December 24, 2022 @02:23PM (#34120199)
Any tips? I can usually carry a conversation but hard to think of a reason to start one
Re:Talking to Strangers by HPsquared on Saturday December 24, 2022 @02:51PM (#34120463)
A random observation à la Seinfeld is always good.
Re:Talking to Strangers by wolverine876 on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:43PM (#34121349)
Say what you feel, be genuine. Be curious about them - including, read the situation. If they are anxiously texting, or looking otherwise like they wouldn't want to be disturbed, don't. And don't force it - there's not always something to say. It's not hard, there's no secret code; it's very basic.

Most of the problem is anxiety. As with anything new, you'll get over it as it becomes familiar. Be patient with yourself.

The bus is late, again, say 'Not again! Are the other buses always late?'

Their fingernail polish catches your eye, say, 'hey - that's great. I love the color/design/etc.'

People don't always respond, some might even look at you strangely - oh well!

Re:Talking to Strangers by MrVandemar on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:39PM (#34123574)
> People don't always respond, some might even look at you strangely - oh well!

Why do you assume you're someone worth having a random conversation with at all? This is a sincere question.

In my experience of people trying to engage me in conversation, none of them are worth the time. At best I've had a social interaction that basically amounted to being on hold on the phone for five minutes while I struggle to work out what these people want and I'm usually left none the wiser; at worst I've had to listen to idiots segue from discussing the weather to holding forth on a variety of lunatic-fringe causes. Time wasted.

On the rare times I've tried to engage people in conversation they react like I would: impatience that I'm wasting their time, and/or blank looks.

I'd really discourage anyone trying to randomly engage people in conversation unless you're sure you really have some kind of shared interest. IE, you're at a gig, you might imagine then that you could have a meaningful conversation with someone there about the band you are both there to listen to.

Re:Talking to Strangers by kelseyfrog on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:17PM (#34123840)
Not parent, but the idea that a conversation with a stranger has inherit worth is tied to two ideas that I hold: people have inherit worth, and that can be exchanged through communication.

I find it relatively easy now to find points of commonality with most people I talk to. Some of this could be explained by the value I place on the intangible feeling of understanding and being understood might be an outlier too.

You're absolutely right too in that if you're repeatedly not clicking with someone it probably isn't worth it to keep the conversation going, but even then there are exceptions. I've seen it take several attempts before a conversation takes flight and sometimes even then it dips back into the mundane only to pick back up again a minute or two later. However, people are much less likely to try to find common points of interest if the person they speak to assumes they're an idiot.

Re:Talking to Strangers by wolverine876 on Monday December 26, 2022 @04:24AM (#34136090)
> Why do you assume you're someone worth having a random conversation with at all?

...

> On the rare times I've tried to engage people in conversation they react like I would: impatience that I'm wasting their time, and/or blank looks.

> I'd really discourage anyone trying to randomly engage people in conversation unless you're sure you really have some kind of shared interest.

In my experience, the conversations are almost always very positive. Others report positive experiences and find it worthwhile. That suggests you are sadly missing something. The odd thing is, you seem to want to stop others from having these positive experiences.

I reject any question about my worth or anyone's 'worth'. Perhaps part of the problem is that you are thinking about 'worth', and so judgmentally and dubiously, that people don't respond well. People pick up on those signals; they respond poorly to being judged. Or perhaps you are judging your own worth, which would be sad.

I find that my attitude and emotion greatly influences how the conversations go. Especially, give people space to flourish, be curious about them, and you will be amazed at what is inside - worlds of knowledge, insight and creativity that you never imagined. They are in you too, I'm sure.

Re:Talking to Strangers by xen2xen1 on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:09PM (#34123377)
"man you do that really fast, you must do that a lot!". Typing, swiping at the checkout, asking "would you like fries with that", look to see what struggle they might be having, or what might annoy them. Get into their space and see what is going on and commiserate.
Re:Talking to Strangers by MrVandemar on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:30PM (#34123513)
My tip: don't start.

Random people coming up to me, usually stating something perfectly obvious that doesn't need stating ("Cool Hat!/Hey it's Hot Today/How about the footy eh?"), and then trying to converse on a variety of boring subjects (the weather/politics/footy/where I bought my hat/vaccines are evil/Jesus Christ is Our Savior) is a colossal waste of my CPU time.

Don't be that annoying person. Live and let live.

Re:Talking to Strangers by to1y on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:07AM (#34124469)
I agree. Most people who do this are introverted/shy by nature unhappy with it and this is their method of proving to themselves and the world that they're not. However it ends up being just as awkward and an equal waste of time because it lacks genuine emotion. Don't say anything and be content with it unless it's something you truly want to express. I.e. whatever is natural for you is probably natural for them.
Re:Talking to Strangers by flappyeagle on Monday December 26, 2022 @11:58AM (#34139416)
Why do you assume it lacks genuine emotion? What if someone (e.g. me) is simply unpracticed at expressing it?
Re:Talking to Strangers by pat2man on Saturday December 24, 2022 @01:30PM (#34119622)
Me too but when I was younger I hated it. It was definitely centered around a fear of being rejected or ridiculed. I eventually learned that my fear was unfounded. Possibly a good use of cognitive behavioral therapy.
Re:Talking to Strangers by wpietri on Saturday December 24, 2022 @02:41PM (#34120376)
For me my fears were richly justified by experience.

Casual conversation with strangers is both complex and subtle, and particularly requires specific face and body language. I think neurotypicals underestimate the complexity because it comes naturally to them.

These days I'm fine at it and have no fear. But getting rid of the fear took getting good at it and doing it enough to compensate for those older experiences.

Re:Talking to Strangers by taeric on Saturday December 24, 2022 @03:10PM (#34120634)
I'm wary of claims that neurotypicals are somehow better at it. Seems more likely that nobody is as good as most everyone assumes they are. That is, self assessment is a known hard problem. Assessment of others would have many of the same traps.
Re:Talking to Strangers by lazide on Saturday December 24, 2022 @03:31PM (#34120804)
There are well recognized patterns in specific types of ‘neuro divergents’ that are fundamental to the conditions and that make it very difficult, if not impossible, to recognize or process common social cues in useful ways. It makes them categorically have a much harder time in this area, for those categories.

What you’re saying is essentially ‘meh, don’t just assume you are hallucinating sometimes just because you’re schizophrenic’.

Maybe? but if they think they are, they very well might be right.

Re:Talking to Strangers by taeric on Saturday December 24, 2022 @03:42PM (#34120886)
Fair. My wariness comes from knowing a large number of people that claim to have these complications, but are also just rude people.

Which is to say, they may be divergent. That doesn't do much to suggest that others are "better" at this. Turns out that life is hard for most everyone.

Re:Talking to Strangers by lazide on Saturday December 24, 2022 @03:54PM (#34120997)
How would you expect them to present except as rude, in that situation?

That sounds like you’re complaining that said schizophrenic in the prior example just ‘seems a little crazy’, but life is tough for everyone?

Re:Talking to Strangers by taeric on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:05PM (#34121072)
I mean rude in the child sense, honestly. Kids can be seen as neuro divergent, sure. But even "typical" ones are often surprisingly rude. Very few people just "know" how to be polite.
Re:Talking to Strangers by lazide on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:07PM (#34121088)
Ok, but what would you expect it to look like otherwise, if they could not actually learn those things because their brain was not wired to be able to?

They still are going to grow up, but unlike normal folks, they can’t learn those skills - or if they do, it takes vastly more effort.

Re:Talking to Strangers by taeric on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:11PM (#34121126)
Me claim is more to be taken that you should work from the assumption it is hard for everyone. Setting yourself apart as someone that is "just bad" at it is going to reinforce that idea.

Can it be true? Of course. Some folks are also just bad at math.

Re:Talking to Strangers by nicoburns on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:22PM (#34121190)
If it was hard for everyone it wouldn't be such a problem, as presumably people would be more tolerant of others getting it "wrong". As it is, it seems that there's a large cadre of people who not only find it easy, but find the "correct" behaviours so self-evident that they tend to assume that people who don't notice these things (or whose natural preferences are different from the unwritten social norm) are being wilfully offensive.
Re:Talking to Strangers by taeric on Saturday December 24, 2022 @05:05PM (#34121577)
It is a learned skill. And many norms are not as shared as folks assume they are. As such, I think you are understating how willing folks are to tolerate people getting it "wrong."

I say this as someone that would almost certainly be described as neuro divergent. Fake it till you make it is the norm for social interactions. That and repetition.

Is akin to thinking everyone else is a good dancer. I mean, the more practiced dancers will be better, at large. There are relatively fewer folks that can't dance, compared to those that don't dance.

Re:Talking to Strangers by lazide on Saturday December 24, 2022 @07:22PM (#34122697)
You seem to be assuming they did not try because they assumed they had an incurable problem.

Why not assume that they did try (and still are), and after failing over and over when others did not, realized they have a problem and are being open about it?

You seem to be denying the problem actually can exist, and blame them for not trying - when you don’t seem to know if they are trying or not. It’s quite odd.

Re:Talking to Strangers by taeric on Saturday December 24, 2022 @07:34PM (#34122779)
I can be wary of things that I know exist. To the point that I'll argue you seem to be taking my point to an obviously false position.

I'm wary of most labeling of this as normal versus otherwise in people. That is it. It presumes a lot of unfairness that, while it does happen, is often overstated, as well.

Re:Talking to Strangers by kelseyfrog on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:21PM (#34123862)
This line of questioning is interesting. Does anyone have papers on the quantification of NT inference ability in conversations?
Re:Talking to Strangers by taeric on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:37AM (#34125436)
Agreed it would be interesting to see. If you find and links, please post back.
Re:Talking to Strangers by marcodiego on Saturday December 24, 2022 @03:55PM (#34121008)
I knew people who loved doing that. One of them told me recently that conspiracism has ruined the experience. It is very hard to talk to someone today without eventually hearing a "Did you know that" followed by a baseless conspiracy theory.
Re:Talking to Strangers by cheschire on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:08PM (#34121097)
Yep, we used to have taboo topics, but the overton window is massive these days.
Re:Talking to Strangers by epicureanideal on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:23PM (#34121195)
But maybe it’s a good thing that people say these things out loud so we can discuss them and maybe convince them otherwise? Or learn that in some cases they might be right?
Re:Talking to Strangers by cheschire on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:41PM (#34121332)
Sure, if you have patience and energy for those sorts of tug-of-war type conversations.
Re:Talking to Strangers by watwut on Saturday December 24, 2022 @06:20PM (#34122233)
Not really. It is not that we can convince then. And it is mostly that the world moved toward these and that they won at convincing others.
Re:Talking to Strangers by marcodiego on Saturday December 24, 2022 @06:24PM (#34122269)
This doesn't work that well. Conspiracists won't change their mind despite any evidence. Unless you're a very good speaker, trying to argue with them will only give them a "stage" to profess their ideas.

Arguing against an irrational but skilled speaker will only benefit the unreasonable one, specially if you arguments are simple and technical: most people don't understand simplicity or technicalities; but get hypnotized by voice, fear, indignation and a feeling of "if he is that person is right them I'm screwed!"

The best way to counter conspiracists is (I think) leaving them alone and spread rationality among the ones who are still not sick or can be cured.

Re:Talking to Strangers by epicureanideal on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:59AM (#34125549)
Ok, but there are "committed conspiracists" and "misinformed conspiracists" or people who haven't thought things through very well, and the latter group(s) may benefit from being able to speak their opinion freely and hear counter-arguments.
Re:Talking to Strangers by PenguinCoder on Saturday December 24, 2022 @08:28PM (#34123114)
No it's not a good thing and you won't ever change someone's mind on their belief in a conspiracy theory, from a one off conversation. people like that have no logical basis for their belief, you can't reason with them using better logic. All you'll end up doing is wasting your time and likely pissing multiple people off. Including yourself. Not worth it.
Re:Talking to Strangers by wiml on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:03AM (#34124797)
I think it is good in a way. You're not going to convince them of anything in that ten minute bus stop conversation, not should you try. But it's good for them to have the experience of talking to someone who doesn't believe in their thing, and it's good for both of you to interact with someone you don't share a belief with but still experience them as a person. On the Internet we tend to protect ourselves from the other by replacing them with a caricature. Regardless of who's right and who's wrong that can become a pretty toxic habit.
Re:Talking to Strangers by kelseyfrog on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:00PM (#34123726)
I find it fascinating that society can support the range of conspiracy and illogical thought out there. I'd always assumed that someone's faulty reasoning would get in their way of their Activities of Daily Living (ADLs), but apparently this is not the case. It's emperically possible to hold the wildest beliefs and still manage a daily existence.

These folks are still hold jobs, pay their bills, raise kids and then meetup with folks on the weekend who sling conspiracy theories that would have been Poe's Law material on 1990s internet.

Maybe I'm wrong in a different way, but at least that means I still have something new to learn.

Re:Talking to Strangers by tehwebguy on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:09PM (#34121110)
Woah, all different topics or what?
Re:Talking to Strangers by mistermann on Saturday December 24, 2022 @04:59PM (#34121511)
I feel the same way about people and their media and culturally powered "truths" which are rarely substantiated as fact, and often conflict with conspiracy theories.

Although, I find talking to all sorts of people about their "factual" beliefs about "reality" to be an immensely enjoyable experience. Smart people very often hold the most interesting beliefs.

Re:Talking to Strangers by layman51 on Saturday December 24, 2022 @08:45PM (#34123222)
In my view, I categorize conspiracy theory conversation to be the same as speaking about religion. What I mean by this is I try not to ask poking questions because I want to avoid offending the person's beliefs and I also don't want to make it seem as if I want to get sucked into their religion / conspiracy theory. For the most part though, most conspiracy theories involve faith without evidence. This approach only works when the conspiracy theory isn't tied to urgent action (maybe including inaction or noncompliance) or scapegoating.