News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by TedDoesntTalk on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:31PM (#34112853)
Append it where?
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by endisneigh on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:33PM (#34112872)
e.g. password to facebook would be:

facebook.com$293MyPasswordYouKnowIt!!123

password to gmail would be

mail.google.com$113MyPasswordYouKnowIt!!123

only annoying thing is that the passwords are long. I guess it's secure, though.

Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by zenexer on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:38PM (#34112913)
That’s not secure at all.

Eventually, some website you use is going to get hacked. They’ll have stored passwords as plaintext. From there, anyone who wants to hack any of your accounts knows your password format. It’s going to be obvious to them that they just need to replace the domain.

Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by endisneigh on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:40PM (#34112926)
how would they figure out the unique identifier? couldn't you say the same thing about using an arbitrarily unique password and then a password manager. if your password manager is hacked then they'd get the encrypted passwords for all sites you use along with all the personal information.

of course, you'll say, don't use a crappy password manager. and that's correct. same reason I don't go to sites that store their stuff in plaintext.

Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by aliqot on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:44PM (#34112948)
you're putting a lot of confidence in an effective password length of 3
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by endisneigh on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:45PM (#34112961)
you're thinking too much about the specific example and not the general point, but I edited the parent comment with an actual example

edit: oh, I did say append so I see why you'd think that. that's my bad. what I meant was include

Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by danparsonson on Friday December 23, 2022 @09:00PM (#34113066)
By your example, your passwords are a set of fixed or knowable data, plus a unique identifier that in your examples is three characters long. Therefore knowing one of your passwords gives all except three characters of every other password, thus making your effective password length three characters (substitute the actual length of your unique identifier if it's more than three).
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by endisneigh on Friday December 23, 2022 @09:01PM (#34113075)
you're right - i have clarified what I actually do. however I do something similar with a different password for sites I deem unsafe, or spammy.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by danparsonson on Saturday December 24, 2022 @12:10AM (#34114195)
Sure, that's slightly better, but you're putting in quite a lot of effort for minimal reward - there still isn't much entropy here compared to the size of the password, and you're relying on security through obscurity (that no-one will work out your method). Password crackers on modern GPUs can chew through many millions of guesses per second so having such a significant leg up would likely make your strategy trivial to break.

Also plenty of perfectly respectable sites have been compromised in the past so your estimation about how safe the site is unfortunately doesn't help much.

I really think you'd be better off using long randomly-generated strings and keeping multiple backups of your password database. There are lots of options that don't put you in the hands of a third party. All (?) sites offer password reset facilities in case of emergency, and you could memorise your email account password so that you can always at least get into that.

Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by endisneigh on Saturday December 24, 2022 @08:54AM (#34116792)
the main goal for myself is to be able to have complicated passwords and remember them without a computer. the problem with all password managers is ultimately it must be possible to get them in plain text by design, so if someone gets that they get all of your passwords.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by TedDoesntTalk on Saturday December 24, 2022 @12:03PM (#34118681)
I’m confused how you worked 2022 into the password. Trying to deduce your algorithm.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by pcthrowaway on Friday December 23, 2022 @10:17PM (#34113557)
Possibly not even 3 characters; 3 numbers.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by yardstick on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:48PM (#34112989)
It does reduce the search space for a brute force attempt. Depending on how short your identifier is. Also if two sites passwords are leaked it could make someone’s job a lot easier.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by oefrha on Friday December 23, 2022 @09:15PM (#34113166)
Pro tip: don’t boast about your password strategy with ~10 bits of entropy online. If I were to target you, you just gave me an edge for free.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by kangalioo on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:36PM (#34112893)
How do you remember the unique identifier?
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by endisneigh on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:37PM (#34112900)
it's deterministic, but obviously I can't tell you the secret ;)

that being said there are a lot of things you could use. you could use information in the whois, you could use the birthdate of the founder of the site, etc.

personally I believe people should use the same password for all sites and then something similar to what I described. though I use a password manager, I do always feel nervous about the implementation leaking out details

Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by Bud on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:49PM (#34112993)
This means that if a breach reveals more than one of your passwords, the pattern is easily recognized and you just made ALL your passwords extremely weak. Not a great idea.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by endisneigh on Friday December 23, 2022 @08:51PM (#34113004)
this is true, yes. fwiw what I do is more complicated than an append. I'll edit it to say "include", which is more accurate.
Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by int_19h on Saturday December 24, 2022 @12:02AM (#34114148)
This scheme as described is not secure, but with one more step it can be. Luckily, that step has already been automated:

https://www.lesspass.com/

Re:Cryptopathic: The situation at LastPass may be worse than... by TedDoesntTalk on Saturday December 24, 2022 @12:06PM (#34118708)
Prior art: http://PasswordMaker.org also with apps, browser extensions, command line tools, and many forks.