News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UnifiedPush: A decentralized, open-source push notificati... by dncornholio on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:29AM (#34095120)
Does the user require to install a separate app to receive UnifiedPush messages?
Re:UnifiedPush: A decentralized, open-source push notificati... by MayeulC on Thursday December 22, 2022 @11:40AM (#34095273)
Yes, they need to have a UnifiedPush distributor on their device, that acts like Google services.

OS makers could install a default UnifiedPush distributor though.

Lastly, the Embedded FCM UnifiedPush library (to be embeded into a client app) handles UnifiedPush over FCM (Google-provided push notifications), so that a server only has to handle the UnifiedPush API (with a rewrite proxy for UP->FCM).

https://unifiedpush.org/developers/embedded_fcm/

Re:UnifiedPush: A decentralized, open-source push notificati... by ehutch79 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:43PM (#34099178)
We can't get users to understand that the ceo isn't sending them mail from [email protected] to go and buy giftcards, and not to ask any questions.

What's the actual likely hood that the average end user is going to install a random service?

Re:UnifiedPush: A decentralized, open-source push notificati... by karmanyaahm on Thursday December 22, 2022 @04:53PM (#34099312)
> What's the actual likely hood that the average end user is going to install a random service?

For now, UnifiedPush is targeted towards De-Googlers, self-hosters and FOSS enthusiasts, not average users.

Re:UnifiedPush: A decentralized, open-source push notificati... by ehutch79 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @06:34PM (#34100432)
Except, in the threads here, this is called out repeatedly as a replacement for push notifications on phones, replacing webpush, apple push notifications, and whatever google is calling it.

Which implies the use case people are seeing is phone apps. Unless people are building one off apps for themselves, you've got end users in the mix.

I don't see how this can be positions as much outside of phone apps, as txt messages or emails would be easier and more universal. Being that they're probably going to be supported here.

To note, i haven't see anyone talking about this being replacement for the part of webpush that handles registration for notifications or whatnot, but as a whole separate channel/technology. Not 'install this to avoid using google/apple for webpush' but 'use this in your app, and have your users install the service'.

Re:UnifiedPush: A decentralized, open-source push notificati... by palata on Thursday December 22, 2022 @10:32PM (#34102072)
Some apps just offer both, and even auto-detect. So if your phone is de-googled, the app will use UP, if it has the Google Services it will use that. For some apps it is available in the settings.

So yeah, the app has to support it, but the user can choose then.

Re:UnifiedPush: A decentralized, open-source push notificati... by Groxx on Friday December 23, 2022 @01:03AM (#34102748)
People are seeing it as a way to get efficient push notifications in an open, decentralized system.

That's pretty much it. Because there isn't really any possible alternative except something that looks like this.

GCM/APNS/ETC do not fit those requirements, so it needs to be something new.