News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by vouaobrasil on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:23AM (#34076996)
This is the prisoner's dilemma situation. Everyone would benefit more from a reduction, but if only one company does it, they benefit (in the short term) even more.

I think the signalling is also valuable -- humans have a remarkable tendency to adopt attitudes over time, and I think every contribution towards the attitude that we should not harm the environment is a good one.

I for one currently support and will continue to support companies with sustainable environmental practises even if the cost is higher, and I encourage everyone to do the same. For, that increased cost is like a payment for that piece (however small) of the environment that I otherwise would not have, and I think that's worth it.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by minism on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:25AM (#34077006)
Right.. this is a perfect example of why government legislation/intervention in the market is needed to some degree.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by flockonus on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:35AM (#34077064)
Over our globalized economy I don't see how local government legislation can work (unfortunately).

Long are gone the days governments around the world coordinated to banish CFCs, for instance.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by vlovich123 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:51AM (#34077164)
You establish agreements over a large enough market that it actually makes a different so that competitors doing the right thing aren’t penalized or aren’t penalized enough that they’re disincentivized.

Sometimes that market is the US and you only need a local bill to do that. Sometimes you do a bilateral or multilateral treaty. But these things happen all the time even today. Eg if not for trump there would probably have been a new pacific trade agreement and Biden has managed to rally multilateral cooperation around security issues around Russia (eg see new applications to NATO as one example as well as related economic agreements and sanctions) and climate change.

The main challenge is that Trump’s behavior of cancelling deals that were on the finish line as well as backing out of existing agreements (Paris accords + Iran) means that partners are now more wary of entering into agreements in the first place.

This has less to do with globalization and more to do with USA’s increasing instability as a reliable partner that can execute on agreed-upon commitments across political transitions. So now countries are less reliant on commitments from the USA. From one perspective, that’s good - local autonomy is a powerful tool. From a different perspective, the USA frequently (not always and maybe not even a majority of the time) lead the way and set a global direction through unilateral action (ie even without treaties). Again, that’s gone less because of globalization I think and more that the world has grown tired of USA’s political weight throwing and realpolitik behavior rather than sticking to common principles (democracy, rule of law, not torturing enemies no matter what they’ve done, human rights, raising up scientists and facts even when politically inconvenient or leaders applying pressure to move their voter base instead of playing tail wag the dog, having principles about who we count as our allies etc). One set of behaviors engenders trust while the other degrades it and leads to whatsboutisim politics. Agreements in low trust environments are rarer and harder to maintain. Agreements in high trust environments are much cheaper.

So, while I agree that the “governments around the world coordinating” is harder I disagree that it’s impossible or that it was caused by globalization Val multi-generational realpolitik weight throwing and underhanded behavior that killed a lot of the good will brought about as the “saviors of WWII” propaganda that was wide spread + “golden city” aura post WWII and during the Cold War + technological and economically outpacing Russia. We’ve been leveraging that good will more than our finances because the former is completely invisible and impossible to quantify and measure.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by safety1st on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:57AM (#34077195)
It really only takes the EU and US agreeing that something is bad. Together they represent a huge chunk of the imports of nearly every sector of the global economy. In practice that is what globalization largely is - other countries producing stuff that the US and EU buy.

If you manufacture a chemical and the US and EU both decide that chemical is banned and can't be imported, your business may very well be toast, and you will have a large incentive to produce stuff that they want instead. This doesn't necessarily even take legislation as the relevant governments have a variety of ways they can apply tariffs, disincentives etc. to stuff they don't like.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by messe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:20AM (#34078032)
It doesn’t even take both agreeing necessarily. In many cases just either one of the EU or the US legislating something is sufficient financial incentive to follow the same rule globally.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by Brian_K_White on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:03AM (#34077538)
The entire US benefits from rules only California makes for itself. The entire world benefits from rules only the EU makes for itself.

That very same globalization sometimes causes influence as a pure byproduct.

Regardless, it's not an all or nothing situation. If there are 6000 problems, it's perfectly fine to pick just one of them, and do something that only makes it 1% better. So what there are 5999 other problems? So what most of this one problem didn't even get better because there is some way around it? Tomorrow you just keep doing more of the same and make the current problem 2% better. Or make one of the other 5999 a little better.

All progress is plodding. There is no other type.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by missedthecue on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:27AM (#34077023)
PFAS are used because there isn't a better alternative. A globally coordinated reduction in production only increases the price of products for consumers.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by Centigonal on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:32AM (#34077050)
...which is a good thing! we should stop taking $20 teflon pans, nonstick fast food containers, and $40 raincoats with negative externalities for granted.

We did fine without PFAS, we'll be okay with expensive PFAS (where externalities are internalized and built into the cost) too.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by wkat4242 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:46AM (#34077128)
Does paying for the pollution really help fix the problem? Will the government use that money to filter rivers for PFAS?

I think a lot of this need also comes from other supposedly environmental choices. My work banned plastic cups and now has paper cups with PFAS which are more toxic. I think the plastic ones were the better choice if recycled properly.

And raincoats were really really horrible before Gore-Tex.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by Centigonal on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:25AM (#34077360)
Price elasticity is real: if PFAS is more expensive, people will buy (and businesses will produce) fewer PFAS-derived products. Raising the price is especially nice because it causes price-elastic use cases (think PFAS coated paper cups) to drop out, while price-inelastic use cases (think teflon joint implants) are not made illegal, just more expensive. If the government earmarks PFAS tax revenue for remediation, that'd be awesome, but that's just a side benefit - the price increase is the main benefit.

I do thing greenwashing and environmental whack-a-mole is a real problem (heck, we see it in the PFAS space with GenX replacing PFOA). I don't see that as a valid reason to do nothing.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by geysersam on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:18AM (#34077318)
Paying for pollution makes the customer consider the full cost of the product, reducing demand to cases when the benefits of using the chemical are actually bigger than the external costs.

It's not about using the money to solve the problems. It's about making the economy more efficient.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by lukas099 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:18AM (#34077314)
If things cost more, people generally buy less of them.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by the_third_wave on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:44AM (#34077445)
> And raincoats were really really horrible before Gore-Tex.

Nope, they were fine. A bit heavier but far longer-lasting, including the waxed versions which can be re-waxed if needed to keep up waterproofing. I'm still using my army-issued raincoats from when I served in 1992, one of them has been with me on a number of expeditions (months of paddling the Yukon from Whitehorse to the Bering Strait, climbing several mountains, etc) where it doubled as a tent bottom, it is still perfectly serviceable. The lighter version I still use when cycling, it is still waterproof and the seams - which usually are the weak spot - still hold. I'm also using a 20yo wax coat which I re-waxed a few times (still using the original tin of wax), that one hardly contains any synthetics. Anything made of Gore-Tex would have delaminated after a few months of this type of use.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by wkat4242 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:17AM (#34078013)
But waxed fabrics don't breathe. That was the huge advantage of Gore-Tex.

Being able to be dry and yet not get soaked in your own sweat was a really amazing invention.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by the_third_wave on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:19AM (#34078400)
Waxed fabrics do "breathe" more or less as much as much as Gore-Tex does and - important - keep on doing so as long as you keep them waxed enough but not too much. Don't make the coat look like a waxed cheese, you're using too much wax. Use enough to get the fabric to reject dripping or flowing water, no more. Gore-Tex was made to imitate this characteristic without the need for wax but once the membrane is damaged it can not be repaired, unlike waxed fabrics.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by snovv_crash on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:38AM (#34078950)
This isn't true. The Gore-Tex layer isn't damaged like this. You're referring to the DNW coating, and there's no reason this can't be a waxed layer like old-school rain jackets. In fact a lot of companies started offering wax based DNW coatings in the name of environmental responsibility.

The actual "Gore-Tex" layer, now no longer under patent and produced by many under names such as Dermizax, H2No, Sympatex and many others, is a thin, flexible, *fragile* PTFE membrane. This allows air through, and via a heat-pump-like mechanism drives water on its surfaces from the warm side to the cool side. There is no 'old school rainjacket' equivalent for this.

Usually when your Gore-Tex jacket stops working it is because the DNW layer is gone. If you used a wax replacement the actual Gore-Tex would still be fine and your rain jacket would still be miles better than anything available 100 years ago.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by the_third_wave on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:28PM (#34083601)
A search says more than a 1000 words - and so do the countless questions it produces on just the problem of delamination.

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=gore-tex+delamination

It might work fine for a weekend hike but the stuff does not hold up to repeated strain. Eventually it'll start to delaminate at the shoulders due to wear from backpack straps, cuffs and other exposed spots. This 'eventually' will depend on what you're doing while wearing the things, as said that weekend hike won't put as much strain on it as does walking the Appalachian trail or crossing the Hardangervidda, let along climbing a few mountains. I like to use material which keeps and can be repaired if needed so for me this is a no-go. My backpacks are between 30 and 50 years old, my raingear between 20 and 30 years, my tents and sleeping bags between 20 and 25 years, my cooking gear is more than 40 years old. It may not be fashionable - who cares about fashion when you're alone in the woods - and it may not be the lightest or most high-tech but I know I can depend on it.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by wkat4242 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @09:42PM (#34089054)
That delamination doesn't happen for normal gore-tex where the membrane is one of the inner layers. It's only with the ultra-thin version used by cyclists that is hydrophobic on the outside. My gear usually starts ripping before the waterproofing is compromised.

But I replace my gear when needed anyway and recycle it. I do hike, but not very far from the civilized world. And previously I lived in a place where it rains every day in winter (western Ireland) so good breathing raingear is really a must have.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by wkat4242 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:46AM (#34090558)
PS the fabric I refer to is called "Shakedry". But it's only one of the many types of gore-tex. The more traditional types don't have this issue.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by snovv_crash on Friday December 23, 2022 @01:13PM (#34108886)
You can get Gore-Tex patch kits for any punctures you encounter.

There are also a wide range of textiles available for the outer layers. Many have high Kevlar/aramid content and are much tougher in abrasion than waxed cotton.

I have a Ventile jacket which should be the pinnacle of cotton waterproof design, and it is much easier to damage than modern synthetic jacket, and on top of this it doesn't breath as well, or keep me as dry under continuous downpour conditions. It's also harder to repair due to the high density of the fibres.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by concordDance on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:10AM (#34078337)
Why are people big on recycling plastic? In the West, non-recycled plastic goes to landfill and is LESS likely to end up in the oceans or whatever, as "recycling" is often sent overseas.

In fact, single use plastic means more oil being used for plastic and less burnt for fuel, leading to lower CO2 emissions.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by spikeagally on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:49PM (#34083935)
>> I think a lot of this need also comes from other supposedly environmental choices. My work banned plastic cups and now has paper cups with PFAS which are more toxic. I think the plastic ones were the better choice if recycled properly.

Why do you need to choose between plastic or paper (PFAS)? Does your work not provide glasses? Ceramic mugs? Can you not bring your own reusable water bottle?

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by SyzygistSix on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:44AM (#34090547)
What was wrong with the old rubber raincoats?
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by wkat4242 on Thursday December 22, 2022 @05:22AM (#34091885)
Sweatiness.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by SyzygistSix on Thursday December 22, 2022 @01:56PM (#34096989)
So we have to use toxic chemicals because people don't like being sweaty. Makes sense.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by 4ad on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:58AM (#34077515)
We should stop taking the pans, one-time use containers, etc, but a GoreTex jacket costs $400, not $40, and even the "cheap" GoreTex knockoffs cost $200...
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by missedthecue on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:03AM (#34077539)
What will happen is that the PFAS pan becomes $26 instead of $20. PFAS is not the most expensive part of the pan, only a minor component. A doubling or tripling of PFAS prices is unlikely to price anyone out of getting that pan or raincoat. It's just going to make middle and lower class people cumulatively billions of dollars poorer.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by pigsty on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:28AM (#34077688)
Iron pans are ridiculously cheap these days and they last forever if you bother to read the 3 line instructions included with them.

Teflon isn’t as great as people were deceived into believing. Even if you’re absolutely meticulous with care, it’ll have a noticeable lack in non-stick abilities within months and be noticeably sticky after 2 years, and rapidly degrading into useless territory. An iron pan starts out about as sticky as a slightly used Teflon pan and feels like brand new Teflon after a few uses and stays that way for as long as a human lifespan.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by missedthecue on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:05AM (#34078295)
I mean pans are only one thing. PFAS are used in many products. Yes you can make inferior substitutions but again this reduces standard of living.

This is not to mention its widespread use in military applications. There is already concern about China's lock on the global supply of rare earths and other raw materials like silicon and magnesium (80%+ market share). What happens when the US can't make fighter jets because a belligerent China refuses to export PFAS?

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by pigsty on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:55AM (#34078646)
Generally, matters of national security are exempt from consumer goods safety regulations.

A typical company also can’t easily handle, say, plutonium, but if the military needs it, an exemption is granted.

The typical consumer gets by without lead, asbestos, and so on. The consumer market will adapt.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by missedthecue on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:06AM (#34080206)
But it doesn't look like a market of the government banning 3M from making it, they are exiting the market out of their own volition
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by shmageggy on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:09PM (#34083351)
What will make people effectively poorer, not having non-stick coating on pans, or the large-scale poisoning of the natural world and our bodies?
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by missedthecue on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:40PM (#34083802)
There is no proof that PFAS is causing large scale poisoning. Industrial workers with insufficient PPE may get increased risks of health effects if they are subject to prolonged exposure to concentrated amounts. But so does exposure to fertilizer and aspartame. The research is not anywhere near saying PFAS are causing large scale poisoning.

It reminds me of the microplastics debate too. Lots of panic about it, little scientific evidence that it is causing large scale health problems.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by shmageggy on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:38PM (#34086091)
I’m glad lawmakers, investors, businesses, and nearly everyone else are not waiting around for “proof”, since that is a nearly impossible standard. We know that these substances are everywhere, and there is evidence of it causing harm in animals and in humans

> With many health effects noted for a relatively few example compounds and hundreds of other PFAS in commerce lacking toxicity data… [1]

If we were to wait to run studies on all of those hundreds of substances, there will just be that much more pollutant in our environments and bodies that will be virtually impossible to clean up. The risk/reward tradeoff is pretty clear.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7906952/

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by themitigating on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:42AM (#34077104)
Better solution ?

Let's take one example. Teflon coated cookware. As an alternative there are cooking sprays, butter, oils, or stiring the contents of the pan more frequently.

In this case it's not a nessacity but a convenience. Why don't we start by restricting the use of PFAS to those products in which there are no alternatives and are a nessacity.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by p1necone on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:49AM (#34077142)
In my experience non stick pans are pretty awful, basically anything else is a better alternative.

You can't get them hot enough to sear a steak properly without damaging the non stick coating, and the non stick coating is oleophobic which means that oil pools rather than spreading out so you can't get proper browning on anything even if you do cook it at an appropriate temp.

Seasoned cast iron and carbon steel will be non stick without either of those downsides, and even regular stainless steel is perfectly fine as long as you let it heat up properly before using it.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by cityofdelusion on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:58AM (#34077202)
I love my cast iron, stainless, and carbon steel pans, but calling them nonstick is a stretch. In fact, their stickiness is pretty much their valuable property in getting good browning on food.

You can definitely cook delicate fish and scrambled eggs on say, cast iron, but you will either be scraping hard during clean up or using an absurd amount of oil to cook. I don't mind it myself, but its clear why nonstick is popular.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by haswell on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:14AM (#34077607)
A high quality, well seasoned cast iron pan will allow you to fry an egg while said egg slides around the pan as if nonstick.

Not every pan is capable of this, and meticulous care is required to keep it in shape, but I became a believer in non stick cast iron when I first met a pan that could do it. I had used plenty of "stickier" cast iron pans before and my perspective shifted a bit.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by snovv_crash on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:55AM (#34079046)
Cast iron is useless for food with starch, eg. hash browns. The starch absorbs the seasoning and you end up with an unseasoned pan with burnt pieces stuck everywhere.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by haswell on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:10PM (#34085758)
This is why an assortment of pans is critical. I have cast iron for sticky things, and cast iron for other things.

And seasoning is a never ending task.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by Reason077 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:50AM (#34077834)
I season my stainless steel pan with a few drops of oil, rubbed on with a paper towel. Very rarely do I have problems with anything sticking to it.

If I'm searing a steak or something at high heat, sure, it's going to leave some burnt-on marks, but if you add water and leave it simmering on minimum heat with a bit of baking soda for 15 minutes, pretty much anything will wipe off with no effort.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by CoastalCoder on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:19AM (#34077631)
I agree. I used nonstick pans for a long time. But once the coating starts to degrade, they're worse than decent-quality traditional cookware. Because food starts to stick, but you still can't use metal utensils to scrape it off.

Now I just use stainless-steel or (rarely) cast iron, and I'm much happier.

And it's even cheaper, long-term. A decent stainless-steel pan costs $50-$200 USD, but lasts approximately forever. Whereas a decent non-stick equivalent costs $30-$50, but needs replacement every few years even if I'm careful with it.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by Reason077 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:58AM (#34077880)
IKEA make a fantastic stainless steel[1] pan called "SENSUELL". Best pan I ever bought! Heavy indestructible construction, heats evenly, retains heat, cleans easily, can be placed under the grill, looks good, etc. The price has gone up recently, but it's still great value IMO!

[1] actually, like many high-end pans, it uses a 3-ply construction with an aluminium layer between two steel layers

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by adrianN on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:23AM (#34078065)
Nonstick pans are not meant for searing steaks. They're meant for making things like creamy scrambled eggs that are difficult to get right on cast iron.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by SOLAR_FIELDS on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:12AM (#34077284)
Ceramic cookware is also PFA free, and while it isn’t 100% as good as Teflon for nonstick purposes, it’s about 95% as good for roughly the same price.

It’s not all that much convenience you give up anyway. My home is PFA free for cookware (indoors, at least) simply by virtue of owning birds because PFA is toxic to birds. I have to use the pressure cooker and air fryer outside but the ceramic pans I use indoors do just fine and aren’t too much harder to clean vs Teflon pans.

I think the only noticeable pain where my ceramic pans clearly lose to Teflon is eggs - eggs want to cling to basically anything and Teflon is just really good at not having things cling to it. Otherwise it’s almost always just as easy to clean the ceramic pans as it is to clean the Teflon ones.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by p1necone on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:43AM (#34077114)
> A globally coordinated reduction in production only increases the price of products for consumers.

Which is great. Higher prices = less usage.

We don't have to eradicate them entirely before we see any benefit.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by missedthecue on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:10AM (#34077579)
It depends on demand elasticity. Products with very little demand elasticity like energy or medicine just make everyone miserable and worse off when production is cut, because you can't live without them. Yes you can scrimp and save and stretch your dollar, but at the end of the day you have to pay up no matter the price.

I'm not sure that anyone knows what the demand elasticity for an industrial chemical like PFAS is, but it's obviously not a completely discretionary item.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by adrianN on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:19AM (#34078031)
Energy has a lot of demand elasticity, it just takes a few years for demand to catch up with price changes. See for example how fuel efficiency changed during the oil crisis a few decades ago. Or how building insulation changes with rising energy prices.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @08:53AM (#34080733)
>Which is great. Higher prices = less usage.

Don't lie to us by not mentioning the tradeoffs.

Reduced standards of living = less spare f-s to give about abstract big picture issues.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by triceratops on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:32AM (#34082831)
Who knows? Maybe better health = more spare f-s to give about abstract big picture issues.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by megablast on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:52AM (#34077165)
Good. People buy less of them then.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by rngname22 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @03:14PM (#34085818)
The better alternative is for humans to suffer from not having good water-repellant substances but in the process avoid polluting the world.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by themitigating on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:28AM (#34077030)
Just to chime in about your use of the word "signaling" and when others use "virtue signaling".

I believe the traditional term is "setting a good example" and even if the motivation is selfish there's a positive outcome. "Virtue signaling" was invented to demonize this behavior by focusing on (the assumed) motive as selfish.

Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by concordDance on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:12AM (#34078351)
The term "virtue signalling" is supposed to only apply to cases where the act being done isn't actually much help.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by vouaobrasil on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:57AM (#34080112)
Good point. Yes, "setting a good example" is a better term, so it's not confused with virtue signalling.
Re:3M to end 'forever chemicals' output at cost of up to $2.3B by triceratops on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:34AM (#34082872)
The use of the phrase "virtue signaling" tells me immediately that the rest of the comment has absolutely no value whatsoever and can be safely ignored.