News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is forced treatment for the mentally ill ever humane? by runnerup on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:55PM (#34072402)
That won’t help. There’s hundreds of thousands (nearing or exceeding a million) people like this in the USA alone. If that worked, it would be widely practiced.

These mental illnesses break the ability of an individual to choose to do what’s best in terms of medication, treatment, and lifestyle. The illness makes one not want to be properly medicated.

Someone can be consistent with their treatment and lifestyle for many months, but it just takes one trigger and a couple days off medications to lose all progress.

Re:Is forced treatment for the mentally ill ever humane? by kdmccormick on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:09PM (#34072599)
> That won’t help.

While I agree with the rest of your comment, I want to gently challenge this specific statement, as someone who has to take a powerful med (lithium) to avoid relapsing into mania with psychosis.

I was so extremely reluctant to regularly take meds, and lapsed in and out of mania for a few years. The main thing that got me to stick with lithium, and a major driver in me staying on them today, is grokking how deeply destructive mania is to all the relationships and other good things in my life.

I'm not saying we should shame mentally ill people, but part of treatment should be helping them understand & agree that permanent treatment is in their own best interest. Easier said than done, of course... it took years for me.

Re:Is forced treatment for the mentally ill ever humane? by abracadaniel on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:57PM (#34076463)
Thank you for sharing these insights. The whole problem space feels so intractable, and all options seemingly inhumane in their own ways, so it’s very helpful to hear from someone whose had success working though it.
Re:Is forced treatment for the mentally ill ever humane? by guerrilla on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:11PM (#34072636)
> The illness makes one not want to be properly medicated.

The medications do that too. The side-effects are horrific.