News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by coreyp_1 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:51PM (#34070450)
As a first step, let's stop calling them "porch pirates".

Call them a "thief".

And, yes, some thief stole something from my porch 2 weeks ago. I asked Amazon to deliver it on a Thursday when I knew I would be home to get the package. It was delivered on Monday instead. Guess who wasn't home to get the package? Yes, I got a refund, which I'm thankful for, but it was still a huge inconvenience for me and it took money out of someone's pocket!

Thief. Not a "porch pirate". Thief.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by WalterBright on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:25PM (#34071069)
I've discovered that when people brag about stealing, they get upset when I just say they're thieves. They prefer to think of themselves as pirates or rebels or some other word that has some cachet.

The same goes for stealing. They'll call it justice, or liberating, getting paid, payback, whatever. They don't like the word "stealing".

Usually, they'll stop bragging to me about thieving and stealing after that.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by bombcar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:53PM (#34070495)
But porch pirate sounds so alliteratively fun!

What's annoying is that Amazon has started delivering with their own companies; it is relatively easy to tell UPS/FedEx/USPS to mark your address as "always signature/handoff required" and they'll not deliver if they can't contact you - the smaller companies are hit and miss.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by khazhoux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:06PM (#34070714)
> Thief. Not a "porch pirate". Thief.

No one has ever argued it's not blatant theft. "Porch pirate" adds precision missing from the general term "thief." I immediately knew what this article was about just from the title.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by p1mrx on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:09PM (#34070790)
"Package thief" is similarly precise.
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by khazhoux on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:16PM (#34070902)
The UPS worker that takes my package could steal it. The warehouse worker could steal it, or the delivery driver.

"Porch" indicates exactly the form of theft: unattended packages in front of people's residence.

I'm really confused why the term is bothering people?

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by p1mrx on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:23PM (#34071028)
Probably because "pirate" has many neutral/positive connotations, including swordfighting and sharing movies.
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by jollyllama on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:21PM (#34070997)
Ok, how about "porch thieves?"
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by WarOnPrivacy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:34PM (#34072122)
> Ok, how about "porch thieves?"

"Detroit woman says her ENTIRE front porch was stolen right off her house"

ref: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9207915/Woman-Detro...

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by WarOnPrivacy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:37PM (#34072158)
> I'm really confused why the term is bothering people?

I think it's adjacent to "Stop Liking What I Don't Like". Maybe like: 'Stop Not-Demonizing What Makes Me Angry'.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by coreyp_1 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:53PM (#34073973)
The term "pirate" has lost meaning and most negative connotation that once accompanied the word.

There are still modern day pirates on water, but that is not what comes to mind to most people when they hear the term pirate.

Today, people think of the antihero, from Jack Sparrow to Long John Silver (Treasure Island, or the restaurant, your pick). They are fun and engaging, clever and witty. They are fighting back against an unjust government. They are even likable, even when they aren't "good" (Captain Hook of Peter Pan).

In addition, the term pirate is often used for copying software or something else digital. It, however, is a victimless crime, in that nothing is actually "taken" from anyone, it is merely that additional money is not given from the pirate to the copyright holder.

Your cute niece and nephew dress up like pirates. Pirates have buried treasure for us to find (so they actually benefit someone, so to speak). They are the very definition of adventure!

This is different. These are not people engaging in a victimless crime. These are not people fighting an unjust cause. These are not just people having fun. These are thieves. Public perception is one way to fight them, so I encourage people not to call them "porch pirates". They are thieves. They may be thieves who steal packages from porches, but they are undoubtedly still a thief. I don't care if you call them blue-hatted, striped-sock, ding-dong-ditch, grinch flunkie thieves, so long as you identify the crime for which they should be rightly ashamed and castigated. They are a thief.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by flandish on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:59PM (#34071624)
> precision

No. It does not. “Pirate” brings with it a “disney like” connotation of someone all nimbly bimbly just living a pirate’s life…

A thief, which is what these people are, is the proper term.

The use of “porch pirate” brings in the clicks, though…

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by tedunangst on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:57PM (#34070563)
What do you think pirates do?
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by mc32 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:03PM (#34070683)
It's a costume people wear on Halloween and a mascot for some professional sports teams. People don't associate them with high seas cut-throat pirates with poor hygiene.
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by WalterBright on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:28PM (#34071117)
Pirates are romantic figures in popular culture. Think of all the pirate movies. And International Talk Like A Pirate Day.

There is no International Thief Day.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by at_a_remove on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:04PM (#34070689)
I think we all understand what pirates did, historically, and the relevance now. You know it, I know it, the poster knows it. Pirates stole. Also pillage, murder, and rape, but that hardly fits the Disney model nor does that concern us now.

The poster is objecting to the cutesy alliterative framing of theft as "haha, porch pirates gotchya!" Porch pirate sounds much more innocuous than "Someone stole from my property."

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by serverholic on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:02PM (#34070663)
We have a tendency in our culture to soften words.

Thief has more emotional impact than “porch pirate”.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by happytoexplain on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:06PM (#34070711)
I agree that "pirate" isn't an appropriate word in this case (though "porch pirate" is very specific and brief, at least), but I would say that we have a tendency in our culture (perhaps all cultures) to bend words in any direction based on our biases, whether that means making them softer or harsher.
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by serverholic on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @03:29PM (#34072049)
I would agree with that.

For example some people want to redefine rape to include sex you regret, and violence to include saying naughty things.

Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by itsyaboi on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:02PM (#34070658)
Sing cute shanties and engage in cheeky hijinks, if we completely ignore the parent comment.
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by rufus_foreman on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:47PM (#34076099)
Watch sports for free?
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by NaturalPhallacy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:05PM (#34070709)
I think "porch pirate" is just a subset of thief. It's not a lesser crime, just one that's just more specific.
Re:‘Porch pirates’ stole an estimated 260M packages in 2021 by lost_tourist on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:22PM (#34071009)
nah matey, I'm still calling them porch pirates, and I'll still send videos of them in.