News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by foofoo4u on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:46PM (#34069395)
There must be something from the past we can learn from. The Salem witch trials come to mind. The Puritans in their towns believed witches to be real. That they existed among them. That they were evil and harmful to their well being. This lead members to believe sightings of behavior to be witchery. But most concerning is the social mechanisms you describe. Where the risk of ostracization outweighed truth. Why risk questioning the claim of a witch when it can cost you your life? The panic grows and eventually takes hold of the town. Everyone is complicit in the behavior, regardless if everyone actually believes it or not.

This story is not unique. We've seen it in WWII Germany and communist regimes around thew world. This language list by Stanford is just a modern reincarnation of the same thing. The language list isn't actually about making people feel safer. It's a means of power and control.

The founding fathers of the United States were well aware of this human behavior. The freedom of speech. The presumption of innocence. Right to a jury. Right to privacy. Are all principles enshrined into law to serve as a countermeasure to our proclivities of mob rule and hysteria. These are all effective. But we now live in an age of social media. Mob rule has returned. But it's now all virtual. Do we need to formulate a new list of rights to counteract virtual mob rule?

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by taolegal on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:09PM (#34070795)
The problem is that the people who think they're so sophisticated and evolved, are, in truth, the same exact people who'd have been a part of the clerisy in the past. Like you said, leading the charge to drown some witches. Where even denial is taken as evidence of guilt.

The people leading this charge into soviet-style language policing, demonization of dissent and scapegoating (in the name of progress) are unfortunately the people who are also totally divorced from self-doubt. There is no inward self-examination aside from the completely fake Ibram X. Kendi/Robin DiAngelo-style quasi-religious original sin-like liberal guilt.