News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by umanwizard on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:35PM (#34040957)
“You guys” is the plural form of “you” for most speakers of colloquial American English, and is completely ungendered, in an empirical sense: if you observe native speakers speaking naturally and colloquially, you will find that everyone who uses it (regardless of gender) uses it consistently to address groups of multiple people (regardless of gender).

It’s derived from the noun “guys”, which is indeed often gendered. But etymology doesn’t determine meaning. Otherwise we would have to conclude that “woman” is male-gendered because it etymologically derives from “man”.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by JimTheMan on Sunday December 18, 2022 @06:00PM (#34045099)
I was thinking about this the other day.

You can approach a group of women and say " hey guys", that is fine.

To a group of men," hey gals", and that is not fine.

"Hey guys" to a mixed group, why... You've now 'elevated' the women to men so everyone is ok with it.

It all implies that being a woman is somehow lesser. And so that is why I'm going to stick to everyone or folks.

Although I don't begrudge or ask anyone to change.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by umanwizard on Sunday December 18, 2022 @06:13PM (#34045294)
Your argument is dubious for two reasons:

1. You assume that “guys” is the male equivalent of “gals”. It’s not — the latter is much more strongly gendered. Your argument is circular, because you assume that “guys” is gendered as one of your axioms.

2. You are talking about “hey guys”, whereas I was talking about “you guys”. The whole point of my post was that you can’t understand the meaning of “you guys” simply by referencing the meaning of “guys”. They are completely different words, and their only relationship is historical, even though one is a substring of the other. Even if “hey guys” is mildly gendered (which I’m not sure of, but I’m at least willing to believe it’s possible), “you guys” absolutely isn’t, empirically.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by JimTheMan on Sunday December 18, 2022 @10:06PM (#34047891)
You guys is a gendered term and a perfectly reasonable axiom.

And because it's used by everyone, I submit this is true in the court of public opinion.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by umanwizard on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:53AM (#34050300)
I have to admit I don’t understand your point or what you’re trying to say.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by DiggyJohnson on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:16AM (#34062243)
If you’re not being sarcastic, “you guys” is never (and I know how strong that word is) gendered. It’s literally a synonym for “you all”, ‘y’all’, or ‘you’ (plural).

Are you a native speaker? I’m genuinely curious because I can’t imagine this not seeming ubiquitous to a person that’s grown up in American English.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by exodust on Monday December 19, 2022 @11:44PM (#34061648)
> "You've now 'elevated' the women to men"

No elevation is happening. There is only inclusion and gathering together all members of the group regardless of gender. "Guys" performs this function effortlessly, without harm.

Gals always = girls. Guys does not always equal boys. That's language at work, an evolution which shouldn't be policed by language activists, instructing us what words are permitted.

If "leader" is part of the origin of "guy", that makes it even more suitable to gender neutral use in modern times. It's healthy when language is allowed to evolve and operate in varying contexts. Gatekeeping and policing words is to create problems and tension.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hedora on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:18AM (#34062257)
Traditional English has three genders: Male, Female, ???:

He/she/it They/they/they Guys/gals/guys

(Unfortunately, incorrectly using "it" to refer to a human is considered derogatory. All the other cells I listed were considered fine 20-30 years ago, and generally still are.)

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by sethammons on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:48AM (#34064157)
"It"? I don't think so. It is "they".

> I could not see the person; [he,she,they, not "it"] were hidden in shadow.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by xigoi on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:08AM (#34063887)
I have a friend who always says “hi women” when meeting up with our group, no matter the genders of the people present. Nobody is getting offended.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by rmak on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:57AM (#34064684)
so what should we use instead of the word "mother nature"? This implies fathers as lesser people, right?
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by malcolmgreaves on Monday December 19, 2022 @11:08PM (#34061426)
Out of all of these, y’all rolls most readily off the tongue.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by hedora on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:13AM (#34062218)
Yes, but if you use "y'all" it either means that you don't think southerners are idiots, or that you are ironically acting like you don't think they are idiots.

Even the wokest wokes have their limits.

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by malcolmgreaves on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @05:42PM (#34073822)
Well, that’s a completely unprompted comment…
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by umanwizard on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:43AM (#34064577)
That’s entirely subjective.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by kaesar14 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:47PM (#34070375)
Sounds extremely southern to me. Not in a pejorative way, but in a way that seems really odd when said by a Northeastern US English speaker.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by chrisallenlane on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:45PM (#34071396)
Southerner here. The correct form is "all a y'alls."
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by slavik81 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:25AM (#34061894)
> etymology doesn’t determine meaning. Otherwise we would have to conclude that “woman” is male-gendered because it etymologically derives from “man”.

Man was not gendered when "woman" originated. In Old English, the words for men and women were "wer" and "wif", while "mann" described any person. Over time, wifmann became woman, and for whatever reason, wermann didn't end up becoming a word.

Other examples of trouble through etymology might include "virtue" and "world", which both derive from "wer".

Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by lstodd on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:47AM (#34062041)
How very interesting. Thank you.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by HideousKojima on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:04AM (#34063439)
Wer did survive in the word "werewolf" as well.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by umanwizard on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @06:42AM (#34064569)
Okay, but my point still stands. If etymology determined meaning we’d have to conclude that “man” is ungendered, which is clearly wrong.
Re:Stanford's “Elimination of Harmful Language” Initiative by eru on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:26AM (#34061902)
Guy refers to Guy Fawkes. I'm not sure why his gender is supposed to have stuck, but not eg his religion or politics?