News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by pifm_guy on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:35PM (#34040030)
We also have a lot of data on ways to reduce cancer before it happens. Reduce obesity. Reduce pollution. Etc.

Yet we really aren't doing an awful lot about those things.

Imagine for example if we had an obesity tax - everyone obese must pay 30% of their earnings into a Medicare fund. Sure it would be unpopular, but obesity would very quickly be solved, and cancer rates would plummet.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by hombre_fatal on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:44PM (#34040123)
That will probably do nothing for obesity rates except fleece obese people. I’d be more interested in seeing appetite drugs like semaglutide become cheap and easy to get, something that helps instead of buying into punitive measures for absolutely everything.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by fuzzfactor on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:26PM (#34042775)
Exactly. There needs to be a reward system for healthy initiatives, not a punitive approach for unsuccessful accomplishments.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by copperx on Sunday December 18, 2022 @07:14PM (#34046243)
It's ironic that you mention semaglutide, because it causes cancer.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by DoreenMichele on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:48PM (#34040158)
Those approaches -- reducing pollution, etc -- aren't popular in part because humans are terrible about not knowing how to count the deaths that didn't happen.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by jodrellblank on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:50PM (#34040177)
> "Imagine for example if we had an obesity tax - everyone obese must pay 30% of their earnings into a Medicare fund."

Imagine for example if we taxed the shareholders of CocaCola instead, they're the ones who got wealthy from obesity. And before you say "it was the consumer's choice", what was CocaCola's $4b/year advertising spend for, then?

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by pifm_guy on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:41PM (#34042013)
I'd totally be up for fining companies retrospectively for harming people's health even before the harm was well understood.

That gives the companies an incentive to do the research ahead of time to minimize damages.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by cj on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:59PM (#34042268)
“Fine company” will just turn into higher costs for consumers.

If raising the price of Coke is the goal, I believe there are already proposals for a sugar tax in various jurisdictions.

Let’s tax the hell out of processed foods so they become at least on par with the price of healthy food.

It’s very tricky since taxes like that will hurt low income households the most.

Another option: ban advertising of heavily processed food, and while we’re at it let’s also ban advertising prescription drugs (as is the case already in Canada)

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by rightbyte on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:08PM (#34042435)
> Let’s tax the hell out of processed foods so they become at least on par with the price of healthy food.

Isn't processed food already more expensive than "healthy"? E.g. precut fries vs potatoes. Etc.

What is cheaper to buy processed?

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by cj on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:45PM (#34044807)
Honestly you may be right.

But walking into a typical US grocery store feels like a place where cheap, quick, processed foods are the focus with healthy food being secondary (perhaps because they’re optimizing their store layouts in response to consumer demand for sh*t food). Rarely is healthy food promoted on isle endcaps.

I do 100% of my day to day shopping at a (very expensive) health food store for this sole reason. At the health food store, they don’t stock soda, chips, etc (or if they do it’s locally made, organic, etc… “healthy” junk food). You can’t buy things like Oreos or Coke because they simply don’t carry it.

For me, removing unhealthy options when grocery shopping led to 40+ lbs of weight loss - with no other lifestyle changes and no additional exercise over 2 years.

When I make the occasional visit to a normal grocery store, I’m always in awe at how much real estate “bad” food gets. It’s the majority of the store.

All of this is to say, another place to look at are grocery stores themselves and the food they decide to carry and promote in their stores, including the layout of the stores, % real estate given to crap food vs. healthy food, etc.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by 082349872349872 on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:52AM (#34048951)
IIUC aisle endcap contents are determined by vendors, not the typical store; it's "pay to position".
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by LawTalkingGuy on Monday December 19, 2022 @12:43PM (#34054988)
Damage during shipping and easier handling.

Processing is a chance to use seconds - damaged or ugly potatoes that nobody would buy, and it packs more product into less space and with an easier storage mechanism (freeze) than properly packing to keep it fresh. Employees can throw boxes of frozen food onto a belt where they have to gently place boxes of fresh food.

Even with a well run shipping company and no problems you'll have a fair bit of spoilage and it means that every box is at risk of full rot (a bad apple...) and needs a human to sort through and pull it out. There are buyers of last resort at every stage of the journey who will take freshly damaged produce for immediate usage but they're often soup kitchens who can barely afford to pay.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by RazvanS on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:51PM (#34040186)
Obesity is caused by lack of access to quality food, being too scarce or too expensive. Sugar and fats are cheap, so most of the pre-made foods are just that. So increase the quality of the food available to the masses and do proper education regarding nutrition and healthy living, and the obesity rate will decrease.

Most of the obese people are like that not because they choose, but because they cannot do better.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by DeWilde on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:32PM (#34040899)
In some cases yes, but hardly in all cases.

Anecdotally, I know people with the same wealth as me or even wealthier who eat copious amounts of sweets in all forms and are also obese. Some people just don't have control.

But yes, proper education regarding nutrition is something that is sorely needed as most people are unaware of the dangers of eating sugar rich and calorie rich foods in large amounts.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by philliphaydon on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:58PM (#34040285)
There is nothing wrong with fat.

People were cooking with lard for 1000s of years until the US decided fat is bad and people started substituting fat with sugar because when you remove fat, you remove flavour.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by Retric on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:07PM (#34040438)
Don’t forget people also died much earlier for thousands of years.

There is a great deal wrong with very high fat diets, the issue is there’s also a lot wrong with very high carb diets.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by philliphaydon on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:14PM (#34040595)
> Don’t forget people also died much earlier for thousands of years.

Funnily enough not from obesity or heart disease.

They died from violence, starvation, infections, plagues, travel, etc.

Fats were not a cause.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by shanebellone on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:44PM (#34042053)
This is a ridiculous point. If you halved today's average lifespan, you'd see a dramatic reduction in cancer.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by philliphaydon on Sunday December 18, 2022 @07:01PM (#34046079)
> If you halved today's average lifespan, you'd see a dramatic reduction in cancer.

Not sure where the comment I’m replying to, and onwards, ever mentions cancer.

Lol

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by Retric on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:25PM (#34042755)
Do some actual research. People regularly got heart attacks throughout recorded history even if dying earlier from other things was common.

The history of coronary syndromes and sudden death, and apoplexy or stroke, goes back to antiquity and has been thoroughly treated by historians and experts from many disciplines. By the beginning of the twentieth century, a heart attack with myocardial infarction was well known to cause death, but comprehension of it as a syndrome that one might survive was much delayed.

…

Part of the historical delay and confusion in recognizing heart attacks apparently lay in the Greek word, kardialgia, which could mean either abdominal or precordial pain. Biblical and Talmudic references abound, however, about chest pain of a life-threatening nature, and Hippocrates mentions sudden death related to an episode of chest distress (Leibowitz 1970).

Leibowitz points out that the great Italian anatomist Morgagni failed to tie it all together, but nevertheless clearly described in 1761 the late pathology found in survivors of myocardial infarction in his well-known dictum: “The force of the heart decreases so much more in proportion as the greater number of its parts becomes tendonous instead of being fleshy” (ibid., 4). http://www.epi.umn.edu/cvdepi/essay/history-of-heart-attack-...

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by philliphaydon on Sunday December 18, 2022 @07:19PM (#34046316)
People have been dying for 1000s of years for things we are still dying from now. But heart disease was not a leading cause of death.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by Retric on Sunday December 18, 2022 @08:11PM (#34046867)
It was a leading cause of death for the same age range it’s a leading cause of death now.

Saying it was or wasn’t a leading cause of death overall is quite arbitrary, though it was at a minimum a common cause of death back then.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by anon291 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:44PM (#34043076)
No they didn't. Death rates from now treatable diseases were higher in the past. But if you managed to escape those and not die in a tragic physical accident, you lived basically as long as anyone else.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by Retric on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:07PM (#34043397)
Go back 1,000+ years and people did occasionally live to be say 70, the difference was they where also less likely to live to be 71. And at 71 they where less likely to live to be 72 etc.

Given a large enough population you would still see very very rare cases of extreme age but you are something like 1,000 times more likely to live to 115 today than you where back in 1,000 AD. Combined with a smaller population and it’s likely nobody live to 115 until quite recently.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by scriptproof on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:02PM (#34040355)
You are surely aware of the campaign "Eat Five Servings of Fruits & Vegetables Per Day". People just don't care.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by adamredwoods on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:17PM (#34040643)
I know we want to believe it was somehow a blame or fault of someone who develops cancer. The reality is I've seen unhealthy people never get cancer and healthy people, children even, who get cancer.

No one is to blame for getting cancer.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by pifm_guy on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:34PM (#34041906)
Many of those cancers might be caused by pollution... For example, UV in sunlight is thought to be the main cause of skin cancer. UV is far higher today than 100 years ago because we destroyed most of the ozone layer. But we don't actually know how thick the ozone layer used to be or how much UV used to reach ground level because we never measured it before destroying it. So possibly skin cancer was very rare 100 years ago.

The same for cancer's from nitrous oxides from car exhausts. The same for particulate pollution. Same for microplastics. The same for all the kinds of pollution we don't yet know about or measure.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by jghn on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:08PM (#34042425)
You're conflating trends within aggregated data and individual data points. Moving towards a healthier population would reduce cancer rates across the total population. It would not remove cancer entirely. Likewise any arbitrary person might be in complete health & get cancer and vice versa as you say. The two are not contradictory.

A similar example is with early detection. The data show that at population scale a lot of early detection efforts cause more harm than good. The problem is that any arbitrary person might have their life saved by said early detection. It's impossible to know who those arbitrary people will be.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by nickd2001 on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:19AM (#34050483)
Well, possibly polluters are to blame? Amongst developed countries, seems like USA stands out as having had a pretty cavalier attitude for decades about polluting land and water with carcinogens, allowing all sorts of cr*p in food etc. The reactive attitude "we'll permit this chemical until we run into any problems with it". vs the EU's "this chemical is suspect , so banned until we find clear evidence that it isn't dangerous". Of course EU not perfect either, plenty of scare stories in other places too. But the attitude in the USA baffles me, why isn't there more public pressure to reduce exposure to dangerous chemicals. is it just people are uniformed, or they think lets just dump it in a poor area or something.... ?
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by mozman on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:38PM (#34041011)
What about a tax where you pay 30% of your earnings for homeless?
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by FpUser on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:41PM (#34041077)
Imagine if we had an idiot tax. Suddenly all world problems would go away.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by rafaelero on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:57PM (#34041331)
It's crazy how we are still not screening everyone for genetic susceptability to diseases and pairing them together with good early detection tests. A lot of missed opportunities here to decrease so much suffering.
Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by melling on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:16PM (#34041640)
Interesting enough, the person on Twitter seems fit and not very old.

15 years ago Randy Pausch was also fit a year before he died.

So, instead of blaming people for poor choices imagine if 16 years ago, when the US National Debt was a mere $9 trillion, if enough people were inspired that on our way to $31 trillion in debt, we spent a few trillion of that on cancer research.

Re:Mark Stokes: I’ve been battling cancer last 2 years only ... by vorpalhex on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:10PM (#34042455)
That would overwhelmingly be a tax on the poor and low income. It would probably not fix obesity anymore than taxing cancer patients would fix cancer.