>Keep in mind that none of this was "doxxing". It's publicly available information what Elon's plane is and where it's flying

99% of a dox is taking public information from obscure sources and making it easily accessible in one place. Doxxing can be sharing public information about someone without their permission. Being public doesn't make it not doxxing.

The information shared was not from an obscure source nor was it from a site that wasn’t easily accessible. It was the mirroring of 1 piece of information from 1 location to another location.

White pages are a single Google search away.

If it's public it can be googled, and if it can be googled it's not obscure.

Argument is invalid.

This is absolutely not doxxing.

So if I used publicly available information (property tax records, court records, vehicle registration records, whatever) to post Brian K. White's home address, it "wouldn't be doxxing"?

Pull the other one.

Correct.

Yeah, no.

Pretty much every platform (including Twitter) considers that to be doxxing.

You don't get to make up your own definitions for words.

Public data is public, but actions are a different story.

https://photos.app.goo.gl/Uxwbo7bhebMnLrpn8

(for the bystanders: there is no included letter or note, just this unsolicited package with no explaination and no known-to-me sender)

This conversation: 12-18

Sent: 12-18

Origin: anonymous fulfillment service

https://branchwarehousing.com/

So you have uncovered some never-was-covered public data from my full-real-name-middle-initial-and-all handle, and proved that some people out there are willing to mis-use public data, and that you are one of them, and I am not.

Strange point to want to make.

I wonder if HN has any sort of official stance on that sort of action @dang ?

Do you really agree that making the public location of Elon's plane more public and easily accessible is doxxing though? I get it if it was the real time location of Elon within 100 meters, or his personal house in a forum with the intention to do harm or something, but the location of a plane that narrows your location down to a city and requires government grade anti air missiles to realistically expect to take down while in flight? The increased security risk of the latter seems like a rounding error to me, which makes the justification for removal very suspect because the thing it does dramatically increase is the public knowledge of how much of a climate hypocrite the guy is flying as much as he does.

Yes, I definitely consider it doxxing. Whether doxxing someone should be allowed is another question and twitter for years has decided that doxxing is against the rules and doxxers typically get shadow banned.

> Keep in mind that none of this was "doxxing". It's publicly available information

I keep seeing this.

Property tax information and license plate information are also "publicly available" in most areas.

That doesn't make posting someone's home address, or the make, model, and plate number of their car somehow "not doxxing".