News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by danilocampos on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:19PM (#3401850)
Hmm.

You know what? Your position, on paper, makes a lot of sense.

At the same time, there are times where you say "eh, fuck it."

And this, for me, is one of them.

Assume we live in a world where those who have power exist in a sphere of privilege. They enjoy protections from the consequences of their actions. Their influence and connections exempt them from the standard costs of citizenship.

If that's the case, if these people exist outside of due process, what's left?

This, I guess.

There are lot of communications in this bundle that are probably pretty mundane, sent and received by people who show up for jury duty and take traffic school when they run a red light. And it sucks that they've lost their privacy on this.

On the other hand, because of Strafor's mission, you can be almost certain that a handful of messages will reveal information where disclosing it is emphatically a public good. Will we find wrongdoing? Downright illegality? I'm not sure.

But I am pretty sure that actions like this are the last reasonably potent check on power we have left.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by devs1010 on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @08:25PM (#3402178)
Agreed. Over the last 10 years, arguably much longer, if you take into account the "war" on drugs, the US government has begun to, in some aspects, wage war on its own citizens. The power grabs by politicians and law enforcement nowadays is reaching insane levels to the point where I am not confident that we live in a fully "free" country anymore and to where I think that people doing things like this could be one of the only defenses against our country going even further down the shitter. Just as our government is fine with killing plenty of innocent people in a variety of ways (non-militants killed in wars, overzealous law enforcement, people executed that are later exonerated) I am fine with some innocent "casualties" when citizens fight back, which in this case is the loss of privacy for some of the people who sent these emails.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by DanBC on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @08:37PM (#3402199)
Kismet and nmap protected by the 2nd amendment?
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by eternalban on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @11:12PM (#3402476)
> At the same time, there are times where you say "eh, fuck it."

Cognitive dissonance overload!

"Anonymous"/"99%"/TPTB_NOT is correct (imo) in criticizing the TPTB's theory of 'suspended norms/ethos due to emergency' e.g. get ready to be groped by a uniformed servant from the margines. Good times.

Now we have supporters of anon/99/we-the-people's position asserting that the philosophy of "what is Right is what is convenient'/'end justifies the means' is in fact acceptable.

USA is saying "eh, fuck it" when it kidnaps, tortures, rapes (abu ..), terrorizes (same place), and holds in contempt (fuck it) the said "it": Our aspirations, our principles, our heritage, and our "fucking" way of life.

Simply based on that ideological finger print, I would certainly entertain the view that holds these groups and their shenanigans to be entirely the work of TPTB.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by shadowfiend on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @11:54PM (#3402568)
In a democracy, people don't get re-elected when they're shown to be crooks in such a huge way that it's impossible to ignore. We already know, to some extent, how crook-y some of these people are. In particular, we know how easily they assault our civil liberties, or perhaps better stated our right to privacy. If assaulting theirs is how we convince the masses that they should not be there, then it is perhaps reasonable to do so. Ours are already under fire, the question is whether destroying theirs will produce a big enough result to make it worth it. I don't think the answer is clear-cut in general, and time will tell in this case, but I don't know that it's as cognitively dissonant as it seems.

In the case of the government, they can't say “well we're watching everyone's conversations because so are the terrorists”. That makes their justification very different from the one in use here, and thus changes the equation a lot.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by eternalban on Thursday December 29, 2011 @12:24AM (#3402641)
There are dragon slayers and there are also those who tilt at windmills. I'll be a believer the day that Anonymous/Lulzie-ones core dump the archives of The City of London.

Slaying that dragon is a game changer; effectively random acts of cyber anarchy and antisocial behavior (people's CCs, for ex.) just raise dust and TPTB love occultation and delight in the demonstration of the emptiness of our "convictions" and "principles".

Have you ever considered that this is an intellectual/spiritual battle between a subset asserting superiority in every dimension of human endeavor that (literally) justifies their rule? If yes, then mind your "principles" and "convictions". That is the Human Front. Hold the line, please.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by mberning on Thursday December 29, 2011 @12:21AM (#3402636)
You must have a fundamental misunderstanding of what cognitive dissonance is.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by jonhendry on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:24PM (#3401863)
"On the other hand, because of Strafor's mission"

The dissemination of information? What's wrong with that?

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by stfu on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @09:13PM (#3402268)
I still don't get what was wrong with Stratefor. I subscribed to their newsletter a long time ago and the content was somewhat on the Foreign Affairs magazine level.

Sure, some military and secret service personal were among the subscribers, but they are most likely among the subscribers of the Wired magazine as well. I am truly looking forward to the email leak and what kind of secret in formations they are able to reveal.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by danilocampos on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @09:47PM (#3402343)
I mean, there's nothing wrong with Stratfor. It's just the business they're in means that the clients who engage them for one-off analysis jobs are often into some pretty... globally interesting things.

Think of it like this.

Say that, one day, all the pigs in town just disappear. Gone.

And everyone's like, "Hey. Where are all the pigs? This is crazy. Hey, Danilo, do you know where the pigs went?"

"Me? Uh, no."

But a few years later, the town librarian has all his emails leaked. And included among this is a brief exchange, a week before The Pig Event, wherein I ask "So, librarian, any advice on books for transporting livestock? Oh, could you set aside Pigs for Dummies for me?"

This message is now... pretty interesting.

Does it prove I'm a pig thief? Not necessarily, unless I get into more detail in other messages. It does suggest, though, that I might have known more than I did when the event happened. And that it's worth digging around for links between me and the pigs.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by doktrin on Thursday December 29, 2011 @01:35AM (#3402781)
Stratfor was essentially labeled as a form of collateral damage. The self-described Anon spokesperson basically said they weren't one of the "offenders" but were "of interest".

I don't feel sold on the merits of going after Stratfor - it's almost as if it was merely a convenient and vulnerable target. It's not too hard to envision just about any company or organization being targeted because of some vague affiliation or "interest".

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by grandalf on Thursday December 29, 2011 @02:16PM (#3404897)
Stratfor is an organization (similar in a way to wikileaks) that offers private individuals the option of buying intelligence analysis. I used to be a subscriber.

How does stratfor get this intel to share with its clients? By tips provided by trusted sources in government. These people would probably lose their jobs if it was found out that they shared info with stratfor.

I would not be surprised if the USG infiltrated anonymous and did this attack as part of a campaign against whistleblowers.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by danilocampos on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:32PM (#3401886)
> The dissemination of information? What's wrong with that?

...Nothing at all?

It's a simple matter of the type of information they disseminate. A type of information of particular interest to people with skin in the game of world politics.

That is, a guy on Stratfor's secret client list probably has much more interesting email to read than a guy working at a Radio Shack in Sarasota, Florida.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by jonhendry on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:40PM (#3401904)
"It's a simple matter of the type of information they disseminate. "

And that type of information is? You seem to be one of the people assuming Stratfor is some kind of Blackwater intelligence company. They aren't.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by danilocampos on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:51PM (#3401946)
> And that type of information is? You seem to be one of the people assuming Stratfor is some kind of Blackwater intelligence company. They aren't.

Oh, thanks so much, jonhendry! I really appreciate your filling me in. Reading America's Secret War, by Stratfor's founder, had left me entirely in the dark about their mission and capabilities until this very moment. I stand enlightened.

The fact remains, the sort of person who is emailing high-level folk at Stratfor either knows things or wants to know things of geopolitical importance. A source with a compelling piece of data the public doesn't know about, perhaps. Or a business tycoon with a question that, knowing it was asked, completely invalidates the public narrative that company had spun.

So if your mission is to get access to data about how people are running the world, a great place to start is a private global intelligence firm.

No one is saying they're not allowed to do what they're doing. Only that "trades emails with a private intelligence analysts" is probably going to be a pretty good proxy for "has interesting, secret shit to talk about."

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by jonhendry on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:02PM (#3401972)
"Reading America's Secret War, by Stratfor's founder, had left me entirely in the dark about their mission and capabilities until this very moment. I stand enlightened."

If you read it, what makes you think Dick Cheney would be involved? The book apparently contradicts everything the neocons stood for. Cheney would probably prefer that Stratfor were shut down, so that he could control the flow of information.

"No one is saying they're not allowed to do what they're doing."

Really? People are tossing around the word 'evil', but they should be allowed to keep doing it?

"Only that "trades emails with a private intelligence analysts" is probably going to be a pretty good proxy for "has interesting, secret shit to talk about.""

Ah, so you've gone from justifying it by saying they're evil and up to no good, to justifying it by saying they merely have interesting, secret shit to talk about.

Lots of people have interesting, secret shit to talk about.

So basically it's really just a voyeuristic thing for you and the moralizing is a pose.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by danilocampos on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:06PM (#3401983)
> If you read it, what makes you think Dick Cheney would be involved?

Nothing. Good luck finding anything where I say "Dick Cheney is involved with the operations of Stratfor."

> Ah, so you've gone from justifying it by saying they're evil and up to no good, to justifying it by saying they merely have interesting, secret shit to talk about.

When I say interesting in the context of "how people are running the world," I mean interesting as in "lied to the public about an issue of global importance."

> So basically it's really just a voyeuristic thing for you and the moralizing is a pose.

Nope. I doubt I'm going to read any of what's leaked.

It's just my fervent hope that one of these days a leak can begin to remedy the sorts of injustice that only the well-moneyed and well-connected can perpetrate with impunity. Any entity that needs Stratfor's analysis of global events and decisions seems like a reasonable candidate to deliver an important payload in such a leak.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by jonhendry on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:20PM (#3402010)
" I mean interesting as in "lied to the public about an issue of global importance.""

It's so secret multiple HN readers have said they subscribed. It's so exclusive that anyone can subscribe for a yearly price that is cheaper than cable TV, let alone secret publications like "Science" or "Nature".

You really seem to have the wrong end of the stick here, as in not-clear-on-the-concept of how Stratfor worked.

If you want to know if someone has "lied to the public about an issue of global importance", and think Stratfor holds the answer, you would subscribe to Stratfor and compare what Stratfor reported to what the public figure claimed.

You've bought into some kind of radical left fantasy of what Stratfor does, turning it into the Trilateral Commission or the Bilderbergers.

"Any entity that needs Stratfor's analysis of global events and decisions seems like a reasonable candidate to deliver an important payload in such a leak."

See above about the Bilderbergers.

Say you're a company doing business with Turkey. Not a huge business, but you've got a lot riding on stability in Turkey. Maybe you import rugs. Maybe you do package tours of Istanbul. Maybe you have a team of developers there. Where do you go for good analysis of the situation there, given the history of military takeovers and whatnot?

The newspapers only cover it occasionally, probably too late to do you much good. MSNBC won't cover it at all on a weekend. FOX News would be all "OMG, Turkish Muslims! Threat or Menace?" and be useless. Turkish media might cover it, but not provide good analysis, and you don't know if the coverage is biased there, or if so, how.

So where do you turn? You could read the Economist, but that might not be good enough. Maybe you could buy some reports from the Economist Intelligence Unit, or Jane's. Or you could subscribe to Stratfor, which is probably cheaper.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by danilocampos on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:31PM (#3402044)
> You've bought into some kind of radical left fantasy

And you've gone to the zoo, friend. Almost to the point where I wonder if you're being deliberately obtuse to troll me. (Nice one, if so.)

Two things to note, here.

1. Stratfor has public products and private analysis services.

2. I'm not talking about what they've disclosed publicly.

You could substitute "Stratfor" with "The New York Times Company" in this scenario and I would take the same position. Papers rarely publish all they know, as sometimes it's a better bet to keep quiet on something juicy to avoid burning bridges. Papers are also routinely asked to sit on a story, or bury it outright, as a favor in exchange for access.

A leak of all New York Times emails would probably include a lot of the same sort of content and people I'm imagining in a Stratfor leak. The SNR wouldn't be nearly as favorable, since the Times has a much more public profile and a much broader scope than just global events. Stratfor's specific focus makes it much likelier that any given source, or any given chum of the CEO, has said something via email that could be pretty powerful, were it disclosed. I'd also wager that Stratfor content will be more candid, since it's a smaller world than mass market newspaper publishing.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by forensic on Thursday December 29, 2011 @12:49AM (#3402701)
Nobody important uses the analysis service. Everyone important uses the CIA.

Stratfor serves small and medium sized businesses with global operations.

Huge military-industrial operations like Halliburton get their intelligence from the CIA.

You don't know what Stratfor is. It's a niche news product, nothing more. Like any newspaper, they have secret sources.

But the news product and analysis services offered by Stratfor are extremely benign. Anon is targeting them for no other reason than that Stratfor is a small business who hired a shitty engineering firm with bad security practices.

Any script kiddie can go around finding non-technical businesses with poor security. Stratfor's 70-person staff is peopled entirely by nerdy writers with humanities degrees who spend all day compiling mostly-public information released by the world's parliament buildings and militaries.

Stratfor deals in the analysis of public information for the benefit for private parties. No government agency relies on them, though they may subscribe, Stratfor will not be their primary source.

The people who rely on Stratfor are companies too small and inconsequential to get CIA-access.

Anyway I support the mission of Anonymous to hack the government and hack evil big corporations but Stratfor is not part of that complex and no juicy information is going to come out of this leak. It's going to be extremely mundane stuff and will probably get a few innocent cab drivers in 3rd world countries murdered.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by jessedhillon on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @10:09PM (#3402368)
It's a sad fact of subjectivity that you can, apparently seiously, call out anyone else for trolling. You've run every fallacious argument up the flagpole here. But it's the fault of jonhenry or any rational person for taking this issue up with you, since you admitted squarely in the beginning that your intellectual justification for this is "fuck it."

The only thing preventing my using this line to justify the publication of internal emails between the 5 people who run my competitor is a thin, grey line that you seem to be drawing and redrawing continually. This is an intellectually and morally bankrupt idea you've got here, it hardly suffices for a proper argument as to why this is legitimate action.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by earbitscom on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:22PM (#3401858)
So funny, I feel the same way about things like TPB, and yet I bet you think shutting them down without a trial is immoral.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by danilocampos on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:38PM (#3401902)
> So funny, I feel the same way about things like TPB, and yet I bet you think shutting them down without a trial is immoral.

You feel as though "things like the Pirate Bay" are run by people who are so wealthy and powerful that they've completely subverted criminal justice and international law?

I had no idea Dick Cheney was running torrent sites. The bit where he sent those stooges to sit in a Swedish court was a nice touch, I guess.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by earbitscom on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:40PM (#3401905)
No, I feel "They enjoy protections from the consequences of their actions," and, "if these people exist outside of due process, what's left?"
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by libraryatnight on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:53PM (#3401951)
They enjoy protections provided by operating in a country where their site is legal. They're not operating outside due process.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by jonhendry on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:47PM (#3401927)
If Dick Cheney were running Stratfor, they wouldn't have said that Iraq probably didn't have WMD.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by danilocampos on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @07:00PM (#3401967)
Get off this, dude, no one thinks Dick Cheney's running Stratfor. I bet he has friends on their client list, though.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by forensic on Thursday December 29, 2011 @12:50AM (#3402705)
All of Dick Cheney's friends get their intel from the CIA. Stratfor is small potatoes.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by drewblaisdell on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:51PM (#3401945)
The Pirate Bay does not exist outside of the confines of due process. It exists only because it is transparent and complies totally with Swedish law.

No one is doing TPB any favors. If anything, it gets more negative attention than it (legally) should.

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by JonnieCache on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:31PM (#3401883)
and yet I bet you think

That seems slightly unfair. Unless of course you've performed a comprehensive background check on danilocampos' comment history. But I bet you haven't ;)

Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by earbitscom on Wednesday December 28, 2011 @06:47PM (#3401931)
You're right. That's not cool. But I haven't really run into anyone who thinks we should shut down sites without due process, particularly on HN. Even still, I shouldn't jump to conclusions.
Re:3.3 million e-mails between the most powerful men are abo... by Iv on Thursday December 29, 2011 @07:15AM (#3403417)
That. Protect privacy for everyone or have no privacy for anyone. I'd be happy to have all my emails exposed if I could read Lehman Brother's inboxes.