News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by jdong on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:43AM (#34011374)
How could it not be? Your plane's location data is just as personal as your car's, or your cellphone's. There's no special aircraft exemption in the GDPR.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by kennywinker on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:01AM (#34011537)
A plane is not a person, a phone, a car, or a home. Elon Musk is often the passenger on his jet, but I am quite sure he is often not on board while it moves around.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by jdong on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:03AM (#34011552)
Why would a plane be treated differently than a car in a GDPR context?
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by zimpenfish on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:03PM (#34017018)
> Why would a plane be treated differently than a car in a GDPR context?

A car is generally registered to an individual. A plane isn't.

You could also -maybe- argue that because there's multiple people on the plane (assuming Ol' Muskie isn't flying it himself) and that those people are potentially different every time, without a passenger and crew manifest, it's not identifying individuals (but I suspect you'd not get far with this.)

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by jdong on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:54PM (#34017739)
Planes are very often registered to individuals, and that doesn't even matter! The plane being company owned doesn't magically change anything, what matters is who's being transported and whether or not they will be easily linked to the aircraft.

From a GDPR perspective it also makes no difference whether it's 5% or 90% of planes that are owned by individuals as opposed to by companies.

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by zimpenfish on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:17PM (#34018058)
Do you have some links that support this theory? I'd be interested to read up on it.

edit: Specifically mentioning planes and their locations, I mean, not "extrapolating from cars to planes".

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by jdong on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:27PM (#34018179)
>edit: Specifically mentioning planes and their locations, I mean, not "extrapolating from cars to planes".

You have to be trolling. What leads you to believe that the GDPR which never mentions either aircraft or cars would treat these two kinds of vehicles differently?

Can you find anything in the GDPR texts to suggest that cars and planes would be treated differently?

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by zimpenfish on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:55PM (#34019407)
> the GDPR which never mentions either aircraft or cars

ICO's guide to the UK GDPR does have a specific example of cars being identifiable[1] - "A vehicle’s registration number can be linked to other information held about the registration (eg by the DVLA) to indirectly identify the owner of that vehicle." Nothing about planes though.

[2] covers car registrations and explicitly discounts company owned vehicles from being PII - "The registration plates of commercial vehicles are not personal data of an individual as the vehicle is owned by an organisation."

All of Ol' Muskie's jets are owned by Falcon Landing LLC, a shell company.

[1] https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...

[2] https://sapphireconsulting.co.uk/is-a-car-registration-plate...

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by rosnd on Friday December 16, 2022 @03:06PM (#34019557)
>ICO's guide to the UK GDPR does have a specific example of cars being identifiable[1] - "A vehicle’s registration number can be linked to other information held about the registration (eg by the DVLA) to indirectly identify the owner of that vehicle." Nothing about planes though.

Car registration numbers is a very common kind of data for businesses to handle, of course it makes it on the list of examples.

Same is not true of planes, of course they don't make it on the list of examples.

>[2] covers car registrations and explicitly discounts company owned vehicles from being PII - "The registration plates of commercial vehicles are not personal data of an individual as the vehicle is owned by an organisation."

>All of Ol' Muskie's jets are owned by Falcon Landing LLC, a shell company.

This doesn't work, you can't wash off PII by tying one aspect of it to an organisation. My phone line might belong to a business, but that doesn't give the carrier a free pass to do whatever they want with associated location data.

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by mcv on Friday December 16, 2022 @03:50AM (#34012331)
I think there's something perverse about the very concept of having a personal plane. Perhaps that's the real issue here.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by jdong on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:21AM (#34013302)
> Perhaps that's the real issue here.

I don't see how it could be, that seems like an entirely separate issue.

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by mcv on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:22AM (#34014741)
It's not. If it wasn't his personal plane but a chartered plane or one out of a pool of company planes, this wouldn't be an issue.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by jdong on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:54AM (#34015155)
Who gives a shit about Elon? What the ADS-B data brokers are doing will continue to be illegal even if Elon never steps on a flight again.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by _djo_ on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:25AM (#34015590)
Please provide some evidence of your repeated claim that they're illegal in the US and Europe.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by jdong on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:53AM (#34015955)
As far as I can see, nobody here has made any claims regarding anything being illegal in the US.

> Please provide some evidence of your repeated claim that they're illegal in Europe

https://gdpr-info.eu/

What kind of evidence do you want exactly? This is crystal clear to anyone with the most basic understanding of the GDPR.

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by _djo_ on Saturday December 17, 2022 @08:45AM (#34027678)
That’s not evidence. That’s just your opinion, based on your assumption that private aircraft are like private cars under the law.

Except that they have never been treated equivalently in any legal venue or government regulation.

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by rosnd on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:05AM (#34027830)
Do you have any evidence to share which might suggest that GDPR treats private aircraft differently than ... literally everything else?

If not, why would we just not accept that GDPR treats aircraft exactly how it treats everything else? The law, as written, clearly offers no specific coverage or exemption for any types of vehicles.

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by _djo_ on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:33AM (#34029261)
As the one making the assertion of illegality in terms of the GDPR, the onus is on you to provide a substantive justification for it. Not me.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by rosnd on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:48AM (#34029478)
I've already done that.

You're the one arguing that there's some special exemption for aircraft, but have done nothing to substantiate that claim.

Besides, with the GDPR it works the opposite way. You have to justify why your data processing is legal, not the other way around.

And for fucks sake, neither of Flightradar24 or ADSBExchange even offer a GDPR-compliant privacy policy. ADSBexchange does not offer one at all.

Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by emodendroket on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:46AM (#34015045)
A big reason these jet accounts were popular is people enjoyed calling attention to how wasteful many of the flights were, which I can’t imagine Elon was unaware of.
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by monkpit on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:23AM (#34015564)
There are services you can pay for (in the US) to track a car’s (almost) real-time location without gps. It’s based upon license plates and widespread webcams and it’s not illegal (yet).
Re:Twitter just banned a wave of prominent journalists with ... by jdong on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:52AM (#34015928)