News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by isoprophlex on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:21PM (#33973324)
So, they generated 3.15 MJ energy from the target, at a cost of an input of 2.05 MJ laser light. Pretty exciting.

However those lasers aren't very efficient, generating the 2.05 MJ required more than 300 MJ of electricity.

What is the path forward... Can anyone elaborate? Do we make the lasers 100x more efficient? Will hitting a target with a 100x mass yield 315 MJ?

Edit: thanks everyone for the clarification. Really helps me putting the numbers in context.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by femto113 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @03:19PM (#33975135)
Scaling the NIF's approach (laser inertial confinement) isn't about more reaction mass per pulse, it's about more frequent pulses, and is probably not going to be practical or cost effective in the foreseeable future. The fuel pellets are tiny (~2mm), their container is only about 1cm and must be nearly perfectly spherical. A continuous power plant would consume about half a million of them per day (6 per second), all of which need to be shot with perfect timing, precision, and reliability to the exact center of the laser sphere. My guess is magnetic systems are much more likely to ever be used in power generation.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by laweijfmvo on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @03:58PM (#33975680)
This feels important. We already know that fusion "works" (proof: look up). But it's not possible to recreate the conditions of a star on Earth. So if this method is also impractical, why would I care that it "works"?
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by MattGrommes on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @05:35PM (#33977109)
If you create an impractical mechanism to prove out a scientific problem, you know it's then worth trying to fix the impractical mechanism. Maybe they start working on a way to direct the pellets into the correct path using magnets or something. But if you don't even know the scientific part works it's not worth going after the magnet solution.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by sam0x17 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @07:59PM (#33978605)
I think OP's point is that the sun already presents itself as an impractical mechanism
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by deredede on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @03:50AM (#33981373)
It's easy to argue that an impractical mechanism we know how to make is easier to modify and refine into a practical mechanism compared to an existing impractical mechanism we don't know how to replicate.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by femto113 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @04:24PM (#33976039)
Scientifically it's potentially very interesting: close up observation of what's going on in the center of a star and all that. I'd ignore all "the future of free clean energy is upon us at last!" hype. That's the lab and the government officials trying to drum up publicity that can then be milked for financial/political capital (it costs many billions to build and run a facility like this), coupled with lazy news outlets trying to milk sensationalist headlines for eyeballs.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @05:02PM (#33976609)
This seems far more credible than the "This means fusion in ten years!" hot takes, which are - frankly - completely implausible, whether they're coming from physicists or journalists.

Weapons research might be a motivator too.

I would be astounded if this can be commercialised. Not because I'm cynical for the sake of it, but because I cannot in good faith see a credible engineering path which might make that possible without spectacular breakthroughs in a number of disciplines.

MCF seems more likely to get somewhere. But my best guess is that advances in renewables will have made fusion redundant within ten years. There is far more scope for incremental and affordable improvements in collection, distribution, and storage than there is for the Big Science breakthroughs required to build one commercially viable ICF plant.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by femto113 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @11:40PM (#33980073)
Funding for NIF is 100% about weapons, it's never been about energy. After '97 (when Clinton signed the CTBT and the US agreed to stop testing new weapons) the national labs were in a panic until some clever DOE wonk invented the concept of "stockpile stewardship" and they went back to business more or less as usual.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by api on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @05:23PM (#33976918)
It proves that net positive fusion is achievable here with known physics and technology (outside bombs which are useless).

We had never done that before.

This will probably unlock more funding. In the end a different approach is probably more likely to lead to a power plant unless truly gigantic advancements in laser efficiency can be achieved.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by teach on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:26PM (#33973417)
Apparently the semiconductor industry already has lasers that are 20x more efficient than what was used in this experiment.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by adrian_b on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @04:15PM (#33975907)
The semiconductor lasers cannot produce pulses short enough for such applications.

They can be used only as the pumping sources for the solid-state lasers or fiber lasers that can produce the short pulses.

So the efficiencies of two lasers must be multiplied. I doubt that there is any chance to obtain an electrical to light conversion efficiency above 10%.

So the energy generated by the fusion reaction should be much greater than 10 times the light energy, to be able to produce excess energy, even with lasers 10 times more efficient than now.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by isoprophlex on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @02:22PM (#33974317)
Interesting, thanks! So the low laser efficiency isn't really important in interpreting the importance of this news.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by dark-star on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @04:57PM (#33976533)
Even if semiconductor lasers could put out the power required (they can't...), a 20x improvement would still mean the efficiency is only around 20%, so you'd still be putting in 10 MJ to get out 2 MJ...

Yes, it's better, but the argument still holds

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by lordnacho on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:29PM (#33973475)
I don't get it. Wouldn't that mean it required 302.05MJ to get 3.15MJ?
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by OkayPhysicist on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:36PM (#33973612)
The purpose of NIF is to investigate the practicality of inertial confinement, not "be a production fusion reactor". They don't use bleeding edge laser tech, nor are they really built to generate significant amounts of power. For context, modern lasers are ~20x more efficient than the ones that NIF is using.

Reporting based on the energy put into the reaction itself (the lasers) reflects far better the feasibility of the confinement tech than spending an inordinate amount of budget on an already incomprehensibly expensive science experiment to try and optimize every last edge condition.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by jboy55 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @06:23PM (#33977747)
The purpose of NIF is primarily to study the effects of age on our nuclear weapons stockpile by simulating the x-ray blast of the primary nuclear device on the secondary fusion stage within an h-bomb in a controlled environment.

Then we can tell how the hydrogen stage will be affected by age, and probably how we can optimize the contents and casing of that to be smaller and last longer.

Any benefits to the future of power generation is a secondary goal.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by lordnacho on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:52PM (#33973855)
Aha that makes sense, it's a jumpstart basically?
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by ep103 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @04:31PM (#33976151)
proof of concept, yeah.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by teach on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:37PM (#33973631)
Yes.

In nuclear fusion, "ignition" means that you get more energy out than the lasers impart. This is the first time anyone has pulled that off in decades of trying, which is a big deal.

But practical nuclear fusion would of course require that you get out more energy _from the entire system_ than you put in, and getting there will require even more problems to be solved. But now at least one obstacle has been overcome!

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @02:17PM (#33974243)
> "ignition" means that you get more energy out than the lasers impart. This is the first time anyone has pulled that off in decades of trying, which is a big deal.

The term is refreshingly intuitive. For decades we've been striking stone and flint. Sparks. We just got a bit of kindling going. It's no bonfire. But it's a big step forward.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by WithinReason on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @02:20PM (#33974288)
>This is the first time anyone has pulled that off in decades of trying, which is a big deal.

Are you sure of that? This is from 2014: https://arstechnica.com/science/2014/02/giant-leap-for-nucle...

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by falcor84 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @02:46PM (#33974670)
Quoting from the article you linked to:

    Hurricane’s current output, although more than the hydrogen fuel put into the reaction, hasn’t yet reached the stated goal to achieve “ignition," where nuclear fusion generates as much energy as the lasers supply. At that point it might be possible to make a sustainable power plant based on the technology.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by tingletech on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @02:47PM (#33974673)
from your article:

> Hurricane’s current output, although more than the hydrogen fuel put into the reaction, hasn’t yet reached the stated goal to achieve “ignition," where nuclear fusion generates as much energy as the lasers supply.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by darksaints on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @05:40PM (#33977204)
How do fusion bombs achieve "ignition"? It's not with lasers, right?

Also, couldn't the net energy from the ignition be used to continue the reaction, so you only need the lasers for startup?

Sorry for the newb questions, just curious.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by jboy55 on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @06:29PM (#33977811)
Caveat: This comment is derived from publicly available info. An H-bomb is a two part bomb. The primary bomb is a implosion plutonium bomb similar in make to the nagasaki/trinity bomb. It is theorized the Xrays from that bomb are focused on a secondary cylinder of uranium-238 that has a core of hydrogen and/or lithium. The Xrays ablate this casing at such intensity that the inward force (the opposite force of the ablation) is strong enough to propell the casing inwards at 300 km/second. This squeezes the hydrogen/lithium and causes fusion which releases a tone of energy, but more importantly a huge amount of neutrons. These neutrons cause the 238 in the casing to fission releasing an even greater amount of energy. A Neutron bomb for example replaces some/all of the 238 with lead, so the neutrons escape without causing more fision. Again, this is all speculation from scientists outside the various labs, and using publicly available information.

For power generation, since the energy from any fusion reaction is primarily emitted as heat and neutrons. The neutrons are difficult to utilize and is basically wasted energy, but the heat would just heat water, turning it into steam, then turning a turbine.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by scarier on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @06:30PM (#33977828)
With a fission bomb.

Don’t have a good explanation for your second question, although I think the short answer is “not with the way the Livermore experiment was set up.”

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by giblfiz on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:53PM (#33973868)
Yes, but the name "ignition" is very useful.

The idea, ultimately, is that like with a wood fire, the energy from the fuel "burning" is what starts the next bit of fuel "burning", and then as it runs on it's own as long as you keep giving it more fuel, you collect the excess heat by boiling water.

So, similar to a wood fire, you might need to use a blowtorch to get it started, and run at a net negative of energy, but the exciting thing is that there was a little flame... that means we can probably make a roaring fire out of it.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @05:13PM (#33976776)
No it doesn't. If you throw some fuel in their general direction, oxygen fires are self-sustaining with relatively little effort. It takes more effort to stop a large oxygen fire than to make one.

Fusion is the opposite. Fusion's natural state is Not Fusing, so in ICF you have to keep compressing and heating the fuel. Using equipment with optically tight tolerances and epic pulsed energy densities. Which are somehow maintained reliably for long periods. In spite of significant debris and huge temperature swings.

Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by kortex on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @10:24PM (#33979654)
Fire's natural state is burning only at standard temperature and pressure (or greater). If you look at the "average" state of all space in the universe, fire is not stable.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by mikeyouse on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @01:49PM (#33973819)
Kind of.. It's like saying you used a 1% efficient 100HP pump to start a water wheel that eventually was outputting 1.5HP of power. We know how to make more efficient pumps, so it's not terribly interesting that it took 100HP of power to generate the 1.5HP -- the fact that only 1HP of output power was actually used to start the 1.5HP reaction is the big deal.
Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean? by iamgopal on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @09:44PM (#33979402)
Let’s say there are 20 different system used to make this ( laser powering, energy collections, target energy density etc etc ) , we only need to make 10 of those system 200 percent efficient to increase overall efficiency to 1000 times , within range of usefulness, I think we will be achieve this.