News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rapsey on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:23AM (#33955579)
Even if fusion ends up producing more power than consuming in the real world, it still has to compete on cost. People too enthusiastic about fusion tend to ignore that it might not actually be a cost effective source of power.

Solar panels are cheap and batteries are easier to build and there are lots of ways of making them.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by coldpie on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:29AM (#33955654)
Unfortunately, energy storage is still an unsolved problem. Research on batteries may get us there soon, but today they aren't feasible. It's very much worth putting effort into both approaches. IMO the best outcome is a wide variety of clean energy sources and storage solutions, so the best solution can be chosen for a given geographical/political/etc situation.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by toomuchtodo on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:30AM (#33955664)
Solar and batteries are already cheaper than fossil fuels in most markets. Nuclear isn’t competing with renewables, it’s competing against batteries and almost free renewables that charge them.

Nuclear is still possibly a great fit for niche locales where renewables aren’t feasible at all. Not a nuclear hater by any means (we need every innovation we can get), just show your math.

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.365.6449.108

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by coldpie on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:39AM (#33955806)
Are solar + batteries feasible to heat every house in Minnesota with electricity when it's below -20F (-30C) for a week, we have <9 hours of daylight per day, and failing power literally means death? I genuinely don't know. Like I said, having a variety of solutions is the best outcome so we can choose the right one & have backups.

> just show your math.

I admit I can't. It's mostly gut-feeling from various science news sources I keep up with (e.g. Ars Technica; Skeptic's Guide to the Universe).

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by megaman821 on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:53AM (#33956016)
Only if you limit yourself to using solar generated with Minnesota's state borders.

Solar, Wind, HVDC transmission lines, short-term battery storage get us most of the way there, and is all on the process of being built out now. Medium term storage is still up in the air (flow batteries? compressed air?). Long term storage looks like hydrogen or natural gas with carbon capture. All these things seem more achievable than fusion in the next few decades.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:20AM (#33956442)
> if you limit yourself to using solar generated with Minnesota's state borders

I live in a cold state. The idea of relying on out-of-state power, regulated and controlled by people with zero accountability to you, for life-and-death energy is a tough sell.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by megaman821 on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:25AM (#33956533)
Bad news then. You most assuredly rely on natural gas from Texas traveling through a long underground pipeline to heat your homes and businesses. Relying on solar electricity from Texas or Arizona traveling through a long wire isn't going to change the status quo much.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:30AM (#33956627)
> most assuredly rely on natural gas from Texas traveling through a long underground pipeline to heat your homes and businesses

Last I checked, we mine our own coal, pump our own oil and put up our own wind farms [1]. Minnesota, for what it’s worth, runs on renewables, coal and nukes [2]. The fifth of natural gas it does use comes from Canada, the Dakotas and Iowa.

These cold-state energy security concerns are a big part of the political puzzle that gets missed in the national discourse.

[1] https://www.wsgs.wyo.gov/products/wsgs-2012-electricalgenera...

[2] https://www.eia.gov/state/analysis.php?sid=MN

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by megaman821 on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:51AM (#33956936)
In northern states almost all residential energy use is heating. The amount of electricity used is minimal, therefore even modest amounts of electricity generation can meet need. Wyoming is the only northern state that has natural gas in notable amounts, all other states import a lot of their energy (especially heating) needs.

If most states stopped importing energy they would have to go back to wood and coal-fired stoves. That would be a huge quality of life reduction in terms of convenience and home air quality.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:55AM (#33956993)
> almost all residential energy use is heating. The amount of electricity used is minimal

Resistive heating.

> most states stopped importing energy they would have to go back to wood and coal-fired stoves

Most states don’t have high-baseload, low-latency life-or-death energy requirements. Those that do have the options I outlined above.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by toomuchtodo on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:28PM (#33957450)
Heat pumps should be paired with rooftop solar and batteries whenever possible for resiliency. I admit the use of natural gas will decline in my lifetime, but probably won’t be fully deprecated.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by toomuchtodo on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:29AM (#33956603)
The state you live in has one of the highest potentials for wind power in the country, easily backed by transmission, batteries, and as a last resort, natural gas.

High level, the energy transition isn't simply a fossil->renewables story, but also a centralization->highly decentralized story.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:37AM (#33956735)
Totally agree, though I don’t know how wind performs in extended and deep subzero / heavy snow conditions. Hydropower is the traditional baseload for the Midwest, but it’s tough to square the destruction to natural beauty that entails in comparison with a remote nuclear set-up.

EDIT: It seems not too badly [1].

[1] https://empoweringmichigan.com/how-do-wind-turbines-work-in-...

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by kelnos on Monday December 12, 2022 @05:02PM (#33961061)
What does the geothermal story look like? I expect it's expensive to first set up, but after that, maybe it's cost-effective and reliable? Asking because I genuinely don't know, but haven't seen it mentioned in this subthread.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by KMag on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:58AM (#34028855)
Note that there are two common uses of "geothermal". One is for geothermal power generation, and but there's also an unfortunate use of the term in describing ground-loop heat pumps and similar technologies. Ground loop heat exchanges are a godsend for heat pump efficiency in the deep of the Minnesota winter, but it's very different from a source of heat that's practically exploitable for electricity generation.

From the context, I think your link is relevant to the GP's question.

However, if you search for "geothermal Minnesota", you'll get hits primarily related to ground-loop heat pumps.

Note that in the Minneapolis area, the ground will freeze down about 3 feet in winter, so you need to bury your ground loop deeper than that. The frost line is even deeper up in the Duluth area. (Also, you need to use an air compressor to purge the vast majority of water out of any in-ground sprinkler systems before the ground freezes.)

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by KMag on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:45AM (#34028691)
I grew up in Minnesota, but left before there was much wind farming in the SW part of the state. (I've been told, SW Minnesota is one of the best places for wind farming.) Wind farming does work well in SW Minnesota.

However, I also remember a news story about some used wind turbines relocated from California that had trouble due to inadequate heaters to keep the lubricant from getting too viscous.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by jsight on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:04PM (#33957126)
To keep warm, I'm estimating 2,628 kwh for a month for a home for a family of 3. In our magical Minnesota where everyone lives in houses with 3 people and only electric heat pumps, we'd have 1,900,000. This means, we'd need 4,993,200,000 kwh in the coldest month (4.993 Twh).

500,000 kilowatt of panels would produce ~33 gwh in the worst month (January). So, we'd need 151 times that many to have a good chance of doing this with purely solar. That'd mean 75,500,000 kw of solar panels. Assuming that we could install these for $1.50/w, that'd cost 113,250,000,000 and there's still a chance that we'd freeze people to death.

To mitigate that risk, we'd want to add ~500 gwh of batteries (just guessing as to needed capacity here). At a price of ~150/kwh, we'd be looking at ~75,000,000,000 in energy storage prices.

Feel free to check my math, as I did that pretty quickly. The figures are absurdly high due to scaling for the worst case type scenarios. Summer months would correlate with lower demand and more than double the supply.

Sensibly speaking, noone would try to do this. Its like building an offgrid home. You can get 90% of the way there and add a generator, or you can spend 10x more be truly offgrid. Almost everyone chooses the former. Maybe even 80%. Solar is great and very cost effective, but the returns diminish the deeper one goes.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by coldpie on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:14PM (#33957267)
Nice. I just looked up last February's bill for my ~1700sqft detached SFH in Saint Paul. It was apparently 6.8 therms/day (12 deg F average temp for the month). That maths out to about 5916 kWh for the coldest month (6.8 therms * 29 kwh/therm * 30 days), or a little more than double your estimate. March was 5.9 therms/day and Jan was 5.4 therms/day. So I think your costs are on the conservative side of things... or possibly my home is very inefficient :)

E: Ah, it occurs to me that you're using electric heat pumps, which are probably much more efficient than my NG boiler.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by jsight on Monday December 12, 2022 @02:57PM (#33959363)
Yes, I pulled the estimate for really efficient heat pumps. To convert to all electric heat like that estimate, we'd have to replace a lot of gas heat with electric. Might as well go for the most efficient thing.

Compared to the nearly $200B in infra investment that I was estimating, that looks easy, lol.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by foota on Monday December 12, 2022 @04:47PM (#33960893)
I realize this isn't relevant for a discussion about future investment, but the current "value" of the whole energy infrastructure for a state is probably in the hundreds of billions of dollars, right? It's been built out over decades, of course, so the actual costs per year are much lower.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by jsight on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @05:35PM (#33977120)
That's definitely possible. Going based upon the output of something like Catawba, that looks like ~3 nuclear plants. I bet that could be done for less than 100B, though I'd just be guessing. I also don't know anything about operations costs for that.

Also, I estimated solar at $1.5/watt. That's probably at least 50% too high.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by pfdietz on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:38PM (#33957571)
We can look at how solar/wind/storage compete with putative fusion. Fusion is a baseload source, so let's see how they would do to provide "synthetic baseload".

https://model.energy/

Selecting the state of Minnesota, 2011 weather data, and 2030 cost assumptions, this would be about 70 Euro/MWh. The cost optimized solution would involve 222 hours of hydrogen storage, 5 hours of battery storage, 4.2x peak power of solar and 2.4x peak power of wind.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by elurg on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:56AM (#33956060)
Why do we need to cover the worst case with 100% renewables?

The goal is to reduce emissions so it would be great even if we can just stop burning coal in the summer.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by Spivak on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:14AM (#33956323)
I think because it's the learned defensive reaction. What ends up happening is that you have someone who really hates fossil fuels who is more than willing to back policies that require a quality of life drop or a massive cost shift onto individuals to achieve 100% renewables. So whenever it comes up anything positive you say about renewables has to be come with the explicit caveat that it's not yet a 1-1 replacement.

It's one of those issues the overwhelming majority of people are on the same page about what we should do but at the ends you have "my livelihood depends on coal" on one end and "my life is insulated against the downsides of full-renewables so I'm privileged enough to have out of touch opinions" on the other and that's who shows up in comment sections.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by jsight on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:29AM (#33956597)
We don't need to do that. But the media focuses on things like that and turns everything into some sort of weird argument that renewables are literally going to freeze gramma to death. Its overwhelmingly about emotion.

Its the same as what we see with EVs, tbh. Oh noes, what if you get caught in a snowstorm!? Imagine if 80% of the cars were EVs and they got stuck and there were... no chargers! Picture yourself freezing to death because of "those people".

Real world performance and goals are not correlated well with media hyperbole.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by jsight on Monday December 12, 2022 @02:58PM (#33959371)
This site has changed a lot in the past year. Its been strange to watch.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by _ph_ on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:11AM (#33956283)
Eventually we have to get to zero net carbon emissions. But the worst case is just to create carbon based fuels from CO2 extracted from the atmosphere and use it in places/for uses which cannot be covered by renewable electricity directly (the far north, airplaines, ...)
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by hedora on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:41AM (#33956787)
In central California with ideal conditions, one day’s worth of storage roughly doubles the price of a solar system that is correctly sized for net zero production in November (assuming a wood stove is supplementing a heat pump).

I don’t think storage will be feasible in places like Minnesota. The following makes far more economic sense:

- Double solar / wind production by buying 2x more panels vs. “normal” states.

- Go all electric (heat pump / induction) for appliances and vehicles.

- Buy 8-24h worth of house batteries.

- Use a fossil fuel generator to top off batteries during outages (this more than doubles the generator’s end to end efficiency)

- Sell excess electricity to the grid, where it is used for subsidized carbon capture.

This should be completely resilient against storms and power outages, and extremely carbon negative. It would cost about 2x as much as best case renewables.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by selimthegrim on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:30AM (#33956626)
I think UMN did a study with 4 hour storage plus solar on the grid a few years back.

https://energytransition.umn.edu/modernizing-minnesotas-grid...

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by coldpie on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:48AM (#33956890)
Thanks, this was informative. It wasn't clear to me, but I think the study does not account for switching heating from burning NG in the dwelling to electricity. I don't have numbers, but I'm pretty sure that's going to introduce an enormous load on the system, and is my main source of skepticism for wind/solar/storage as a solution for all electricity generation in places like Minnesota.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by hadlock on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:54AM (#33956035)
I honestly wonder if large scale population of the northern areas is feasible without carbon fuels. Historically chopped wood was used to heat northern homes and camps, later coal and oil and I guess now to some extent electricity, but as you say, renewable energy doesn't apply there. If places like Minnesota are a net negative for green/renewable energy, their costs may be much higher to offset generation in more favorable climates.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by Mistletoe on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:30AM (#33956612)
Cold can be mitigated a lot by enhanced R-value insulation in a single application. Northern states have higher levels of insulation.

https://www.energystar.gov/campaign/seal_insulate/identify_p...

I don't really see a hot/cold stratification in this chart-

https://www.statista.com/chart/12098/the-us-states-with-the-...

And even then, the difference in costs seems quite small. Alaska is $332 and Georgia is $310.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:40AM (#33956779)
Not are carbon fuels are carbon negative - biofuel pulls down carbon from the atmosphere when it's created, so is considered carbon neutral.

I think it's highly likely we'll be burning a lot of algae fuel in the coming decades in situations where the energy density of carbon fuels is necessary.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by tacocataco on Monday December 12, 2022 @01:47PM (#33958499)
The birds fly south for the winter. Then again, the birds dont have to worry about who owns the land wherever they eventually land.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by VaxWithSex on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:06AM (#33956207)
Minnesota can use wind, which is also cheaper.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by gjsman-1000 on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:21AM (#33956464)
Minnesota has anticyclones, which are periods lasting over a week with almost no wind.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by _ph_ on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:14AM (#33956321)
There are plenty of other renewables usable than solar. Wind power would be the obvious one, as wind is often a great complement to solar anyway. Then there are long-distance transmission lines, water power, energy from biomass. Finally, if everything else fails, create hydrocarbons from CO2 in sunny places, ship those "eFuels" to Minnesota.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rootusrootus on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:45AM (#33955893)
I wonder if we should seriously consider moving people away from such cold climates and towards warmer ones. Air conditioning is cheaper and coincidentally happens at about the same time as maximum solar power.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by coldpie on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:48AM (#33955935)
This might work with post-Surak Vulcans, but it's not gonna fly here on Earth with humans :)
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by finnh on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:16AM (#33956353)
We are doing that actually, but the other way: rather than moving the people, we are moving the climate.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by Matticus_Rex on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:38AM (#33955795)
"Places where sun availability makes solar inefficient" is still a niche so massive that "niche" seems like a bad descriptor.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by Gwypaas on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:01AM (#33956141)
Keep in mind HVDC. 3300 KM north of the Sahara desert, and you are relatively close to the Arctic circle. North of that is still a "niche," but now we're talking about a million people living hugely spread out.

Most of those people living in Russia, Norway, and Sweden with easy access to an abundance of hydro, to the level that energy flows north to south in the Scandinavian countries.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by selimthegrim on Monday December 12, 2022 @06:07PM (#33961789)
Well maybe once they finish blowing up the ones they built in Donbass and half-built near Saratov we can revisit it.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by dahfizz on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:51AM (#33955962)
Construction still hasn't begun on that project, 3 years later. When is the last time LA had a large construction project come in under budget?

I'll believe it when the batteries are actually installed and the bill is paid.

Also, the solar farm is planned for 800-MWh of storage. In 2021, LA used over 65 TWh of electricity[1]. That's over 7 GWh, per hour. So this storage would run the city for a few minutes. Not exactly a replacement for base load generation.

[1] https://ecdms.energy.ca.gov/elecbycounty.aspx

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by toomuchtodo on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:07AM (#33956215)
See you in ten years at the earliest when any nuclear generator you break ground on today generates its first kWh of power (assuming it isn’t wildly late or over budget, as every one built since the 70s has been).
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by dahfizz on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:22AM (#33956486)
I'm not saying fusion is necessarily the answer. I'm just tired of hearing "solar plus storage is the cheapest option" when the sources always rely on projected costs and a pathetically small amount of storage.

We need a major breakthrough in storage tech to make grid-scale storage a reality. Li-ion batteries are never going to cut it. Who knows whether grid scale storage will come along faster than fusion.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by pfdietz on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:43PM (#33957633)
We don't need major breakthroughs, we just need to watch technologies proceed down their experience curves.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by vlovich123 on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:28AM (#33956596)
But at least we’ve built them and we know we can provide the necessary capacity.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by melling on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:47AM (#33955921)
That’s great! Because there are [ONLY] 8500 coal power plants producing 20% of the CO2 emissions globally.

Removing 20% of emissions will make a huge difference.

ETA on this should be around 2030?

What I don’t get is since solar is cheaper, why are we building so many coal power plants?

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2317274-china-is-buildi...

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by throitallaway on Monday December 12, 2022 @05:13PM (#33961182)
Solar generates electricity during the day. It would have to be overprovisioned and paired with storage in order to handle dark hours. There are some battery banks out there (Tesla), but I don't think they're very common.

Coal handles baseline load. We should be using nuclear for baseline instead.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by q1w2 on Monday December 12, 2022 @06:37PM (#33962072)
> Solar and batteries are already cheaper than fossil fuels in most markets.

This is false. This has only ever been shown to be true in extremely narrow edge cases where the batteries only needed to last overnight in extremely sunny locations.

For solar+batteries to be cheaper they need to be large enough to power through weeks/months of cloudy/snowy/leafy/rainy weather in places that are at least near higher latitude locations.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by conradev on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:11AM (#33956279)
CATL is working on sodium batteries as a lithium replacement shipping in 2023

Form Energy is working on iron air batteries as a new class of multi-day energy storage, launching its first test installation in 2023

The US passed a tax credit for energy storage, to encourage building more pumped storage capacity

Congress is working on transmission line permitting reform

There are some good reasons to be optimistic in the near term

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rapsey on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:33AM (#33955711)
> Unfortunately, energy storage is still an unsolved problem.

Mechanical, lithium based, flow, heat, compressed air, pumped hydro are all types of batteries that are able to store quite large amounts of power today or in the near future. Certainly cheaper than fusion has any hope to be within 20 years.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by BeefWellington on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:35AM (#33955748)
Solar panels are cheap and batteries are easier to build because they're already taking advantage of economies of scale and aren't in the R&D phase still.

The viability of fusion has been centered for a long time around getting more power out than you put in and once that marker is met it's viewed as the last giant hurdle in the way. There's still plenty more R&D that needs to be done before it can easily / readily scale though.

It's where nuclear was in the 60s basically. Even if it only ever gets to be comparable to nuclear in terms of costing but with none of the hazardous byproduct, it will come out ahead. When you consider the environmental factors involved in battery production it is pretty clear that fusion at least has the potential to be the cleanest sources of energy. Whether it ultimately gets there is another question.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rapsey on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:39AM (#33955798)
> It's where nuclear was in the 60s basically.

Plants built in the 70s are still operating. It is nowhere near a decade away.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by BeefWellington on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:40AM (#33955829)
Fair, my statement had an implied "if they cleared this hurdle" attached but I probably should have made it explicit.

I do think it'll be a decade or so to go from net gain -> commercial fusion reactors coming online.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by gabesullice on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:37AM (#33955783)
Pessimists were saying solar panels and batteries were too expensive too, not so long ago. If we discover fusion power to be viable in our lifetime, it will be a breathtaking accomplishment to witness. It's a fork in the timeline with repercussions that will reverberate for millenia, across trillions of human lives.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by pfdietz on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:46PM (#33957668)
They laughed at Galileo, but they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.

Most skepticism is ratified by subsequent events.

DT fusion doesn't appear to have much to recommend it, since it still requires a thermal cycle like fission or coal, and that keeps its cost high. From an engineering point of view it involves large monolithic plants with very complex and stressed equipment. This seems the opposite of good engineering.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by gabesullice on Monday December 12, 2022 @01:20PM (#33958117)
My impression is that the research efforts have been focused on "can we do it?" Then, if the answer is yes, they'll focus on "how do we do it efficiently?" Where efficiency can mean anything from capital efficient, to resource efficient, to energy conversion efficiency. Limiting one's focus on the next blocker in the critical path and not increasing scope beyond it sounds like perfectly good engineering to me.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by pfdietz on Monday December 12, 2022 @01:42PM (#33958444)
It seems like terrible myopic project management to me. You want to avoid first steps that you know are very likely going to lead to dead ends down the line.

We're constantly being told to take the long term view. Are we only to do that when it's favorable to the technological optimist's case or budget?

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rgmerk on Monday December 12, 2022 @04:24PM (#33960542)
This.

If you have to build a steam turbine to convert the energy from your fusion reactor into electricity, it's never going to compete with solar and wind power in most of the world.

Doesn't mean that there won't be applications (if you can make all those lasers compact enough, submarines, ships, and ultimately spacecraft come to mind), but grid electricity is doubtful.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by codealot on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:06PM (#33957147)
Beautifully stated. I teared up. This and watching us settle on the moon and Mars would be incredible. And achieving more breakthroughs in AI and medicine and everything else. I am an optimist and really excited by everything on the horizon.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by HillRat on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:49AM (#33955944)
Yeah, the cost of capsules for NIF is something like 4 orders of magnitude higher than it needs to be for commercialization, though admittedly it's not like they've industrialized the process yet.

The other thing is that if LLNL is still using their own definition of Q, it's not necessarily the case that they've demonstrated net-energy breakeven; they like to compare direct energy delivery to energy release, so when calculating Q they basically pretend there aren't any energy losses from actually running the huge laser facility itself. As a result, LLNL assumes that laser technology will improve to the point that real-life Q can catch up with their "scientific Q" metric. (IIRC I think "Project LIFE" was supposed to develop some of those technologies, but it never worked out, possibly since NIF is so far behind their promised schedule.)

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by ragebol on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:43AM (#33955877)
Not everything is expressed in cost, externalities like the looks and intrusiveness of something do matter.

1 fusion plant has less NIMBYs to deal with than wind-on-land, for example.

But yes, could be that still it's too expensive by the time it becomes available. By then I hope we can make a fusion plant so small it fits on a space ship and power an Epstein drive :-)

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by pfdietz on Monday December 12, 2022 @08:31PM (#33963399)
Fusion will have plenty of NIMBY once the tritium leaks start. It doesn't take leaking a very large fraction of a DT plant's tritium to reach levels that already cause fission power plants PR problems.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by gjsman-1000 on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:33AM (#33955717)
> Solar panels are cheap and batteries are easier to build and there are lots of ways of making them.

Right now they are, but they often rely on materials from politically unstable regions (particularly Africa), or potential political rivals (China). Also, many solar panels require polysilicon from China, which is almost certainly produced with forced labor.

https://www.csis.org/analysis/dark-spot-solar-energy-industr...

https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/04/12/clean-energy-china-xinj...

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/nov/29/evidence...

And it's not just a China problem.

"On batteries, there were major issues with the mining of between 15% and 30% of the world’s cobalt in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Amnesty International found that children, some as young as seven, were working in artisanal cobalt mines, often for less than $2 a day. Mining conditions were reportedly hazardous, and workers often did not have adequate protective equipment and were exposed to toxic dust that contributed to hard metal lung disease."

The US is trying to crack down but Europe is lagging behind on it. However, if the report's claim (which I see no reason to doubt) that China has 82% of the global polysilicon market is true, with most of their polysilicon production being in the Xinjiang region, calling solar panels (or batteries) "cheap" is fairly distasteful considering their sources.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rapsey on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:37AM (#33955784)
Mechanical, flow, heat, compressed air, pumped hydro are all types of batteries. All capable of storing MW to GW of power. It is not all lithium and cobalt.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by automatic6131 on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:49AM (#33955946)
Once again, I am reminding HackerNews that the technology to build a battery capable of storing enough renewable electrical energy for the (world|nation) for even half a day *does not exist* at any reasonable cost.

And if you want to store multiple days for a northerly nation with very cold winters, frequent high pressure anticyclones (so, no wind) that can last about a week, and you want to switch everyone to zero carbon heating, then the technology doubly doesn't exist.

And the only retort to the above will be mumbling "yeah, but exponential improvement in batteries plus didn't someone say something about hydrogen?" which is essentially, wishful thinking. When you can build a zero carbon grid out of nuclear fission plants - and we've known how to do so since the 60s.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by VaxWithSex on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:58AM (#33956085)
Sure it exists, it is called compressed air. Even better with CO2.

Close to me is the oldest one, built in 1972 and still operational today: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kraftwerk_Huntorf

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rapsey on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:02AM (#33956156)
> Once again, I am reminding HackerNews that the technology to build a battery capable of storing enough renewable electrical energy for the (world|nation) for even half a day does not exist at any reasonable cost.

But it is almost certainly closer to existence than fusion.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by gjsman-1000 on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:19AM (#33956418)
Almost certainly not. The US alone generates 4,095 billion kWh yearly. For a half a day, you would need to store 5,600,000,000 kWh. Tesla Megapack can store 3916 kWh fully loaded. This means you would need 1,430,000 Megapacks to power the US for half a day. With Tesla only being capable of producing roughly 40,000,000 kWh of Megapacks annually, it would take 140 years to produce all the batteries. If Tesla created 100 times the factory capacity they have now (which, could the supply of raw materials even withstand the smallest fraction of that?), it would take 14 years, for batteries that have a warranty of 15 years. These are lithium-ion batteries which are the most space-efficient, unless you don't mind clearing hundreds of square miles of space for this project. Did I mention it costs about $1 million per Megapack right now, so this project would cost $1.4 TRILLION assuming all Lithium+Cobalt+Supplies+Labor cost the same as they do now despite demand being increased 100x, and ignoring all engineering costs, and factory scaling costs, which could multiply the cost exponentially. All to power the US for just half a day. Now consider how to add Europe, Asia, Africa, South America, the rest of North America...

We're not close, and it's basically completely unfeasible. Fusion will be closer in 100 years than such a project.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by pfdietz on Monday December 12, 2022 @12:50PM (#33957730)
Almost certainly yes.

Consider pumped thermal energy storage. Use a thermal cycle to generate hot and cold (say, by compressing a gas, probably argon, extracting the heat, then reexpanding, and then storing the resulting "cold"), then reversing that cycle to generate power.

This scales embarrassingly well. It can be made entirely from cheap materials available in essentially infinite supply. No component operates at a temperature above the creep limit of ordinary steel. Round trip efficiency could reasonably be 75%. This requires no technological breakthroughs -- it's 19th century technology.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by rapsey on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:48AM (#33956893)
I have listed 5 different types of batteries than Tesla makes. A number more are much farther than the fundamental science stage of Fusion. Tesla primarily makes batteries for cars, grid storage is actually way more flexible in the type of battery that can be used. You are missing the forest for the trees.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by jillesvangurp on Monday December 12, 2022 @06:36PM (#33962060)
There are quite a few battery chemistries now that don't involve any cobalt. And the ones that do can get their cobalt from more reputable sources than the mining industries founded by colonial powers in Africa. (often backed by big oil and mining corporations). Cobalt and other minerals were mined long before lithium ion batteries came along, for example.

For all the crocodile tears about children mining cobalt, it's easy to forget how other industries can be just as bad or much worse. Of course, critics of batteries are laser focused on only and exclusively criticizing how bad things are when it comes to batteries and literally nothing else whatsoever.

I mean, do you want to talk about oil? Or coal? Or copper? Or uranium? Nasty industries, each of them. Especially oil. Lots of environmental destruction, poor working conditions, the occasional bit of genocide or sponsored corruption, wars, etc. Mining and oil/gas industry just are a nasty. Especially when everybody just accepts it as normal and looks the other way.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by barnabee on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:30AM (#33956622)
Most things don’t start off cost effective, they become so due to investment, demand, industrialisation, competition, etc.

Maybe fusion will stay a small part of the energy mix for decades even after the first commercial plants are built but be part of what eventually enables us to use orders of magnitude more energy than we do now…

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by megaman821 on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:34AM (#33955736)
I agree. There is no breakthrough on the horizon that is going to make a fusion plant have the complexity closer to a natural gas plant than a nuclear fission plant. Therefore the costs will remain high.

It could still be a useful technology, especially in space. I could see a moon or mars base powered by fusion.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by DennisP on Monday December 12, 2022 @10:55AM (#33956049)
Gas has low capital cost but relatively high fuel cost, especially outside the US. For most fusion designs (possibly excluding NIF), the fuel cost is insignificant.

Also of course we might want to consider the carbon emissions of gas plants.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by megaman821 on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:11AM (#33956282)
That is what I mean. Some people are imagining the capital costs of a natural gas plant with the fuel and environmental costs being almost nothing. There is absolutely nothing to suggest that a fusion plant would cost anything less than a fission plant at this point.
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by neonsunset on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:02AM (#33956153)
Solar and wind are bad and unsustainable due to mining of rare earth minerals and photovoltaic cells degrading and becoming a landfill liability.

Cost effectiveness is also a myth perpetrated by the death of nuclear executed through bureaucracy.

The nuclear, however, is currently the true energy source to use, technologically much simpler (than fusion) to execute with decades of experience making it the safest out there. It is the zero-carbon environmentally friendly energy source.

[dead]
Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by neonsunset on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:19AM (#33956430)
What were the estimated damage and deaths caused by Fukushima incident? When was the reactor site built, when was the reactor designed?

A few extra questions you may also be interested in: lithium, cobalt mining, costs of nanolitography for high efficiency photovoltaic cells. All that with tax breaks and heavy govt incentives vs insane regulatory burden on nuclear industry. Also nuclear scare in education that makes the public treat opinions like yours as even remotely realistic.

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by VaxWithSex on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:27AM (#33956555)
extra questions you might be interested in:

where is most of the uranium mined that is used in european reactors? what environmental damages are done by reprocessing uran? costs of the buildback of reactors? who will pay for it when the costs for this are 10x what the operators put aside for it? how much subsidies go into nuclear? how do you prevent proliferation in rougue nations that use nuclear for example iran?

Re:Fusion energy breakthrough by Livermore Lab by VaxWithSex on Monday December 12, 2022 @11:23AM (#33956494)
Why did people back then think it was save and then it exploded? Were they wrong in their assessment back then? Why were they wrong? Are you sure your assesment is correct today? Why is it better than their assessment back then? Are you sure you are not making the same mistakes that they made back then? Oh look, I can ask questions too, because I am a sealion.