News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by hobbitstan on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @05:50PM (#33901505)
It's interesting how pale skinned they are compared to current Egyptians. It's like a whole history was lost.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by keenmaster on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:01AM (#33905471)
A whole history was lost? Not at all. The area surrounding the Mediterranean has always had high variance in skin color even within a particular region. That being said, my guess is that the average “native” Egyptian was tan far before the 7th century when Arabs arrived. The population of the Levant (Syria, Lebanon…) was/is on average lighter than that of Egypt since one of the genes for “whiteness” originated there, but Egypt traded a lot with the Levant and there was some population mixture.

The notion posited by other commenters of a lighter Coptic population being more representative of the skin color of the average ancient Egyptian is dubious, though they obviously mixed less with Arabs - those two statements are not mutually exclusive. It’s also worth noting that the average Egyptian is quite ethnically Egyptian. Arabs did not just come in and massively displace Egyptian DNA. For starters there were many more Egyptians than Arabs. People in the West can say that any non-Muslim minority in the Middle East is more representative of the “real” natives of the land because of less mixture with Arabs (e.g. Assyrians). Isn’t that too convenient and somewhat ridiculous of a narrative, given the common bias against Muslims?

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by bmikaili on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:18AM (#33905949)
This is wrong. DNA studies (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egypt%E2%80%93Mesopotamia_rela...) show that modern day egyptians are not really the closest to ancient egyptians, they just live on the land that was once ancient egyptian.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by sct202 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:37AM (#33908275)
Your citation states continuity with additional ancestry mixing in from later migrations:

>The study stated that "our genetic time transect suggests genetic continuity between the Pre-Ptolemaic, Ptolemaic and Roman populations of Abusir el-Meleq, indicating that foreign rule impacted the [native] population only to a very limited degree at the genetic level."

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by DoItToMe81 on Sunday December 11, 2022 @09:11AM (#33943321)
Yeah, modern Egyptians are directly related to ancient Egyptians, with the biggest change being that they have significantly more subsaharan DNA than any of the tested ancient Egyptians.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by HideousKojima on Thursday December 08, 2022 @02:39AM (#33905294)
Copts (Egyptian Christians) are often much lighter skinned than Muslim Egyptians. I'm guessing there was less intermarriage with the Arab invaders amongst the populace that didn't convert. You can look at Rami Malek for an example of a Copt that westerners would be familiar with.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by keenmaster on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:51PM (#33913196)
Even with Arab gene flow, Muslim and Christian/Coptic Egyptians are very genetically similar, which shows how small Arab contribution to the Egyptian gene pool was. There is probably a bigger difference between Egyptians in the north vs south, and a much bigger difference between “city” Egyptians and Egyptians in the villages or desert. Across the Middle East, “city” people tend to be lighter, in part due to lifestyle but also often due to genetic differences (e.g. bedouins have genetic distinctions and don’t intermarry much with city folk).

Copts with lighter skin are a small minority among Egyptians with lighter skin in general. Not that it matters much, but this is interesting to me from an anthropological standpoint.

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by saiya-jin on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:57AM (#33906934)
Another item may be simple sun exposure. Manual workers in any tropical country are much darker-skinned compared to white collar workers. Basically anywhere in subtropics its considered posh to look as white as possible, see massive business ie in India with skin whitening. You won't see many self-tanning creams in shops there but tons of whitening ones.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by KoftaBob on Thursday December 08, 2022 @05:00AM (#33906222)
That's more a case of selection bias.

Those who had portraits made of them when they died, like the Fayum Portraits, tended to be wealthier Egyptians who weren't outside working in the sun as much as the poorer ones.

Also, the Fayum area that "Fayum Portraits" gets its name from is not too far from Cairo, which is in the Northern part of Egypt, where peoples skin color tended to be lighter than those in the far south of Egypt, as you got closer to what was Nubia.

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by orcul on Thursday December 08, 2022 @02:06AM (#33905091)
Well the Arabs invaded in the 7th century...
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by AlotOfReading on Thursday December 08, 2022 @02:24AM (#33905205)
These aren't photographs. Skin color was often used for artistic purposes and to impart symbolic meaning. Egyptians in particular were conventionally depicted with reddish or yellowish skin to indicate life or vitality, with light blue or white highlights to showcase lighting and contours.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by wl on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:19PM (#33912767)
Red skin for men and yellow skin for woman is a convention of tomb paintings. Those are the stylized paintings on walls with the stereotypical technique of combining a side view and a frontal view into a single 2D representation. Mummy portraits belong to a different, later genre that is far less stylized and more realistic. The skin tones, in particular, are more true to life in mummy portraits than tomb paintings.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by ashwagary on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:21AM (#33907088)
Whitening the skin and features of important figures in history is a habit of western civilization. Im never surprised when I see the deception continue in western academia.

Those African shaped noses didnt break themselves. The recently discovered Egyptian statues and other art that survived for thousands of years submerged in the Mediterranean Sea with African facial features unscathed prove that there is an agenda that continues.

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by imbnwa on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:23AM (#33909685)
From the article: "People depicted in the portraits were upper-class, say curators."

They are literally pointing out that these are portraits of aristocrats, whom it is very well-known would likely be of non-Egyptian, if not mixed, origin at the time they were buried. No one is making a claim that this is what the average Egyptian looked like in the article.

Now if you still think its appropriate to argue that modern Egyptians represent a population replacement demographic, well, you're free to I guess, but I'd wager there weren't enough conquerors to replace the entire or even the majority of the population.

Also, Copts and Amazighe are also African, so "African shaped noses" is sorta weird to say, never mind the prominence of similarly shaped noses to Copts and Amazighe in Ethiopians and adjacent populations in the Horn of Africa. I know "what you mean" but what I mean is that we sorta eliminate a whole lotta physical and cultural differences when we talk about some essential unity of Africa lying in looking some particular way.

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by ROTMetro on Thursday December 08, 2022 @01:08PM (#33911036)
The first female pharaoh was described in contemporary texts as being blonde. There are blonde mummies and archeologists tried to pass them off as having had their hair 'lightened' but that has recently been shown to be completely made up and that they are natural blondes. What bias does it show that a false narrative of 'lightening hair' was wholly made up? Not the one you are trying to push.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by ashwagary on Saturday December 10, 2022 @09:21PM (#33939389)
>The first female pharaoh was described in contemporary texts as being blonde.

Never heard this claim, but it's a weak argument to rest on if we believe it to be true.

Naturally blonde and red haired black people arent that uncommon. Furthermore, if we are being honest, every genetic trait on this planet is represented in a subset of the African population.

Every variation of hair color, eye color, skin color, eye lid, etc...naturally occur among the population.

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by dragonwriter on Saturday December 10, 2022 @09:29PM (#33939449)
> Naturally blonde black people arent that uncommon.

Yes, they are, which is why every reference to “naturally blonde black people” focusses on one group—Melanesians of the Solomon Islands—as the emblrmatic group, of whom about 5-10% are naturally blonde, which would be an incredibly tiny share of the overall Black population, if they were racially Black in the first place, rather than dark skinned Pacific Islanders.

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by ashwagary on Saturday December 10, 2022 @09:40PM (#33939522)
These traits including naturally gray and white hair are recessive but they exist in the black African population, literally millions in number. People just rarely talk about or catalogue them outside of the African continent. Black subsaharan African parents give birth to children with every variety of these traits with regular frequency, this has been true for atleast all of Africa's recorded history.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by dragonwriter on Saturday December 10, 2022 @10:56PM (#33939907)
> These traits including naturally gray and white hair are recessive but they exist in the black African population, literally millions in number.

There are over a billion racially black (by recent sub-Saharan African descent) people in the world. “Literally millions” is tenths of a percent of that population—quite rare.

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by to1y on Saturday December 10, 2022 @11:33PM (#33940108)
The point is surprisingly ancient Egyptians were much closer to modern day Arabs and Europeans than modern day Egyptians who are recent migrants from sub Saharan Africa
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by Avicebron on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:24AM (#33907119)
Or maybe it's not a deception and your bias is showing? We're stuck with the history, not a made up one we want to believe.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by ashwagary on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:29AM (#33907647)
If it quacks like a duck...

I would be more skeptical of the deception idea if it was isolated and had no precedent. This Euro style global scale racism and forcefed history revision through colonization isn't a component of other major civilizations.

My statement is not controversial. I would expect 7 billion people from diverse backgrounds agree and the billion or so beneficiaries in an echo chamber disagree.

Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by frostburg on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:56AM (#33907896)
This would be somewhat more convincing if there wasn't a whole rabbit hole of "black Egypt" pseudohistory (with and without ancient aliens) - before you complain, this doesn't mean that people with dark skin weren't involved in the extremely long history of that civilization.
Re:Face to face with ancient Egyptians by ashwagary on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:03AM (#33907949)
The absurd alien narrative is a minor fringe belief at best and has no factual basis.

The history of Europeans making false self serving claims across the spectrum of knowledge on the other hands has centuries long established fact and easily proven evidence backing it.