This is not a hypothetical; all drives do fail at some point - it's just a matter of when.
The only way to be safe are external backups, not even RAID (which in unlucky cases, can suffer from serial failure).
If one really doesn't want to spend any money, an option is to periodically backup to an external drive, although cloud backups are relatively cheap and automated, nowadays. But also this is subject to localized mass-failure, ie. burglaries.
I wouldn’t recommend relying on a single drive for long-term storage of anything that’s worth more than ~$1000 - neither with SSDs nor HDDs. Freak accidents can happen with any component. You PSU can go rogue and fry your SSD, etc.
The best option is most likely a single local drive with continuous mirroring to a cloud service. The drawback is the ongoing cost of the cloud, and the possibility of partial data loss, because cloud mirroring won’t be instantenous when saving bulk data.
A local RAID1 array is cost-efficient, but doesn’t save you from black-swan events like floods or house fires.
What numbers we have show that failure rates are low, but honestly I would give it another decade or two before using SSD for persistent data storage (of important data without backups to rotating disks). I don't think we're there yet.
Alternatively you could get a NAS, they are great.
Life experience has taught me not to trust detachable drives at all
The primary issue is not the 10 to the minus X failure rate they quote, but the much more likely chance that you will lose access to the data for some reason. For example, the account is hacked, someone closes the account, or the account just deleted/restricted by the provider.
But I’d say it’s unlikely that your local copy and the cloud backup would get destroyed at the same time.
Also, when I said “cloud”, I meant a proper cloud service with an SLA like S3 Glacier, not Google Drive which gets wiped if your Google account is disabled for uploading a YouTube video with background music.
Can you tell the difference in "what if {HDD,SDD} suddenly dies and I loose everything?"?
> Also, how much is the average lifetime of a consumer-grade SSD these days?
Years.
Actually with all that TLC/QLC/xLC you can get even less than some old-time ones, but they are cheap and you can get much more than you need, so you will have plenty of resource to spare, ie if you have 250GBs of music - you can buy 1TB and have x4 'over-provision', if you have 1TB - buy 2TB or more.
And as others said, music collection is basically WORM so you probably would have the problem of finding an ancient USB3 controller to attach your ancient USB->SATA/NVME external drive for your new shiny holodeck with USB23423 in 2042 than it to die on you.
WD Blue 1TB Desktop Hard Disk Drive - 5400 RPM SATA 6Gb/s 64MB Cache 3.5 Inch - WD10EZRZ - $50
I can't say what $20 is 'substantially cheaper'. Sure, if you need dozens of TBs...
And currently you have a big chance of getting an SMR HDD, which is... quite a gamble.
I've had great luck with surplus HGST drives, they tend to be more reliable than Seagate.
Also, SSD only for music collection seems expensive. I’d get a 2TB (or whatever size seems reasonable) spinner, and put the rest of the funds towards backups (like Backblaze).
I've got a 240 GB Intel SSD with 49254 hours on it. That's 5.6 years worth of constant work. Still kicking. Not doing anything heavy though. The only reason it's still doing anything is because it's in a firewall. It does run Prometheus though, so it's not completely idle.
I would look into Blackblaze personal backup for your use case. Just make it a habbit to download and test your backups.
> Also, how much is the average lifetime of a consumer-grade SSD these days? I always think they'll die in 5 years, but that's totally out of my head and not from experience.
Some have warranty that long but the fact you wont reach TBW doesn't mean it won't lose data.
JESD218 spec only guarantees year of retention unpowered (for enterprise, 3 months for customer) soooo good fucking luck. Many manufacturers don't even say the guaranteed retention in datasheet.
Also, once you finish setup your backups make a calendar entry to test restores at least every year (preferably more often).
That retention spec is for a drive at the end of its write endurance. A drive that's less worn-out will have longer retention, more or less by definition (reduced retention is the main problem caused by the wear of writing lots of data). Also, IIRC it's one year for consumer and only 3 months for enterprise (albeit at a higher storage temperature).
It's bundled on the Ubuntu installer, though it taints the kernel.
You need a mirror or raid pool. Set the checksum to sha256 before copying your music over if you want the utmost protection.
Buy 2. Sync the devices regularly. Better to have 2 512GB drives and deal with syncing them once a while and half the space than 1 1TB drive and it's all gone due to any issue.
Never completely depend on a single storage device.
If your data is that important you'll want 3 - 2 - 1. 3 copies of data: two in different media, one offsite(offsite includes cloud these days)
Anything can always randomly suddenly fail. Low probability, but reasonably possible. So if it contains anything collectible, you'd want mirroring (ZFS is pure awesome) for availability and separate backups just in case.
But every time I get a little bit paranoid about the idea of "what if it suddenly dies and I loose everything?" and then I start thinking about backuos, at which point I'm like "nah scree this".
Are there any recommendations for particular manufacturers to look for? (Seagate, Samsung, Toshiba etc)
Also, how much is the average lifetime of a consumer-grade SSD these days? I always think they'll die in 5 years, but that's totally out of my head and not from experience.