News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by s1artibartfast on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:35PM (#33833717)
I'm curious how the carbon credits are priced and where the money goes.

Is it purely a disincentive or does it somehow work to offset the emissions?

Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by isthispermanent on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:53PM (#33834017)
It's mostly a disincentive. At least a chunk of the money goes to member countries to help transition away from fossil fuel use.

There are a variety of rules and mechanisms to ensure the money that is distributed gets spent that way. How effective those rules end up being in real life I'm unsure.

The World Wildlife Fund is one of many publications that's skeptical of the efficacy of how the money is spent: https://www.wwf.eu/?8275441/ETS-revenues-report-2022

Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by o_1 on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:55PM (#33834038)
There is no mention of alternative power sources for maritime cargo.
Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by jandrese on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:56PM (#33834057)
Carbon credits are currently mostly just a tax.

The fundamental problem with carbon markets is that there is literally no supply. In a properly functioning carbon market these carbon emitters would be buying units of "tons of carbon removed from the atmosphere". Just paying the cleanup costs of the pollution they are emitting. Very simple. The problem: nobody has any large scale carbon capture projects to buy from.

What should be happening is that carbon capture projects should be selling their services on the market and these emitters should be buying them at market prices. This would create a carbon capture economy and encourage people to find more efficient ways to do it, since a more efficient solution would produce a superior product on the marketplace and capture more sales. But all current carbon capture technology is small scale and outrageously expensive so it would crush the fossil fuel industry. But without an incentive like this the carbon capture tech will develop very slowly as it has done over the past 30 years since there is little to no demand for it.

The worst part is that even if we did decide to zero out our emissions and take the massive economic hit, it would still not account for the two centuries of CO2 buildup already in the atmosphere.

Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by klabb3 on Friday December 02, 2022 @01:38PM (#33834762)
> But without an incentive like this the carbon capture tech will develop very slowly

I don't think that's a big issue. If the tech was economically viable it wouldn't be hard to lobby for such regulation. The positive net effect is easy to prove and argue for.

I think what's stopping carbon capture has more to do with the expected efficacy of it. I mean, when you have ~400 ppm CO2 in the air it's a bit like reassembling a broken glass. Sure, you can improve every process with engineering, but there are also physical boundary conditions that look pretty bleak for most forms of CC.

> even if we did decide to zero out our emissions and take the massive economic hit, it would still not account for the two centuries of CO2 buildup already in the atmosphere.

Perhaps one step at a time? We are absolutely nowhere near zero emissions, we don't even have a plan. Our entire civilization runs on hydrocarbons today. Nothing against CC research per se, but it doesn't look like a basket where we should put many eggs in.

Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by jandrese on Friday December 02, 2022 @01:52PM (#33834996)
There is a bit of a chicken and egg problem with the tech that it won't become economically viable until it is out of the lab and being used at scale, but it will never get out of the lab until it is economically viable.

I'm a big believer in the power of markets to solve problems like this, but getting the market started is almost impossible because of the very high level of short and medium term pain associated with it. You might argue for a gradual or partial opening, but that gets forever bogged down in arguments/lawsuits over who should be included and who gets a pass and thus never really gets started.

Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by adgjlsfhk1 on Friday December 02, 2022 @02:05PM (#33835182)
The fatal flaw with this line of reasoning is that carbon capture is guaranteed (by entropy) to be energy negative. We aren't in an either or of zero out emissions or carbon capture. We need to zero out emissions *and* carbon capture. Large scale carbon capture is only viable with large excess amounts of renewable power.
Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by s1artibartfast on Friday December 02, 2022 @03:13PM (#33836233)
Seems like a reasonable solution would be to make a market for a subset of emissions and increase it slowly over time. For example, you could require 0.1% be purchased in carbon markets in scale that number up over time as the carbon Market place grows and costs go down. It seems strictly better than a flat tax that goes into the general fund.
Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by cormacrelf on Friday December 02, 2022 @01:09PM (#33834294)
It’s like a tax paid up in advance. The government can create carbon credits out of thin air, they sell them to you, you get to emit without breaking the law / getting fined. The government decides how many to create, and sets the price that way because the market decides how much being able to emit carbon is worth. The incentive is not to have to pay for them. Reduce your emissions, improve your bottom line. Simple as that.

This isn’t an offset scheme but you can buy some kinds of offset credits and use them like the basic emissions credits as essentially a license to emit. But I think there’s some rethinking of offsets as a whole concept going on, a realisation that they’re actually not producing real results and just enabling emitters to keep going longer and more cheaply. If the claimed offset is not realised, then this is a massive net loss because of the lost time spent propping up emissions. So your offset efficacy has to be really high to be tenable, but while estimates vary, the harder we look at them, the closer to 0% effective they appear to be.

Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by themitigating on Friday December 02, 2022 @01:21PM (#33834482)
Tesla would probably not exist if not for those credits.
Re:Europe Makes Shipping Vessels Pay for Carbon Emissions by bombcar on Friday December 02, 2022 @01:52PM (#33834997)
Perhaps if they never existed, but it would continue to exist as it is now without them.