News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by musk_micropenis on Thursday December 01, 2022 @12:59PM (#33819963)
A lot of angry comments in here, but the post says there's an ad-free paid version,

> Ads will give users the option to use our independent search engine with ads that don’t track them, or to sign up for ad-free paid search

Are you willing to put your money where your mouth is? Or do you expect software companies to work for free? (Presumably not the companies you work for).

Re:Brave launches private search ads by derefr on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:06PM (#33820050)
Some users — possibly Brave's core target audience — might complain that there's no way to remain anonymous in this flow: either you allow Brave to leak your info to advertisers, or you allow Brave to leak your info to Stripe in the payment flow. There's (currently) no way to pay for a Brave Premium account with crypto or through any other anonymous mechanism.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by musk_micropenis on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:09PM (#33820106)
> either you allow Brave to leak your info to advertisers

Can you expand on this? According to the article the ads are privacy-preserving but I'm open to hearing otherwise. There's not a lot of detail in the article.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by INeedMoreRam on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:35PM (#33820510)
Assuming we can trust Brave, the article clearly states: "Brave Search only uses your search query, country, and device type to show you ads, and does not keep any kind of profile of your searches."

My question to somebody who understands this more than me, by collecting query, country, device type, is that enough info to identify users?

Doesn't Brave automatically get User Agent strings, too?

Re:Brave launches private search ads by musk_micropenis on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:39PM (#33820569)
Even if that is enough to identify users, you'd have to show evidence that that information is being handed to advertisers, which is what GP accused them of.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by SV_BubbleTime on Thursday December 01, 2022 @02:53PM (#33821759)
Because this is the entire internet model, it is not at all a reach to assume there is a privacy issue.

Rather, I think you should have to prove that sending your search data OR having your credentials tied to your credit card are privacy preserving.

The burden of proof is on Brave. Not skeptical or cautious users.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by fanso99 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @05:01PM (#33823549)
Unless they mean something non-conventional, a search query, country, and device type are not enough to do any fingerprinting reliably. Some would argue that if you live in a very small country (like Vatican City) and you are the only user who searches for some obscure query on a daily basis then that's enough to identify you. But on a global scale of a search engine - no, not enough.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by autoexec on Thursday December 01, 2022 @05:19PM (#33823770)
> My question to somebody who understands this more than me, by collecting query, country, device type, is that enough info to identify users?

Collecting search queries alone is enough to identify users. see: https://www.nytimes.com/2006/08/09/technology/09aol.html

Re:Brave launches private search ads by prmoustache on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:08PM (#33820085)
Where? I don't see any account management in https://search.brave.com/
Re:Brave launches private search ads by derefr on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:09PM (#33820093)
Following the link from TFA (under "Search Premium") leads to https://account.brave.com/?intent=checkout&product=search
Re:Brave launches private search ads by prmoustache on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:12PM (#33820156)
Thanks 3$/month looks like a decent price to me. I might give it a try although I am already running an ad blocker on my browser.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by paulcole on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:26PM (#33820363)
Is there any amount for which you would’ve instantly signed up and started paying or would even $1 a month still be something you “might give a try” (read: won’t do in a million years)?
Re:Brave launches private search ads by prmoustache on Thursday December 01, 2022 @02:42PM (#33821603)
I won't pay for anything if that doesn't provide me decent search results. This is where the "might give a try" comes from and I would definitely try the version with ads first because I would hate creating an account and giving my card number to another service if I am not 100% sure I am interested. I would also want to know if I need to pay that amont per user in my household or if I would need as many accounts per family member so that the quality of our search results aren't harmed by the difference in interests/history.

3$/month seems decent to me if search results are improved over google. The 10$/month that kagi ask me for are a bit harder to swallow. Not in itself but additionned to all the other 10ish bucks services I am already subscribed to (streaming, backup, etc). There is simply a limit/month I am willing to spend on the whole package and if I spend say n$/month on a search engine per user I will unsubscribe to other services of the same cost. And this is something I may have to negociate with my partner.

The good thing is it is easier to move from and to a paying search engine than say, an instant messaging service.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by paulcole on Thursday December 01, 2022 @03:20PM (#33822143)
Jesus Christ. First it was $3/month seems like a decent price that you might try if you weren’t already running an ad blocker. Then it’s there’s no price cheap enough if it’s not decent search results. Then it’s well I need to know how many people per account and then it’s I’d have to talk it over with my partners.

You can just say there’s a 0% chance you’d pay $1 a month and that you’d always have an excuse for why this option isn’t good enough for your high standards.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by prmoustache on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:19PM (#33822925)
hmmm no.

What is the use of paying a service if the search engine results are so crap you will use something else in the end?

Re:Brave launches private search ads by paulcole on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:30PM (#33823084)
> Thanks 3$/month looks like a decent price to me. I might give it a try

From everything you said since, it sounds like you had no intention of giving it a try.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by blacksmith_tb on Thursday December 01, 2022 @03:36PM (#33822355)
At $1 it would be a no-brainer for me, but one possible argument I can see is that a flat fee is a funny arrangement here - I pay $3/mo if I make 100 searches a day, or 1, or none. If the idea is that it would only be fair to Brave to pay them for what they aren't making by showing me ads, you might think it would make more sense to have me pay for exactly how much they lose, not less or more?
Re:Brave launches private search ads by paulcole on Thursday December 01, 2022 @06:06PM (#33824300)
> you might think it would make more sense to have me pay for exactly how much they lose, not less or more

You might think that, yes.

Why is the flat fee “funny”? Netflix, Spotify, NYT, etc. all charge the flat fee. In fact I’m having a hard time thinking of any non-flat-fee consumer digital products.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by blacksmith_tb on Friday December 02, 2022 @12:30AM (#33827180)
Well in broad terms those also are getting paid up front or making you watch / listen to ads instead, sure. In the case of SEM, the industry puts kind of a lot of energy into tracking ads, so it seems a little more straightforward to know how much I'm worth to them. But in more general terms, if we ever manage to sort out micropayments, I would prefer to pay as I go for everything - imagine the flat rate subscription model for say, your energy or water bill: "we're charging about what most families would use in a month; you say you're not a family of four? too bad."
Re:Brave launches private search ads by paulcole on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:50AM (#33829811)
> if we ever manage to sort out micropayments, I would prefer to pay as I go for everything

I wouldn’t hold my breath lol.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by ericholscher on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:43PM (#33820635)
Glad to see other folks investing in ethical advertising. It's something we've been working on for a long time over at https://ethicalads.io/ -- and it's an important step forward in improving how ads are served. With the advances in ML, we're investing in content-based ads, which we can do as a display network. But search ads have so much context built in, they don't need to track you.

> A lot of angry comments in here, but the post says there's an ad-free paid version,

People in the comments here who have expectations that products be free, but also not include ads, are a continual problem with the discourse around this stuff. It's quite tiring and repetitive. Brave is even giving you the option to opt out of ads by paying a very reasonable $3/mo. I'm not sure what else you could ask for -- ads that don't surveil you, and the option to pay a reasonable amount to opt out of them.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by encryptluks2 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @10:57PM (#33826584)
LOL. Ethical ads is like saying rape can be ethical.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by alpaca128 on Friday December 02, 2022 @07:01AM (#33829416)
Ads just like sex are ethical if they're consensual.

If I want to buy a product and want to see what exists, ads can actually be helpful sometimes. I don't want to see them in any other situation, though, and it doesn't ever justify tracking.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:57PM (#33820867)
Can I just get unobtrusive relevant ads without tracking? I didn't mind the search ads on Google back in the day before they got egregious and greedy.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by secretj on Thursday December 01, 2022 @03:02PM (#33821897)
So the ads you see are just based on country, type of device (windows,linux,macos,android or ios), and your search term, which is the minimum you really need for relevance. But these are not kept in any sort of tracking profile and Brave doesn't know anything about you, or queries across sessions. And unlike most of the search engines out there right now, we are motivated to ensure that the ads do not become a mess that buries organic results.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by criddell on Thursday December 01, 2022 @03:10PM (#33822010)
Why is type of device needed for relevance? I can think of specific searches where maybe it could matter, but generally I don't think it does.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by marginalia_nu on Friday December 02, 2022 @04:09AM (#33828378)
Says at least something about socioeconomic status. Although I think less than one might imagine.