Re:Jewish revenge after the Holocaust: How one group plotted...
by GameOfFrowns on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:09PM
(#33779691)
Didn't stop them from executing the Nakba against the inhabitants of Palestine already in 1948[0].
On top of that, the irony of poisoning the water supply is thick, since Jews had been accused of poisoning wells for hundreds of years at that point[1].
Re:Jewish revenge after the Holocaust: How one group plotted...
by graymatters on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:28PM
(#33782943)
Your comment shows you have absolutely no clue about history and what the so called Nakba was. The fleeing of guest worker Arabs (brought there by the British during the 1920s-1940s, while preventing the persecuted Jews from finding asylum there) from the land of Israel was the result of Syria, Iraq, Egypt and the British puppet kingdom of Trans-Jordan armies invading Israel the next day of its establishment. The only catastrophe of these Arabs was that the Israelis did not do to them what they would’ve done to the Israeli Jews had the Arabs won the war (or any other war they waged against the Jews before and after the state of Israel was established).
Re:Jewish revenge after the Holocaust: How one group plotted...
by unmole on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:38PM
(#33783416)
What are these, alternative facts? Pray tell us who lived in Palestine before the British seized control and declared their intention to establish a Jewish homeland. Europeans persecuted Jews for centuries and finally decided to deal with the Jewish question by displacing Arabs.
The overwhelming majority of Palestinian Arabs were displaced before the Israeli Declaration of Independence. The Nakba was not a reaction to the invasion.
Re:Jewish revenge after the Holocaust: How one group plotted...
by aj7 on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:10PM
(#33779707)
I wouldn’t take this too seriously. Israel, armed to the teeth with nuclear weapons and a battle-hardened military, is, in real life, vastly more powerful militarily than the much-larger Germany.
Re:Jewish revenge after the Holocaust: How one group plotted...
by GameOfFrowns on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:16PM
(#33779811)
Can you explain what you are referring to? What has contrasting the military capabilities of Germany and Israel have to do with the subject of the article?
Re:Jewish revenge after the Holocaust: How one group plotted...
by aj7 on Monday December 05, 2022 @01:48PM
(#33869937)
What I meant was this. What was described was an unofficial, non-state, conspiracy by Jewish partisans to right a wrong or take revenge, in their eyes. It was apparently somewhere between a flop and a fantasy.
Meanwhile, the Jewish STATE took action, resulting in a two-decade development program, where, IRONICALLY, they became more powerful militarily than the German state.
IRONICALLY. NOTHING was meant to be construed as hostility or potential retribution by Israel against Germany.
I had thought people would have come to these conclusions automatically, but now I realize I have to be more explicit in explaining these comments.
On top of that, the irony of poisoning the water supply is thick, since Jews had been accused of poisoning wells for hundreds of years at that point[1].
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nakba
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitic_trope#Well_poisoni...
-They didn't care at that point
(Not) funny fact: statements "not the same people" and "the same people" are considered both true at the same time.
The overwhelming majority of Palestinian Arabs were displaced before the Israeli Declaration of Independence. The Nakba was not a reaction to the invasion.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plan_A_(film)
Meanwhile, the Jewish STATE took action, resulting in a two-decade development program, where, IRONICALLY, they became more powerful militarily than the German state.
IRONICALLY. NOTHING was meant to be construed as hostility or potential retribution by Israel against Germany.
I had thought people would have come to these conclusions automatically, but now I realize I have to be more explicit in explaining these comments.
I will refrain from eating fish next time I'm in France.