But I feel like it taught me to be bored with eating, and to establish a more healthy relationship with food. High-fat, mid-protein, low-carb sounds terrific for the first day or two but once you're two weeks in, you're so sick of it all that you'd just as soon drink some water and get back to whatever you're doing.
Also if I don’t eat right as I feel hungry I’ll feel as if someone has gut punched me. I get absurdly hungry.
As for the "gut punch" though, sounds like gastritis or something. Unless you're being metaphorical. For me, water helps when I'm fasting and stomach pains start.
Likewise, I've noticed an effect develop with artificial sweeteners where I can have small amounts without difficulty, but if I start consuming it several times in a 48 hour span, I get cramps.
In periods where I've become addicted to carbs hunger pain is much stronger, but I've been able to keep it down for many years now. So if you're getting it intensely, your gut is probably still reactivating to its old profile.
I believe restriction in the regular diet is one way of correcting it while staying in a routine. But I have also experimented with fasting, intense exercise, hot/cold contrast in the shower, and breathing exercises, and the common theme to each is to challenge homeostasis in some fashion. Obviously there's always some danger in going too far, but if our norm is total comfort, we can definitely drop some aspect of it from time to time.
Part of that might be from less water retention early on.
Your body holds on to more water when your diet is full of carbs. As your liver runs down its glycogen stores and you eventually go into ketosis, you lose a lot of water. That's also there the early 'keto flu' comes from, which is a bit like a hangover; plenty of fluids and electrolytes fix you.
Losing water looks great on the scale. On the one hand, it doesn't actually do anything for you healthwise. On the other hand, losing that water ain't bad for your health either (assuming enough fluids and electrolytes), and is a great motivator for the kickstart you described.
Wouldn't this advise need to keep in mind absolute height? BMI tracks the ratio between the height and weight, but it does nothing to tell the difference between a short thin person and a taller heavier (but same BMI) person. The latter which would need more calories than the former. I know people who eat ~400 kcal less than me per day, because they are shorter and similarly thinner. Following that why wouldn't their crash diet threshold be sufficiently lower?
How true is it? I don't know. But even then I don't see why they couldn't take multivitamins.
It's probably a mistake to connect the two.
Yes, we Americans overeat beef / Hamburgers, but I don't think anyone eating burgers is at huge risk of malnutrition... as much as a risk of heart problems, diabetes, cholesterol, etc. etc.
It turns out that a standard burger with beef, ketchup, lettuce, onion, and bread covers most of your macro, and even micro-nutrients. It also is way overboard on salt and fats, but... that's not the particular problem here.
One of the bigger problems vegetarians have is finding a proper replacement of meat and all of the easy nutrients meat contains. All amino acids, various vitamins, iron, etc. etc. There's a fair amount of nutrients here.
And even the worst McDonalds burger contains a variety of lettuce / onions / ketchup that covers few nutrients that beef is missing (ex: Ketchup has Vitamin A, Potatoes / Fries has Vitamin C).
The amount of lettuce, tomatoes and onions is so minimal I doubt it contributes to your vitamin intake in any useful manner. If you eat a salad you get 50x that amount of those vitamins.
Pretty strongly disagree here. US Beef consumption is about the same as in early 1900's, which was a time where personal health in several metrics was far better. (Weight being the obvious one)
Always very skeptical when people talk about cholesterol, it's a really nuanced topic, but the average person seems to be stuck in the 1970's with "cholesterol bad". Thinking high ldl is always bad is only slightly better.
If you eat only the beef and veggies from a Big Mac three times a day you'll get plenty of vitamins and minerals with minimal calories (~650 calories)
If you eat the three entire Big Mac meals you won't get any more essential nutrients to speak of and you'll consume far too many calories (3960 calories)
The average american has junk to cut from their diets with no nutritional loss whatsoever. Typically fried and sugary foods.
Practically pure proteins can be provided by turkey breast or chicken breast, adding e.g. around 300 kcal for an adequate daily protein intake, and the rest of the food can be composed of non-starchy non-sweet non-oily vegetables, which provide only about 20 to 50 kcal per 100 grams. One could eat more than 1 kg of various such vegetables without exceeding 800 kcal.
There remain a few things that would have to be taken from supplements, e.g. omega-3 fatty acids, vitamin B12, vitamin D3 and vitamin E (which is abundant only in high-caloric food, like olive oil or almonds). The simplest is just to take one pill per day of those offered by various vendors, which include all the essential vitamins and minerals, to be sure that none of them is insufficient.
A little vegetable oil would be needed for linoleic acid.
We both come from a South Asian background and discussed how the number would change for a home cooked vegetarian diet which is more nutrient dense but low in protein, and I was told that would lower it below 1200, but he didn't feel comfortable recommending that diet unsupervised. He emphasized that I should decrease calories by removing carbs, then fats, then proteins. And that I should prioritize eating proteins above fats and carbs, especially if I planned on increasing the amount of exercise I did.
I asked him if the 1200kcal was net or gross. For example if I did 2 hours of moderate exercise, should I eat back 400kcal+ to maintain a net 1200kcal. He didn't have an answer for me, other than saying, if I start to feel weak or lightheaded I should immediately stop exercising. I don't have pre-existing conditions related to blood glucose, but I imagine that would would change many of these guidelines. I was told to stay mindful of hydration.
The stories I hear of fasted work outs is the reason I asked him about low calorie diets. My non professional intuition makes me believe that even intense cardio should be okay, but moderate or heavy resistance training should be avoided on a low calorie diet.
There is no reason to avoid resistance training.
I also imagined that muscle recovery would be less efficient or take longer from a fasted state. I have hit rowing/ERG goals and made time improvements so I feel comfortable saying that fasting doesn't hinder my cardio.
I understand that energy goals are correlated with body size, we were discussing a general minimum kcal threshold for unsupervised dieting. I am unsure why you feel estimated BMR/RMR - 200 kcal is unscientific. I was told that without supervision, it would be hard to ensure proper nutrition on a very low calorie diet. Additionally, he expected that some people would fall into a binge-restrict cycle because they can't sustain their usual energy level.
I was additionally curious because there have been days I forget to eat, and thinking back I realized my total calories for those 24 hours totaled less than 600 kcal.
Fortunately it's fairly cheap and easy for people in developed countries to obtain an RMR test. This can then be used as a personal baseline to calibrate diet plans.
If someone dangerously obese maintains hydration, electrolytes, vitamins, and enough lipids to empty the gallbladder, getting to a low adipose tissue state, resetting insulin, ghrelin, and leptin sensitivities, and reducing the likelier risks of cancer(s) seems like a good tradeoff than either lap-band surgery or slow/plateau weight reductions.
Intense hunger goes away after about 72-80 hours of "starvation", however brain fog and low energy dominate. Careful "starvation" dieting down to slightly underweight isn't something one can do without several months of spare time, ready access to healthcare, and immense self-control. Afterwards, self-control is absolutely required to avoid binge cycles.
GLP-1 agonists are expensive but interesting crutches to get there.
It is likely that over millions of years of natural selection, the human body is far more tolerant of borderline starvation conditions than being stuffed with HFCS. Many types of cancers associated with Western diets are likely due to the human body becoming more hospitable, whereas chemotherapy and starvation add cellular stress that kills off malfunctioning cells. It's likely no accident whereas CHD, gout, diabetes, high cholesterol, and cancers are the consequent of unnatural diets and lifestyles.
Why stop at getting rid of glucose? Add some plasma donations and orlistat. Now you've got balanced macro loss!
(don't do this)
(I actually donate whole blood and platelets often.)
If someone were carrying around an extra 250 Mcal in adipose tissue, multiple factors determine what their risk budget could/should be to downsize to a suitable homeostatic state.
I lost 60 lbs over a couple of years and set a state lifting record for my age group. I love what I do and kept the excess weight off. I got good at what I do and the intrinsic reward still burns, even though I’m not lifting for records anymore. I wake up every day ready to go hard for at least 50 minutes. It doesn’t take me more time than that to stay in shape, but I do eat consistent with my goals.. which is the harder part.
I personally think someone needs to really own their desired outcome and then there are many valid and healthy ways — and even more “effective” ones — to get there. Hard to measure “own” though. Measuring every different kind of modality is generally missing the point. We actually know how people get in shape and stay in shape. The problem is generally in the mind.
Losing weight that fast generally means it comes back pretty quickly as well.
> I lost 60 lbs over a couple of years
That's a much more reasonable timeframe. It's almost like we have to trick our bodies into finding a new metabolic balance. Do it too quickly and it just rebounds. Do it more slowly and it seems to be more sustainable.
I was under the impression it was like trying to fight drug addiction and the chances of you sustaining it and not relapsing/making up the missed calories later as near impossible for most once you’ve become addicted enough to things like Diet Coke, Chik-Fil-A, etc.
what i did was cook for myself so i can reduce vegetable oils, salts, artificial flavorings etc, then cook things like fresh tomato sauces with fresh basil/oregano, fresh fish cooked slowly in plum sauce, chana masala curries with low sodium and delicious spices etc etc
once you get used to healthy, satisfying and flavorful "good" food, carbs, salt, oil and junk food cravings faded away and buying snacks after that was just not satisfying at all...
n=1 and all that, but that was my experience fwiw
As for being difficult… yeah. The transition sucked. Body aches, headache, and very slight case of the blues. It took willpower. After about 3 days, I was okay. It was similar to quitting smoking for me, except that quitting smoking didn’t give me body aches.
I think something like Tex-Mex would easily allow for clean eating. Avocado toast, with whole grain bread is fairly healthy and was an absolute favorite of mine after workouts and I would consider it "American" food. Tacos are a great way to have good portion control and also feel filled. Allowing non-traditional recipes opens many options. Avocado grapefruit salad on tortillas with fried tortilla strips is a recipe I came across recently that I really enjoyed. I think non-traditional is the essence of true "American" food.
For fast food, Popeye's Blackened tenders are not breaded, a 5 piece serving is listed at 280 kcal compared to the classic tenders being 740 kcal. Nuts or apple slices with peanut butter is a fairly filling snack and can easily fit within 200 kcal. The main thing you would have to look out for is sodium if cooking at home is difficult. I know most of my bodybuilder friends go to a diet of chicken breast and brown rice for dinner for months at a time when they want to cut. It's around 400-500 calories depending on how you prepared it.
Vegetarian and vegan recipes are good starting points for cleaner eating too. Borrowing from other cuisine makes it a lot easier as well. I love preparing vegetable side dishes for dinner in the way it's prepared for Korean dishes. Miso soup is fantastic for when I have food cravings late in the night. It's not "American" but I'd argue there's nothing more American than making microwave miso soup at 3 am in my star wars mug. Coffee is popular too, and is very low calorie if you can get used to no milk or sugar, or only sugar alcohol/substitutes.
For some context, I grew up and live in one of the most culturally diverse states and counties in the US. I know that not everywhere in the US has the same diversity of food options, but I would argue that Amazon has done a lot to make food accessible.
The one meal per day limit makes it hard to over/eat.
It seems either this is extremely tricky to measure, or it is a myth (like aspartame or MSG or yellow 5 cause cancer or whatever).
On the other side are people that say, "eat less, exercise more".
Lots of people have chosen either one of these to be true. It is certainly possible, though.
It is entirely possible that something that was done for a long time is a healthy thing just as it is entirely possible that it was a terrible thing that we conquered with knowledge and abundance. Evidence is what tells you if the thing falls into one of those categories.
I like living in a time where we are outraged if children in our community die and in cases where there was nothing that could have been done we want to do research to find something we can do in the future. That was not normal for millennia until really very recently and it seems healthy to me?
Is this actually true? I thought archaic humans had much better dental outcomes because their diets had a small fraction of the sugars that modern diets do. Could be wrong but I was definitely under the impression that poor dental health was more a function of modern diet and not something that necessarily existed throughout history.
Feel free to nit-pick that example, there are an absolute plethora of others. When did surviving appendicitis become a thing? What was the median life expectancy for a newborn baby at various times in history? Calling out the fetishism of humans in a "natural state" needs to be done. Just as there are things we can learn from our pre-historic existence. Evidence is obviously the required thing not just amusing anecdote about how we have totally "lost our way."
Certain palms are also (and have been for... Again I don't know, but I believe 'a very long time') 'milked' for a sugary sap that's drunk fresh or fermented.
Being the norm historically does not imply it is healthy or optimal, only that it is at least survivable on average.
I mean if you have some pre-existing disease sure. If you’re on certain diuretics you may screw up your blood chemistry, but an otherwise healthy, overweight person eating less than 1200 kcal/day? Maybe not the most efficient way to lose weight but it’s far from “dangerous”.
One company working to reverse diabetes in the US is https://www.virtahealth.com/ (disclaimer: I work there).
The general advice, even from my primary care physician, has been that anything less than 1200kcal/day is dangerous and is crash dieting. Looking around, I found this other study studying total diet replacement providing 810kcal/day as the sole food for 12 weeks, showed significantly greater weight loss compared to standard counseling and modest energy restrictions. The difference in weight loss was measured at 12 months. (BMJ 2018;362:k3760 [1])
25 BMI, which the diabetes study used in addition to T2D, is not considered clinically obese in the US. 25 BMI is the line between clinically normal and overweight. I wonder if crash dieting is advised against on the assumption that most people will go back to unhealthy eating habits instead of changing their diet, and also become more likely to fall into binge-restrict cycles. It's easy to imagine that if someone is able to make meaningful changes, crash dieting is more effective than most other methods.
[1] https://www.bmj.com/content/362/bmj.k3760