News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Narcissistic Collapse by 1attice on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:10AM (#33763908)
Not every meltdown is narcissistic collapse?

Sometimes, it happens because you're terrified. Which, frankly, is where my LGBTQ ass is right now.

Because Musk's wife left him for a trans woman and his daughter transitioned and disowned him and *immediately after that* he spent 44 billion to eradicate a 'woke mind virus'.

I'm scared because every day or two I see another article on HN that uses Free Speech, a precious and vital political freedom, as a way of spreading fear and hate. And I see the heads nodding along.

You all see exactly what this is and you are pretending otherwise.

Now hurry; greytext a viewpoint you disagree with.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by the_doctah on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:16AM (#33763964)
>I'm scared because every day or two I see another article on HN that uses Free Speech, a precious and vital political freedom, as a way of spreading fear and hate. And I see the heads nodding along.

And you, like seemingly increasing amounts of people, fail to understand the mechanics of free speech. The part you don't understand is that hate is protected. And that is just as important to protect as any other free speech.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by yunwal on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:26AM (#33764089)
Yet another person who doesn’t understand that the first amendment doesn’t give nazis the right to have their views distributed by an online forum. Sad!
Re:Narcissistic Collapse by the_doctah on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:31AM (#33764147)
Nazi rhetoric is so lazy and reddited. And your comment is useless without examples.

With anti-free-speech advocates continually trying to expand the definition of what constitutes "hate speech", we could be talking about totally different things.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by greenhorn360 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:55AM (#33764350)
Any speech that advocates violence towards, lies or misconstrues as to make a group seem violent, or describes an outgroup as a disease.

As applied to the groups of people Nazi Germany imprisoned or killed on a large scale or burned books and information about.

The definition isn't expanding. You (and most of us) just weren't taugt in school that groups other than the Jews were targeted.

And no, the Nazi rhetoric as you dismiss it isn't lazy, false, or uncalled for. It's the closest parallel to what's happening in the US right now.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by the_doctah on Sunday November 27, 2022 @12:10PM (#33764537)
The examples you're using have always been illegal. Threats, libel, slander will get your speech removed from any platform.

I don't know too much about their correlation with Nazism though.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by yunwal on Sunday November 27, 2022 @03:41PM (#33766687)
Threats, libel, and slander must be directed towards a specific person
Re:Narcissistic Collapse by 1attice on Sunday November 27, 2022 @05:58PM (#33767902)
Well, what about something like 'The Libs of Tiktok', a Twitter account that routinely posts the home addresses of trans people? They get away with this by posting the address on its own, but against a trans-symbol background.

Technically, they haven't threatened anyone, but the threat of stochastic violence is legimately chilling to that 'vigorous open free speech debate' that we supposedly all want, and that is so untroubling to so many freeze-peachers speaks volumes.

You can have physical intimidation or free speech, pick any one.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by kinnic on Sunday November 27, 2022 @12:10PM (#33764529)
Only a fraction of the people being referred to as Nazis in contemporary, largely-online discourse are saying anything close to this though. It's a routinely misapplied term.
Re:Narcissistic Collapse by yunwal on Sunday November 27, 2022 @03:44PM (#33766736)
The term is irrelevant here. No matter who you are, you don't have the right to have your viewpoints amplified by a private platform unless your viewpoints qualify as protected speech.
Re:Narcissistic Collapse by fzeroracer on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:22AM (#33764036)
Well no, depending on where you live 'hate' is not protected for one. And for two, it should be obvious that there is no such even handed methods of protection going on, considering how quickly Twitter is banning even mildly left-leaning voices under false pretenses elevated by liars and charlatans.

There is no 'free speech' being protected. It's speech for me and not for thee. Which is hypocritical coming from Musk.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by luckylion on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:38AM (#33764213)
> Twitter is banning even mildly left-leaning voices under false pretenses elevated by liars and charlatans.

Who? That one comedian who impersonated Musk? She has been reinstated, hasn't she?

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by 1attice on Sunday November 27, 2022 @02:35PM (#33765933)
off the top of my head: Crimethinc, a relatively boring and old leftist site, was banned recently and not reinstated AFAIK.

There was that Friedman guy yesterday.

Refusing to stick out your hand does not make the rain go away.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by luckylion on Sunday November 27, 2022 @03:05PM (#33766251)
They were banned a few days ago, it seems -- unclear why, it sounds like the called for violence (against Tesla no less), but it's so full of "the capitalist fascists are murdering us"-crazy-level rhetoric that it's hard to find out what happened.

I don't know who "that Friedman guy" is, but I did read that Musk announced a general amnesty. No clue if they are included, I assume it depends on the (given) reason for the ban.

It's hard to tell. Whenever I look at something on Twitter, I still see left-wingers posting, but I assume if they're not banned they're not real leftists and that's not a counter-example etc. Movements should really go back to officially recognizing members so we can discuss these things more easily!

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by 1attice on Sunday November 27, 2022 @03:54PM (#33766832)
Dude, the capitalist spent 44 BILLION dollars to fight the "woke mind virus". He proceeded by inducing Twitter to shed most of its LGBT, Black and female workforce -- those before/after team pics are gutting, and easily googled.

You get that that is literally how fascism do, right?

This phase is called "Gleischaltung".

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by indy on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:34AM (#33771484)
It's difficult to argue about the woke mind virus with someone who is suffering from the woke mind virus.

Not everything is fascism.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by 1attice on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:19AM (#33774651)
describing your opponent as "infected" is, in the most literal sense, dehumanizing.

In this instance, for example, you used it as an excuse to stop thinking and talking.

That's all that's needed. It scales.

Fascism is a process, not a toggle. And currently, it's processing you.

Read your Adrendt. I am also available on this thread to continue explaining it.

Re:Narcissistic Collapse by indy on Monday November 28, 2022 @05:33PM (#33780847)
Oh no, you've caught me red handed 1attice, I am indeed a fascist. I would have gotten away with it if it weren't for your brilliant insight, you truly are an amazing person protecting the marginalised communities from evil. Truly a life well spent, your father must be very proud to have a son like you.
Re:Narcissistic Collapse by the_doctah on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:31AM (#33764151)
I didn't say anything about Twitter.
Re:Narcissistic Collapse by 1attice on Sunday November 27, 2022 @04:21PM (#33767102)
I'm always distressed when Americans act like this isn't a problem that Germany's strong anti-hate laws had to solve years ago, successfully.

Which isn't to say that hate speech is solved problem in Germany -- but this ontological handwringing about separating it from regular speech is disingenuous. See https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/germanys-laws-ant... for example.

My understanding (as a non-German citizen who lived there for a year, in the '00s) is that while the line between hate speech and regular speech might be open to debate in Germany, no one debates that there is a line.

In other words, the existence of the distinction is recognized even though it is irredeemably vague. This is important: there is a recognized, valid ontological category for vague distinctions!

To non-American ears, the U.S. debate around free speech sounds a lot like one person shouting 'squares and circles are different and can be treated differently,' and another pointing out that, because squircles exist, the slope is too slippery to acknowledge the reality of squares and circles.

But you know what? You can still make one of these pretty good: https://www.etsy.com/nz/listing/867606078/fisher-price-shape...

This pattern is employed on both sides of the aisle -- my fellow leftists do it to, particularly around issues of gender. (And I say that as a trans woman.)

The only thing worse than a pink-is-for-girls transphobe coming at me and telling me that gender isn't real is a nonbinary polyamorous anarchist telling me that gender isn't real, and those are basically my options in 2022.

The next protest I attend, I'm bringing a sign saying 'clastic, ad-hoc, and vague ontological distinctions are still real distinctions' but this is why I'm not really invited to protests