News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ooh.directory by s3000 on Wednesday November 23, 2022 @01:48PM (#33723059)
This is the best thing for RSS in a long time. What I miss though for RSS streams is commenting. 'Nobody' reads the articles on link aggregators. In a way, RSS is a link aggregator that limits its user base to the ones who read and don't comment.

I am wondering what will happen if RSS readers find a way to share comments on posts. Maybe ActivityPub makes that possible.

The only service of which I am aware that allows for comments on RSS is https://linklonk.com/ . Are there other approaches to bring comments to RSS streams?

Maybe ooh.directory can use ActivityPub to allow commenting and voting on the entries. Comments on HN are great to check for problems with an article. That should also be true for comments about entire blogs.

Re:Ooh.directory by rambambram on Wednesday November 23, 2022 @01:58PM (#33723179)
> What I miss though for RSS streams is commenting.

>In a way, RSS is a link aggregator that limits its user base to the ones who read and don't comment.

I share this view. What do you think about a concept wherein a collection of followed feeds is presented in a timeline with the possibility to 'comment' with an email form? It will look like a regular comment textarea under some blogpost, but the commenting is done by email. The reaction isn't immediately visible under the blogpost (if at all) and therefor everything works humanly slow. But there's also no signup required, so it's more anonymous and openly accessible.

Re:Ooh.directory by s3000 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @03:22AM (#33728928)
>a collection of followed feeds is presented in a timeline with the possibility to 'comment'

From my point of view, that's the future.

Using mail is dangerous because it is another protocol, and it still requires account management because nobody will post to arbitrary pages with their primary mail address. That said, mail still has the potential to become the standard for social networks.

Why should comments not be immediately visible? People can already write mails to authors. That's not what builds momentum. The interesting part is the interaction of the audience.

We can build social interaction that improves direct human interaction in the same way that cars improve human movement. I wouldn't focus on slowing it down but on speeding up the filtering so that it is easy to find the individually preferred audience among all possible reactions to an url. The difficult part is to maintain group identities and momentum when all comments are dissected and re-aggregated.

It's problematic to manage comments on the server of a blog post. This creates silos and echo chambers because it is difficult to find the comments of a user on other blogs and creators rarely allow their audience to create their own posts. Newspapers with their comment sections already offer that protocol. We have Facebook because newspapers missed out on coming together and offering the missing parts.

What is missing at Linklonk, apart from opening up to ActivityPub, is long-term conversations on posts. On aggregators like HN, there is an audience at the top comments. Hardly anybody writes comments on old posts. To make comments on off-momentum articles worthwhile, it would be necessary to have a notification function that is triggered not only by replies but also by new comments when they pass a threshold.

Re:Ooh.directory by rambambram on Thursday November 24, 2022 @02:06PM (#33735083)
Thanks for your reply.

> Why should comments not be immediately visible? People can already write mails to authors. That's not what builds momentum. The interesting part is the interaction of the audience.

I agree, but I was thinking of some filtering function wherein the webmaster can whitelist/blacklist comments. If a certain site or topic attracts - for whatever reason - visitors who abuse the comments, the webmaster needs to be able to block stuff afterwards or even upfront. An ideal life would be wherein every visitor/commenter does only nice things.

> Hardly anybody writes comments on old posts.

Interesting idea. I always like it when I get responses on my videos/comments on Youtube from years ago.

Re:Ooh.directory by lonk11 on Friday November 25, 2022 @08:03AM (#33741992)
LinkLonk supports comment notifications for any item that you have subscribed to. You get notified through browser notifications and email. And you can mute/follow individual branches of the comment tree. Details: https://linklonk.com/item/396040801387544576

There is definitely more to improve, but I'd like to see more use of the comments section first to know what needs to be improved next.

As for ActivityPub, I just saw https://go-fed.org/ on HN and it looks like a good fit to add ActivityPub support to LinkLonk (since it is written in Go). There are multiple ways to do it, so let me know how you would like to see it working. Do you want to follow posts of Mastodon users on LinkLonk (similar to how it shows you RSS content)? Do you want Mastodon users to be able to follow your channels on LinkLonk (e.g. @[email protected])?

Re:Ooh.directory by s3000 on Friday November 25, 2022 @03:01PM (#33746204)
>LinkLonk supports comment notifications ... can mute/follow individual branches

Great!

>how you would like to see it working

That's a difficult question. My primary focus is on the availability of discussions. Nevertheless, integrating LinkLonk in both directions with Mastodon should help with growth. There doesn't seem to be an algorithmic timeline, which LinkLonk could provide. Establishing LinkLonk as an integrated RSS Reader and ActivityPub Client could attract a bigger user base that makes calculating suggestions easier.

What ActivityPub can bring to new social networks like LinkLonk is the ability to share the comment section with various other providers. E.g. RSS readers or annotating browser plugins can pool their comments in one place to have an active discussion even if each tool has a small user number.

However, pooling discussions is generally avoided:

1. When there is a dupe on HN, the discussion in the old submission is not continued.

2. There exist various aggregators like lobste.rs, reddit.com/programming or tildes.net, that almost discuss the same articles as HN, but they are different communities.

3. Twitter and Mastodon could pool the replies to posts of the same url, but they don't.

The trivial approach for LinkLonk would be an integration with lemmy.ml and all Mastodon posts that discuss the same URL. That way, most posts would come with a discussion and LinkLonk instantly had a vibrant community.

With the pool-avoiding behavior in mind, some adjustments could be needed but I haven't figured out what that could be.

Re:Ooh.directory by mawise on Wednesday November 23, 2022 @07:37PM (#33726424)
> I am wondering what will happen if RSS readers find a way to share comments on posts

The IndieWeb community is focused on this with Social Readers[1] and Webmentions[2]. The core idea is your reader also ties into your own published feed, so you can make a comment right in your reader that publishes the comment to your own feed and sends a webmention to the original article so they know about it.

Barriers to entry are still kinda high (much like making a website 25 years ago) so any adoption should lead to a better signal/noise ratio. Unless it becomes popular enough for bots to start spamming the webmentions...

[1]: https://indieweb.org/social_reader

[2]: https://indieweb.org/Webmention

Re:Ooh.directory by account42 on Thursday November 24, 2022 @07:45AM (#33730686)
Webmention depends on the original source to link back to those comments for discovery though, right? I think perhaps a better approach would be a way to comment on any URL and see comments from other users (or communities) that you have subscribed to. That way the author of the content being discussed is not in a position to limit the discussion to what they approve of and you can discuss things that are not even opted into this system.

Ideally this system would also be integrated into browsers you you can see and write comments even when visiting a URL directly.

Re:Ooh.directory by mawise on Thursday November 24, 2022 @08:56PM (#33738307)
Thats exactly what my vision is for comments on Haven[1]. Without webmentions, you're just telling your friends/followers what you think which enables private comments/conversations on public content.

[1]:https://havenweb.org

Re:Ooh.directory by msephton on Thursday November 24, 2022 @07:54AM (#33730765)
I at the end of each of my blog posts I include a link to the tweet where I announced the post. Works well for me. If Twitter dies I guess I'll have to swap them out at some point.

Alternatively, you could use something like a Discus embed for comments but I didn't want to have one more thing to manage.