News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by ghuntley on Monday November 21, 2022 @01:20PM (#33695933)
Technical write up by the security researcher at https://emily.id.au/tailscale

ps. she's looking an employer rn // hire her!

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by tailspin2019 on Monday November 21, 2022 @01:38PM (#33696166)
> The speed and quality of Tailscale's response to our report is unlike any vendor interaction I have experienced, and suggests a deep commitment to keeping their customers safe.

I have mixed feelings here as a Tailscale customer.

Yes a quick response is great, but this actual security issue is pretty terrible IMHO.

Anything other than an immediate response would have been akin to lighting their company on fire and walking away.

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by bombcar on Monday November 21, 2022 @01:46PM (#33696269)
Your username would have been a good option for a cutesy name for the vulnerability, however.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by hellcow on Monday November 21, 2022 @01:50PM (#33696315)
> Anything other than an immediate response would have been akin to lighting their company on fire and walking away.

Have we forgotten Zoom, who reinstalled itself secretly on user machines with an RCE-vulnerable server, which they described as “working as intended?” They’re still wildly popular today with organizations despite the insane lack of regard for security and their users’ safety.

Mistakes happen. I applaud Tailscale for moving so quickly and doing the right thing.

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by xmodem on Monday November 21, 2022 @02:36PM (#33696861)
I would caution against grading on a curve
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by bobbylarrybobby on Monday November 21, 2022 @06:32PM (#33699712)
The users of tailscale and of zoom expect very different things from their respective software vendors
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by acuteaura on Monday November 21, 2022 @03:25PM (#33697450)
As the reporting party of the much less severe (and much less interesting) TS-2022-003[1] I can confirm that vendor interaction is also swift when not responding would not light the company on fire. In fact there were several other vendors that were affected that have yet to mitigate it.

[1]: https://notes.acuteaura.net/posts/github-enterprise-security...

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by loa_in_ on Monday November 21, 2022 @04:47PM (#33698469)
> Anything other than an immediate response would have been akin to lighting their company on fire and walking away.

Companies get away with sweeping customer security issues under the rug less and less, but still far too often. I honestly wish we as a people would put other players of this game in as high standards as you do here for this company here.

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by dang on Monday November 21, 2022 @02:13PM (#33696568)
That article has so much more information in it that I've changed the URL to that from https://tailscale.com/security-bulletins/#ts-2022-004. Thanks!
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by archon810 on Monday November 21, 2022 @08:39PM (#33700722)
I submitted it 7 hours ago, but it didn't get any traction with the original title https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33695800.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by dang on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @03:14PM (#33710828)
Ah sorry - we're eventually going to implement karma sharing to take care of cases like this. Often I search to see if someone else has already submitted the 'better' URL but I forgot to do that here.

There's a lot of randomness in which submissions get noticed and achieve liftoff from /newest. At least it evens out over time if you continue to post good submissions!

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by beanjuiceII on Monday November 21, 2022 @02:43PM (#33696944)
sounds like tailscale should
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by ghuntley on Monday November 21, 2022 @04:11PM (#33697987)
that would be a really cool outcome (tm)
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by erdaniels on Monday November 21, 2022 @03:24PM (#33697434)
can you DM me her email? I can't find it anywhere and I'd love to start a chat with on a security position at my work.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by maxmcd on Monday November 21, 2022 @03:42PM (#33697650)
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by ghuntley on Monday November 21, 2022 @04:06PM (#33697931)
Have passed your comment over to her. The website has been updated with an email address.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by erdaniels on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @09:12AM (#33705950)
Thanks!
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by er4hn on Monday November 21, 2022 @03:29PM (#33697502)
where does she say she is looking for an employer? Would be worthwhile to start a conversation with her.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by ghuntley on Monday November 21, 2022 @04:01PM (#33697867)
Em interned with me earlier this year. Have passed the threads over to her.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by Loic on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @02:16AM (#33703000)
The quality of her writing is wonderful, clear, to the point, funny and of course all the technical details are well explained. For a non native English reader like me (I am French), a real pleasure to read. You can congratulate her!
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by LVB on Monday November 21, 2022 @06:32PM (#33699713)
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by IshKebab on Monday November 21, 2022 @05:06PM (#33698724)
Very well written. Also quite worrying given they're supposed to be a security company and these kinds of issues are well known.

Then again it does seem like the entire universe applies "eh probably nobody will try and hack it" to services listening on local TCP interfaces.

They certainly don't care about multi-user machines, though I suppose there are so many local root exploits these days you're basically trusting your users anyway in that situation.

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by dathinab on Monday November 21, 2022 @06:33PM (#33699723)
> Also quite worrying

Linux is used by by docent "security companies" and still has vulnerabilities from time to time. So does Apple in the products where their care about security, etc.

More important are three things to realize:

1. their handling of the incident, which wasn't just fast but you could say absurdly fast to a point that I'm pretty sure multiple employees dropped everything the moment they read the mail to solely focused on fixing and analyzing it

2. it's Windows only (at least it's main problem is), coming from a workaround for a feature "missing" in windows from a company which is relative young and started out in the Linux/UNIX space.

3. it is exploitable due to a fundamental design flaw of browsers

Or what I'm trying to say: It isn't that surprising (or worrying) that such a thing happened, what matters is how they handle it and make sure that it will not happen again.

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by IshKebab on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @03:15AM (#33703307)
> a feature "missing" in windows

It's not missing. Windows has named pipes. They just don't use the same API as Unix sockets so you would have to do some work to do it properly (or use an existing library that abstracts both interfaces).

In any case Windows has had support for Unix sockets since 2017 so there's really no excuse.

> Linux is used by by docent "security companies" and still has vulnerabilities from time to time. So does Apple in the products where their care about security, etc.

Right but neither of them are companies whose sole product is a security product.

I agree their response time is good - they probably realised how bad it looks!

Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by oefnak on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @03:31AM (#33703419)
Well, since tailscale doesn't auto update, it doesn't matter how fast the response is. Updating it will take a long time anyway.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by kbenson on Monday November 21, 2022 @07:59PM (#33700453)
Always nice to see a vendor respond quickly and adequately. Even better when they go above and beyond, as seems to be indicated here by the timeline posted and the assessment of what fixes were put in place by the researcher(s). Good job Tailscale.
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by intelVISA on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @01:26AM (#33702705)
no love for our homie Jamie, Geoffrey?
Re:CVE-2022-41924 – tailscaled can be used to remotely execu... by mikehotel on Tuesday November 22, 2022 @10:52AM (#33707060)
Best exploit write up I’ve read. All the details, interspersed with nonchalant humor.

“None of these words are in the Bible.

This is certainly true of the King James Version, but many of these words can be found in what might as well be the Old Testament of Same-Origin Policy: the WhatWG Fetch Standard, which defines the CORS rules we are being accused of violating.”