News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by modriano on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:13PM (#33672899)
Imagine you have a largish property (say 5 acres) and you had a greenhouse that was not visible from any adjacent public land, and police suspect you're growing some marijuana in that greenhouse. Would it be unreasonable for cops to get a helicopter, fly high enough to see over the things hiding the greenhouse, claim they saw marijuana from a distance of over 400 feet with just their eyes, and used that as probable cause to then get a search warrant for the property? In Florida v Riley, "The Court held that Riley had no reasonable expectation of privacy in this case because anyone could view Riley’s property from a helicopter flying in navigable airspace and figure out what was inside. The police officer did not enter Riley’s land or interfere with it in any way. Furthermore, the manner in which he was flying the helicopter was well within the law; therefore, the police officer was within his rights to view Riley’s property from the air. The Court determined that the police action in this case did not violate Riley’s Fourth Amendment rights." [0]

That case was in 1988, and it is not out of line with the 4th Amendment decisions over the ~50+ years since the Warren court that made good 4A decisions (like Katz v SUS [1]). So expect this case to fly through 6 to 3.

[0] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1988/87-764

[1] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1967/35

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:35PM (#33673160)
Yes. The whole drug war is antithetical to the spirit and original intent of the 4th and I firmly believe the court decided these cases incorrectly. Imagine extending this ridiculous helicopter analogy to satellites of increasing capability. Where would there ever be any expectation of privacy? Must we all cling together in lead lined boxes underground?
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by xahrepap on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:44PM (#33673243)
Or wifi that can see through walls. Etc etc.

It’s to the point where we need a new amendment to bolster the 4th in the modern era.

Not saying we SHOULD need one. Because I agree the spirit (and honestly the letter) of the 4th covers us. But clearly bad actors are winning the fight right now.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:15PM (#33673554)
This is what always killed me about the "liberal" judges, so many of them are TERRIBLE on the 4th.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by matthewdgreen on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:58PM (#33673992)
This should be one of the places where conservative "originalist" judicial philosophy shines: after all, that entire philosophy is designed to constrain government power based on what was reasonable and expected in the 1700s. You'd imagine that one could use this approach to protect citizens from government adoption of modern surveillance technology (which is capable of "searches" that track a user's electronic records, among other things.)

Surprisingly, that's not at all what we've seen. For example in Carpenter vs. United States, the Supreme Court was asked whether tracking someone via cell-transaction records required a warrant under the 4th amendment. Chief Justice Roberts and the Court's liberal justices said "yes, it is a violation because citizens should have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their movements." Meanwhile the most prominent originalists (Thomas, Gorsuch as well as Alito) filed dissenting opinions lamenting the decision, saying that the 4th amendment doesn't provide any protection for these records.

Anyway ordinarily I wouldn't respond to a political rant, but I do think it's important for HN readers to know what the most important judges in the country are actually saying on this point.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by krapp on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:40PM (#33674434)
The originalist interpretation of Thomas, Gorsuch and Alito seems correct to me. The 4th Amendment refers to "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures." Cellphone records do not belong to the person who owns the cellphone generating that data, nor are they papers or effects in the way the Amendment was meant to refer, nor an intrusion onto a person's private property, therefore the Amendment shouldn't apply.

Also, as of now SCOTUS has decided a right to privacy doesn't exist within the Constitution.

The problem with wanting an originalist interpretation of the Constitution is that the Constitution doesn't really say what most people think it does.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:50PM (#33674531)
Cell records seem like “papers” to me. Just because this case isn’t specifically outlined in the text doesn’t mean that power is automatically granted to the government without a warrant.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by krapp on Saturday November 19, 2022 @04:49PM (#33675138)
>Cell records seem like “papers” to me.

But would they seem like papers to someone in the 1700s? "Papers" in that context are physical documents, parchment and ink.

That's the problem with Constitutional originalism - it boils down to interpreting the mind of an imaginary ghost, which fundamentally leads to justifying confirmation bias by proxy.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @08:22PM (#33677068)
They had documents held by third parties that pertained to your commercial activities. Looking at them required a warrant.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by j33zusjuice on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:06PM (#33677741)
Exactly. This isn’t new, this is just further abstracted. When we consider what these things are analogous to, then, yes, they should require a warrant. Should the government be allowed to intercept your mail, make an exact replica, and send the original to the intended recipient? Obviously not. The same, therefore, applies to packets.

Should LE be allowed to look at all the recipients of your snail mail without a warrant? Absolutely not. They, therefore, should not be allowed to read your call logs. It’s basically the same.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by jfengel on Monday November 21, 2022 @01:23PM (#33695983)
As far as I can tell, they are allowed to read envelopes without a warrant:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_cover

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by mixmastamyk on Saturday November 19, 2022 @07:29PM (#33676687)
Unfortunately they are someone else’s papers, someone in bed with the government.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:21PM (#33674237)
I totally agree. The originalists haven’t made a very strong intellectual showing on the 4th.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by wcunning on Saturday November 19, 2022 @04:26PM (#33674902)
Gorsuch's dissent read to me as: refile this case with the following complete legal theory that would provide 10x as much protection as the majority's decision. He clearly didn't like the use of the cellphone records, just didn't want to rule the way the majority ruled with so many outs for the cops given how little effort it takes to get a warrant these days.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by notfromhere on Sunday November 20, 2022 @10:09AM (#33681442)
Originalism is a lot like Biblical interpretation. It says exactly what you want it to say if you twist it in just the right way. And magically, originalism always lines up with whatever the existing Conservative party line happens to be.

If you really want to get technical, the Supreme Court has no business in judicial review, as that is not explicitly stated in the Constitution. Marbury v Madison is more tradition than anything.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by modriano on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:16PM (#33673560)
I must confess, I wasn't really presenting a hypothetical, even if I initially presented it that way. I was just presenting the facts of the case Florida v Riley [0], which the Supreme Court considered and then decided individuals don't have a reasonable expectation of privacy in locations that can be viewed by a helicopter just outside the bounds of your property. So unless the court completely changes direction on decades of consist (anti-privacy) 4A interpretation, the SC will absolutely rule that it's fine for a geosynchronous satellite to just watch any particular target 24/7, when it becomes economically possible for an investigation to employ such tools.

[0] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1988/87-764

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:40PM (#33673810)
I got your intent and I've read a lot about the Riley case. The courts have completely destroyed the 4th amendment, its terrible.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by newZWhoDis on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:15PM (#33674161)
Yep. Most of the federal government is unconstitutional and the courts allowed it.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by Amezarak on Saturday November 19, 2022 @04:48PM (#33675127)
Technology destroyed the Fourth Amendment. If the government couldn't fly the helicopter themselves, they would just buy the data, as they already do your cellphone location data, car tag scan data, credit card purchase histories, etc.

It's going to be clearly silly for most people to say that multibillion dollar corporations are allowed to conduct unlimited surveillance on you, but the government can't. The 4A was encoding a legal right to the societal expectation of privacy. We've spent the last 30 years blithely destroying that social expectation via tech. Of course no one much is up in arms in it now - we've trained it out. Big Data and the Fourth Amendment are antitheses. Even if you were to somehow rile up enough people to force some sort of legislation against stuff like this, it's going to happen anyway, illegally, and they'll find a way to get away with it. Consider the myriad abuses of the CIA and NSA. What happened when the CIA spied on Congress illegally as Congress investigated their other illegal actions, and then got caught, then lied about what they were doing? Absolutely nothing, and the guy in charge is now considered a hero by a whole political faction and is a frequent media commentator expounding his opinions as a Trustworthy Expert.

In a world where you're dealing with human beings, you can't have giant repositories of extremely useful data in centralized locations and think that a "don't look at this" sign is going to do you any good. You have to not have giant centralized repositories of data people care about. The Fourth Amendment could only effectively exist in a world where privacy was valued and invading it meant breaking into someone’s home, or his lawyer’s office, or paying people to follow him around all day.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by at_a_remove on Saturday November 19, 2022 @05:31PM (#33675515)
I think one of the biggest flaws was the use of the word "expectations." Call it a sea change, call it a paradigm shift or a shove on the Overton window, expectations have been changing. Technology can certainly kick that along and often opens new chinks in our armor, but there's a societal and therefore legal bent to it, too.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by Amezarak on Saturday November 19, 2022 @06:02PM (#33675840)
Neither exists in a vacuum. Technology changes culture and culture shapes the use of technology. Nevertheless, anytime you have people highly incentivized to use data, and the data exists, it will be used.

And in fact our use of technology definitely contributed to this, even when it seemed very innocuous. Logging is invaluable for testing and troubleshooting, forum posts, DMs, login data, and tweets obviously have more value as things that are non-ephemeral...but what you do by logging everything, what you do by having an Internet where things are by default non-ephemeral is change exactly this societal expectation.

Going back to the helicopter example in this thread, would we argue that the government shouldn't be allowed to look at the aerial view on maps.google.com? The very existence of this service changed what people understood as private.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @07:11PM (#33676538)
> It's going to be clearly silly for most people to say that multibillion dollar corporations are allowed to conduct unlimited surveillance on you, but the government can't.

Corporations can’t put you in jail and that’s why the 4th amendment needs to be strong now more than ever. The government should be required to get warrants and not just be able to buy that data.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by Amezarak on Saturday November 19, 2022 @07:28PM (#33676676)
What kind of actually effective controls do you think could possibly exist in a world where everyone can buy the data except the police? Aside from the fact other people and corporations can do quite a lot of horrible stuff to you, including turn the government on you - the obvious outcome is the police would simply use proxies and parallel construction, no matter how "illegal" you make it.

It's one thing to say they shouldn't be able to do it and we need to pass a law, it's another to create a world where they actually can't, and aren't incentivized to.

As a whole separate question, do you think companies and individuals should be banned from voluntarily giving data to the police, out of ideological motives or generosity or whatever? That also just intuitively seems weird. Charging a fee for something you're happy to do is just a small jump. The problem is the mass collection of data in the first place. Once you have that, the rest is inevitable. Mass data collection is a massive qualitative change to what we had before.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @08:21PM (#33677056)
Can’t would be ideal, but I’d settle for better rule of law and legal protections.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by feet on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:29AM (#33680410)
How about make it so that nobody can buy the data?
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by Amezarak on Sunday November 20, 2022 @04:43PM (#33685716)
This might be a promising step, but you still have the problem of a) the data exists b) people are highly incentivized to get the data. Ban selling it? They'll share it. Ban sharing it? They'll form byzantine corporate structures that make it not-really-sharing. Or they'll just do so informally.

If you want it all to stop, that means banning the collection of data. This of course won't eliminate it altogether, and it will wipe out a lot of the tech industry, but it will go a long way, and proving someone has collected data they weren't supposed to is a lot easier than proving they shared it inappropriately.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:24PM (#33673663)
> Imagine extending this ridiculous helicopter analogy to satellites of increasing capability

An originalist analogy would be the government spotting something with their naked eye from a boat that isn’t visible from land. I don’t think that would be unconstitutional. If someone in a helicopter is using their naked eye to look at your one property, that seems to be in a different category from e.g. thermal imaging everyone from space.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:38PM (#33673801)
This isn't a very good argument. A naked eye assessment from water is no different than from land. You won't see over walls or between land features, you also can't go within 400 ft of any arbitrary point in a piece of property from the water. Furthermore the 400 ft rule is totally arbitrary, and enforcing it relies entirely on the word of the police who are 100% incentivized to lie about both altitude and use of "the naked eye". The whole think stinks of authoritarianism.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:15PM (#33674164)
> the 400 ft rule is totally arbitrary, and enforcing it relies entirely on the word of the police

I mean, any distance is going to be arbitrary. And “people might lie” is a bad reason to reject a rule. (It’s a good reason to raise the burden of evidence.)

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:20PM (#33674225)
The decision set no burden for evidence, and the dissents specifically pointed out that no reasonable civilian pilot would be flying so low. The court invented this shit whole cloth to justify the drug war fashion of the day, it’s horrifying overreach.

Imagine saying out loud with a straight face that it’s not a search because you’re in the sky.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 19, 2022 @04:05PM (#33674662)
> decision set no burden for evidence

Defence didn’t allege the cops lied. This case wasn’t about lying cops.

> no reasonable civilian pilot would be flying so low

This argument has merit. That said, civilians don’t slowly patrol neighbourhoods either. So I’m not sure where the threshold is for what cops can do on patrol.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by mcbits on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:26PM (#33674281)
I suspect the 4th amendment would have been worded somewhat differently if the royal tax collectors in Boston had been clever enough to train tea-sniffing dogs to search cargo for tea smuggling without physically searching inside.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by ghoward on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:17PM (#33672958)
I think you're right about the end result, and I do not like it. I also disagree with the Riley case: unless you have REALLY good binoculars, there isn't any way someone could tell what kind of plants are in a greenhouse at 400 feet.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by mkl95 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:33PM (#33673135)
It's a known fact that cops struggle to distinguish hemp from marijuana. If they can't do it when it's in front of their faces, there's no way they will at 400 feet.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by aerostable_slug on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:44PM (#33673848)
Even better: outdoor grows have been located via their heat signature at night (I have a relative who was a national guard pilot and did this). There's no way to know what's there, just that it's a different temp than the native greenery. Generally this is done on public / state land, but I imagine more than one raid on private land was cued by this technique.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by dehrmann on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:55PM (#33673968)
They're literally the same species. You might still need a license to produce hemp, so they could plausibly consult the license list, notice your cannabis, see you're not on the list, and get a warrant either way.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by Melting_Harps on Sunday November 20, 2022 @02:09AM (#33678983)
> You might still need a license to produce hemp, so they could plausibly consult the license list, notice your cannabis, see you're not on the list, and get a warrant either way.

You;ll only appear on that list if you do so for commercial purposes and are required to get a license, furthermore you can legally grow MJ or Hemp without one provided you live in a legal state: where you are allowed up to 6 plants per Adult resident of your home above the age of 21. So you can legally have a large compliant grow if you live in a CO-OP as is common in several legalized States.

And this very thing was disputed in CO in the early phases of Amendment 64 (legalizing recreational MJ and Industrial hemp in 2012), and then was made law of the land after the Farm bill of 2018 wherein hemp could be grown in all 50 stares as it was codified as a matter that was to be handled by their respective Department of Ag in their state/city.

In short, their is nothing stopping anyone growing Industrial hemp as a crop for their own usage in a legal state if it is not used for commercial purposes, it is however, not wise to do so because the DEA can get a warrant and sill do a search and seizure and continue to use things like asset forfeiture to ruin your life in the process so it's best to limit such grows not because the Law doesn't allow it, but for the sheer fear of having an agency that is growing in irrelevance to come inot your Life when a rather easy to get license/permit will do--some States even distinguish between commercial and R/D for this very purpose and to skirt around Laws where Federal funding can be threatened as was the case with CU Boulder/Denver.

> They're getting a warrant, not a conviction.

While true, you can still have your Life ruined in the process of said search warrant and be subject to asset forfeiture. Personally speaking, i think that is a direct violation of one's 4th Amendment Right, but that doesn't mean it doesn't happen and it's best to be avoided.

Source: My startup was providing financial services and payment processing to the Legal Hemp Industry (2015-2018), and my co-founder was one of the first to legally do so under the seed/breeding program in CO.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by rufus_foreman on Saturday November 19, 2022 @07:21PM (#33676626)
They're getting a warrant, not a conviction.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by scarface74 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:14PM (#33673545)
>… you're growing some marijuana in that greenhouse

Your entire argument is based on the flawed premise that government should have any right to stop you from growing, selling or consuming marijuana.

Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ... by alex_young on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:50PM (#33674529)
Interestingly however, if they use infrared imaging they can’t do so without a warrant. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyllo_v._United_States