Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ...
by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:50PM
(#33674531)
Cell records seem like “papers” to me. Just because this case isn’t specifically outlined in the text doesn’t mean that power is automatically granted to the government without a warrant.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ...
by krapp on Saturday November 19, 2022 @04:49PM
(#33675138)
>Cell records seem like “papers” to me.
But would they seem like papers to someone in the 1700s? "Papers" in that context are physical documents, parchment and ink.
That's the problem with Constitutional originalism - it boils down to interpreting the mind of an imaginary ghost, which fundamentally leads to justifying confirmation bias by proxy.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ...
by ch4s3 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @08:22PM
(#33677068)
They had documents held by third parties that pertained to your commercial activities. Looking at them required a warrant.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ...
by j33zusjuice on Saturday November 19, 2022 @10:06PM
(#33677741)
Exactly. This isn’t new, this is just further abstracted. When we consider what these things are analogous to, then, yes, they should require a warrant. Should the government be allowed to intercept your mail, make an exact replica, and send the original to the intended recipient? Obviously not. The same, therefore, applies to packets.
Should LE be allowed to look at all the recipients of your snail mail without a warrant? Absolutely not. They, therefore, should not be allowed to read your call logs. It’s basically the same.
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ...
by jfengel on Monday November 21, 2022 @01:23PM
(#33695983)
As far as I can tell, they are allowed to read envelopes without a warrant:
Re:US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around ...
by mixmastamyk on Saturday November 19, 2022 @07:29PM
(#33676687)
Unfortunately they are someone else’s papers, someone in bed with the government.
Also, as of now SCOTUS has decided a right to privacy doesn't exist within the Constitution.
The problem with wanting an originalist interpretation of the Constitution is that the Constitution doesn't really say what most people think it does.