News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:07PM (#33672814)
Ugh, I hate it when articles leave out the most crucial information, namely:

1. How did Mass install these apps in the first place if it was "clandestine" as the lawsuit alleges?

2. Google is not in the business, generally, of just giving access to private data to government agencies just because they asked. Was there some sort of legal requirement or court order involved here?

In other words, I'm taking this whole filing with a giant cup of salt until more details are available, never mind that legal filings are by definition highly biased to the side being represented.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by alistairSH on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:19PM (#33672981)
If this is true, doesn’t this mean Android is unsafe/compromised by default?

The suit, as described, leaves a lot of questions.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by GeekyBear on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:41PM (#33673223)
> The suit, as described, leaves a lot of questions.

Here's what the suit alleges:

>To increase adoption, starting on June 15, 2021, DPH worked with Google to secretly install the Contact Tracing App onto over one million Android mobile devices located in Massachusetts without the device owners’ knowledge or permission. When some Android device owners discovered and subsequently deleted the App, DPH would re-install it on to their devices.

https://nclalegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Complaint_W...

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by lakomen on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:57PM (#33673374)
So Google Play Store installs apps without consent. And one can't unistall Google Play Store. Ergo, we finally need to liberate our phones and tablets with an open alternative which isn't F-Droid.
Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by MichaelCollins on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:21PM (#33673621)
Why not F-Droid? F-Droid is great.
Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by anonymousiam on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:36PM (#33673168)
You would be naive to believe that Android/iOS are secure in this respect. Pretty much every government in the world has a "need" to surveil their population, and have "insisted" upon this capability.
Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by andybak on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:43PM (#33673239)
In this particular instance, color me naive.

You're saying a State Government can request Google installs a 3rd party app on 1 million phones? If that's true then I'm genuinely astonished. And more so that it wasn't headline news at the time.

Or maybe there's more to this than currently is apparent.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by jesboat on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:47PM (#33673282)
> You're saying a State Government can request Google installs a 3rd party app on 1 million phones? If that's true then I'm genuinely astonished. And more so that it wasn't headline news at the time.

Yes. That's what happened. (I'm not sure if the 1E6 phones claim is accurate, but it was a non-trivial chunk of people near MA).

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by simpss on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:35PM (#33673156)
I'm pretty sure these submissions are related:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27558500#27558758

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by adam_arthur on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:28PM (#33673073)
If Google is involved and allows random apps like this, then yes
Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by toast0 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:12PM (#33673518)
If you don't trust Google, commercial Android is not for you.

Google can push apps onto your phone and the apps can run without interaction on the phone. Often that's useful and authorized by the user --- you can use the google play website to push things, but this case shows it's not limited to that. I don't think you can disable this through settings, you would have to disable play services or block the networking or not have gapps installed or something.

Play services runs in a priviledged mode and generally updates itself, so there's a lot of trust needed.

Afaik, all modern commercial OSes intended for end users have a similar level of trust required for the vendor. The capability to push code run in a privileged space enables rapid response to emergent malware, but also enables the vendor to take actions without explicit consent.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by landemva on Saturday November 19, 2022 @11:39PM (#33678306)
I keep Play Store disabled and only enable it when I want to update apps. This seems to keep regular apps from auto-updating.

I don't often need GPS, so I wonder if disabling Play Services would work for me without allowing forced spyware pushes.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by factsarelolz on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:14PM (#33672921)
> 1. How did Mass install these apps in the first place if it was "clandestine" as the lawsuit alleges?

Discovery will probably shed some light on this. How would the plaintiff know the exact method used?

> never mind that legal filings are by definition highly biased to the side being represented.

Tell me you’ve never been a plaintiff in a lawsuit without telling me you’ve never been a plaintiff in a lawsuit. Why would the fillings _not_ be biased to the side being represented? Why would the side being represented be biased to the defense? That makes no sense at all.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:22PM (#33673001)
> How would the plaintiff know the exact method used?

This is not exactly difficult. They are alleging that this was installed on a million phones, I'm sure doing some straightforward technical forensics would make it clearly apparent what was going on.

> Why would the fillings _not_ be biased to the side being represented?

You've misunderstood my point, though I don't understand yours. Of course the filings are biased, that is exactly what I'm saying. I've just seen numerous cases (myself included) where people get out their pitchforks when they've only read one side's version of events, well before a complete picture emerges of what actually happened.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by factsarelolz on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:27PM (#33673066)
> They are alleging that this was installed on a million phones,

This allegation is based up the number reported by Google that is available to the public.

> I'm sure doing some straightforward technical forensics would make it clearly apparent what was going on.

Why? Why spend the money to hire a forensics analyst or a team, when through discovery you can learn that information straight from the source. In my opinion it would be worth it to wait to see if the lawsuit actually progresses and is not immediately slapped down by a judge. If immediately slapped down then you just wasted money, by waiting to ensure it’s approved to move forward you can save some money.

I will admit I have not read completely the actual filing, which probably will shed more light on it than an article.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by jesboat on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:44PM (#33673248)
1. Some background process, probably part of Google Play services, installed the app. Users were not notified that the app was installed. Eventually the app, once already installed and running, would put up a notification asking if the user wanted to participate.

The app was intentionally subtle, in that it had no application icon, which would presumably make it very difficult for user to disable contract tracing if they had enabled it. If you managed to uninstall the app, it would get reinstalled silently again.

2. The lawsuit alleges that there was no legal requirement or court order. Even if there had been, the lawsuit argues that the conduct would still have violated federal and state law and constitutions.

It is really pretty shitty, and, IANAL, probably is/was illegal, with the caveats that (a) I'm not sure whether Massachusetts or Google or both should be considered responsible; and (b) they might try to argue that a user's acceptance of Google's ToS and privacy policy constitutes permission.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by throwaway5752 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @01:57PM (#33673376)
It seems just moderately shitty. They did it with good intentions and there is no indication they misused the data. Despite that, clearly a mistake and some form of lawsuit is warranted. I guess "disappointed and hope they learned their lesson, what a crazy time to live through, I am happy we can all move on" doesn't drive engagement.

Nothing they did nears being as shitty as what the "Civil Liberties Alliance" represent. They are a bunch of bought and sold lawyers that trick us little people into believing they are pro-freedom with stunts like this, when their actual goal is deregulating in the context of worker safety, environmental, and food and drug safety to increase profits of industry. They get the votes they need for this from the evangelical movement, who they pay back by pushing for a radical reinterpretation the first amendment. Their end goal is a religious state with unregulated, unaccountable capitalism. To call them monsters is unfair to monsters.

Not everything requires a good guy and a bad guy. "Everybody Sucks Here" applied here.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by IncRnd on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:34PM (#33673747)
> They did it with good intentions and there is no indication they misused the data.

There is a very old proverb from Abbot Bernard of Clairvauxin in the 1100s that is still applicable today, "The road to hell is paved with good intentions."

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by MichaelCollins on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:18PM (#33673585)
> They did it with good intentions

That's how the road to hell is paved.

“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.”

- C. S. Lewis

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by throwaway5752 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:25PM (#33673669)
I've heard that somewhere before! And it's a good point, I'm glad you brought it up. I'm not defending the action, removed from context. However, intent does matter to me and is a well established legal consideration. Note the distinction between first, second, and third degree homicide for just one example. Just plain common sense application: I will feel differently if I am hit while crossing the street by 1) an ambulance speeding to save a mother and infant in preterm labor 2) a teen driver negligently text 3) someone speeding to get somewhere on time 4) a drunk driver 5) someone swerving to hit me because they don't like people like me for some reason. I am still mashed by a car and in rehab for a year, regardless, so is it unreasonable of me to feel differently which of those cases it is?

edit: To reply to your late edit, " It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies" is magnificent, because it correctly frames the NCLA lawsuit "The robber baron's cruelty". I can recogniz,e a wolf in sheep's clothing or trojan horse, whatever your preferred metaphor is.

I would reply "No thank you to either option, but thanks for the books, C.S. Lewis"

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by dmix on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:47PM (#33673885)
People often use those good intentions to silence dissent. If anyone questions their actions you can just spin it to say "well then you obviously don't care about [good intention, ie “grandmas dying of COVID”]".

So they are a very critical piece of the puzzle with this sort of abuse of power. They can very easily muddy the waters and obfuscate things.

It's often the side effects of their actions anyway. In this case the access the app provides is the side effect. The side effects outweighing the alleged benefits is what matters. Easily the most often recurring problem is politics. 1 step forward, 2 steps back.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by tigen on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:52PM (#33673927)
A tyranny exercised with good intentions "may" be worse than all possible ones? Weak.

So, that includes all possible versions of good intentions? All good intentions lead to torment? There are no sociopathic tyrants lacking conscience?

Anyway, I doubt Yahweh considers it a sin to install tracking software onto people's phones.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by MichaelCollins on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:56PM (#33674588)
> Anyway, I doubt Yahweh considers it a sin to

I don't give a damn what your god thinks. Or are you responding to C.S. Lewis's beliefs? Quoting a Christian doesn't make me a Christian, least of all when the quote doesn't even present a religious argument.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by jasmer on Saturday November 19, 2022 @02:55PM (#33673969)
Wait ... what (?) ... 'good intentions' are not very relevant here.

I don't care what Koch's other objectives might be, this is an ugly transgression of people's rights.

Arbitrary government surveillance is an incredibly bad thing and a very slippery slope.

We're witnessing governments around the world establishing '360 Surveillance' for all sorts of 'socially positive!', but ultimately dubious reasons.

If the government had specific reason to grab information about a specific person and a lawfully obtained warrant given a specific set of circumstances - then yes.

Or if we're talking the government buying generalized anonymoized information that is publicly available otherwise - then yes.

But slipping spyware onto phones is straight outrageous.

I'm generally a communitarian type person who believes we ought to step up and do the right thing as citizens but even I recognize this as the slipperiest of all slopes irrespective of their reasoning, and I can't fathom the tone of the comments here given that this is HN with usually a distinctly more libertarian-ish leaning.

"Not everything requires a good guy and a bad guy. "Everybody Sucks Here" applied here. "

Sorry but the 'Government of Mass' are the 'Bad Guys' here and the 'Koch Brothers' (or whoever is paying for this, I don't care) are the 'Good Guys' for going after them. That's it.

This will hopefully be resolved in the courts.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by potatototoo99 on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:03PM (#33674038)
Good intentions, good grief!
Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by mindslight on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:26PM (#33674288)
> 2. The lawsuit alleges that there was no legal requirement or court order. Even if there had been, the lawsuit argues that the conduct would still have violated federal and state law and constitutions.

I would think the lack of a legal requirement or court order would actually absolve Massachusetts, as it would leave the responsibility resting on Google. As surely within the terms of Play store etc, Google has the power to do anything they'd like to your device and personal information. And that power extends to Google's actions when working with other parties.

I'm most definitely not a fan of mass surveillance or centralized control. But running an operating system developed by a surveillance company, to which they have multiple backdoors and frontdoors, is fundamentally a surrender to these terrible things.

The main thing that makes this different than every other Google update is that the government of Massachusetts was also involved, for a "greater good" public health purpose rather than the usual lucre.

Now, if we had real privacy protection (either legislative or common law) to the point that processing individuals' private information were illegal, even regardless of any contracts purporting the opposite, then there could be a claim. But something tells me this suit isn't looking to go that far.

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by newZWhoDis on Saturday November 19, 2022 @03:09PM (#33674104)
> Google is not in the business, generally, of just giving access to private data to government agencies just because they asked

Since when?

Re:Koch-funded group sues US state agency for installing spy... by washadjeffmad on Saturday November 19, 2022 @05:13PM (#33675362)
> Google is not in the business, generally, of just giving access to private data to government agencies just because they asked. Was there some sort of legal requirement or court order involved here?

That's called asking with more steps.