News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by detritus on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:42AM (#33639481)
Yeah. great. It's too late though, isn't it? The damage is done.

'Thanks'. 'Well done'.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by 543ge4q3 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:42AM (#33639480)
If you added the word "Only" to the title, it would completely change the subtext.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by sjsdaiuasgdia on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:47AM (#33639559)
The original title sticks to the actual claim, and doesn't add subtext. You can interpret "one in five" in either direction. You can say 80% of Brexit voters are still fine with their vote, or you can say the 20% who have changed their minds would be enough to reverse the decision could the vote be held again now.

So yeah, adding words does add subtext, but your phrasing of this seems to imply that there is existing subtext. What do you see, specifically?

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by 543ge4q3 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @10:12AM (#33639936)
Choice of words is a component of subtext, as you hinted at yourself. Below I have hilighted the key action word, which is also an important choice when setting subtext.

"One in 5 people now think" is a positive-sounding construction which lends more statstical weight to the result than an impartial examination of the numbers, and people who scan headlines are far from impartial.

Other constructions are "4 in 5 still support...", or "80% still support", or "20% now think", which are all still mathematically neutral, but the subtext is different.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by sjsdaiuasgdia on Thursday November 17, 2022 @10:24AM (#33640139)
Is there a phrasing you think would be neutral that still references that data point?

I'm struggling to figure out a neutral phrasing involving this data point. My reading of your response indicates that you see a temporal indicator ("now") or a delta indicator ("still" / "no longer") as both introducing bias. "One in five people think Brexit was the wrong decision" without anything clarifying significantly misrepresents the data.

It seems your issue is actually with the data point being in the headline at all. Maybe the headline should be a dry thing like "A Brexit survey happened, read inside for details". I won't entirely disagree. But I think this is less about word choice than you think.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by 543ge4q3 on Thursday November 17, 2022 @11:37AM (#33641399)
I think it was the book "How to lie with statistics" that dedicated a page or two to the perceived differences when "x%" is used vs "1 in x", depending on the actual value.

I think that using "20% now think that..." would give a more accurate impression to someone scanning the headline.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by ranting-moth on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:53AM (#33639636)
Isn't that a well known fact that you can generally change the meaning and/or subtext of everything by adding or subtracting a word?
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by junot on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:47AM (#33639550)
Agreed. Is this figure supposed to be high? Seems like there's a good chance that 1 in 5 Biden voters now think it was the wrong decision and 1 in 5 Trump thought similarly after his years in office.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by beardyw on Thursday November 17, 2022 @10:03AM (#33639784)
Any mistake is only for 4 years.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by NDizzle on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:47AM (#33639560)
Way more than 1 in 5 Biden voters, given the last two years...
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by jleyank on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:53AM (#33639646)
Guess they decided they look better in brown.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by jfengel on Thursday November 17, 2022 @12:00PM (#33641877)
It's high given that the original referendum was so close. It was a rather large and irrevocable decision based on a bare majority.

People may regret their choices in elections, but they can revisit them every few years. Brexit is, if not forever, at least for a very long time.

Two mutually contradictory caveats:

1. The referendum itself was never intended to be serious. It was held because David Cameron thought it would fail, in order to shut up the anti-Europe wing of his party. He resigned over it.

2. Although the referendum was close, it was effectively affirmed by the elections in the wake of Cameron's resignation. It was still close, but they ended up with a majority for the party campaigning explicitly on a pro-Brexit platform.

This adds up to a cautionary tale on referendums. A big question was put to the people -- even bigger than an election -- and a largish majority (not a bare majority) are unhappy about the result.

In that sense, yes, 20% is a pretty big number. Not that it changes anything. It's much too late for that, and it doesn't tell us anything about the counterfactual where the referendum lost. But it's worth remembering going forward, both with respect to the EU and for national decision-making.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by easytiger on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:43AM (#33639496)
YouGov. Whatever.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by usedtoprog on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:44AM (#33639504)
yougov also repeatedly reports that x% of the UK population want COVID-19 restrictions to continue indefinitely, along with the closure of nightclubs. You'll forgive me if I don't treat yougov as the main source of UK sentiment
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by uniqueuid on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:47AM (#33639562)
It's a sample of N~1700, so +/- 2% for a 95% confidence interval. The responses are weighted so self-selection along socio-demographic variables is mostly accounted for.

Sure, almost all off-the-shelf polling is rather bad these days, but they did their job as well as you can reasonably expect.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by ianai on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:52AM (#33639628)
Polling has un-earned respect lately in the US. Is there any reason to suspect opinion polls are more reliable in the UK? Afaik people are just as shifted away from landlines there.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by uniqueuid on Thursday November 17, 2022 @12:22PM (#33642277)
Modern polling is hard because people tend to distrust elites more than in the past. It's a fundamentally unsolvable problem to elicit attitudes from people who lie to you, lie to themselves and make up opinions on the spot.

That said, modern polling uses a host of techniques and is of course not tied to landlines. Companies use access panels of available participants, f2f sampling (walking to random people's houses, but that's expensive of course), and in particular statistics such as poststratification.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by usedtoprog on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:49AM (#33639587)
Hilarious. More downvotes and cancellations, please
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by golergka on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:46AM (#33639530)
Which means that 80% support this decision 6 years later.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by wongarsu on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:50AM (#33639599)
Actually only about 70% of leave voters, with the other 11% undecided.

I think the interesting data point is that 19% of leave voters would vote differently in hindsight, but only 5% of remain voters would. That's a 4x difference. But you're also right that most people did not change their opinion.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by xracy on Thursday November 17, 2022 @06:09PM (#33647284)
This is exactly the statistic I was wondering about. One of the things that struck me about the original vote was that it was pretty close (~52%-48%). And the funny thing about close votes is how much power the 51st voter gets for their decision in spite of clear signalling that people don't actually know the answer.

Like, the original thing you're asking is probably not very well understood or not very consequential if about half the population is for and against it.

You can absolutely make a decision based on this, but you're asking a whole bunch of "armchair experts" their opinions, only to find out that they don't know because they don't have a good concept of the suggestion.

So the change in opinions after the fact is actually probably a lot more meaningful than the original vote was.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by ceejayoz on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:49AM (#33639581)
That's misleading.

51.89% voted for Brexit. That leaves 41.51% now.

48.11% voted against Brexit. If that hasn't changed, the British public no longer support the policy.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by taolegal on Thursday November 17, 2022 @10:59AM (#33640799)
But doesn't everyone usually say how dumb the general public is, citing the results when posed a ridiculous question?

Can't help but feel people are citing democracy here when it aligns with them but otherwise they're scornful of the general public.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by ceejayoz on Thursday November 17, 2022 @11:06AM (#33640894)
British politicians abdicated their responsibilities to said public. The non-binding referendum with no implementation details passed by a tiny majority became "the people's will".

I think something of Brexit's magnitude should've required more than a simple majority of the population to proceed with.

Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by wongarsu on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:47AM (#33639552)
Is that a lot? What's the usual rate of regret six years after a vote?
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by squaredot on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:49AM (#33639593)
I am not sure if the state of the UK economy would be substantially different without Brexit. Most of the problems would be the same, maybe with a slightly bigger carpet under which to hide the dirt.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by tgv on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:56AM (#33639679)
And there are also people on the other side who changed their mind. Less, but apparently it was also 1 in 5 in the early days of COVID. So don't overinterpret these numbers: it still looks very divided.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by wongarsu on Thursday November 17, 2022 @09:57AM (#33639691)
Alternative headline: Four times as many leave voters as remain voters would vote differently in hindsight, but most haven't changed their opinion.
Re:One in five who voted for Brexit now think it was the wro... by beardyw on Thursday November 17, 2022 @10:02AM (#33639756)
From what I can tell probably more than that number had no idea what they were voting for when they voted leave. Those who voted remain did know what they were voting for. Hence the difference. Too late now.