News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by Spivak on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:10AM (#33610061)
God this shit it tiresome, giving money people doing social justice isn't funneling money into some "culture war" -- at best you could say that the groups involved see the greatest opposition to their mission is political but these groups aren't political except as a means to an end. They would, (and do, I'm part of one) support politicians on both sides of the aisle so long as they support their mission.

You would be surprised how amenable Republicans at the local level, who don't have to keep up appearances on Twitter, are to social justice -- doubly when someone in their family is a member of one of those disadvantaged groups.

You don't get to say "I don't like this so I'm going to say it's political and then demand you stay out of politics." Literally everything is political.

Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by majjgepolja on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:27AM (#33610291)
See I am not American and don't care about American culture war, Republican Democratican, or whatever you guys are using as an excuse to burn down buildings.

It's plain wrong to put banner ads in third world countries like Brazil and India, sounding like wikipedia doesn't have money to run their servers.

It's plain wrong to funnel that money to executives.

People who make wikipedia great aren't even involved with this. They have enough money to run servers, and a potential donation doesn't create additional content. They are trying hard to hide that fact with some clever wording.

This is textbook example of __dark pattern__ which highly privacy focused people love to point out when a bootstrapped startup collects telemetry data from their little application.

The Wikipedia fundraising effort is sounds like a metric driven C suite executive desperately trying to make charts "stonk".

Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by zeroonetwothree on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:24AM (#33610247)
Would you feel the same way if Wikimedia funded groups acting against social justice?
Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by antihero on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:47AM (#33610607)
No because there’s a difference between doing good and doing bad, even if that’s subjective.
Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by ars on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:08AM (#33610947)
You didn't think that through, did you? It's almost impossible to define good vs bad without it being subjective.

You killed someone. That's bad. Except they were dying of a terminal disease, so now it's good. Except you still killed someone, so that's bad.

Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by OkayPhysicist on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:40PM (#33612421)
Pack it up folks, ars here has solved ethics! You heard it here first, nothing can be good or bad, because sometimes it's not obvious whether something is good or bad. 2500 years of philosophical inquiry, and we've finally got our answer!
Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by 988747 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:04PM (#33611852)
"Social justice" is the opposite of justice, and therefore evil :)
Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by pessimizer on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:15PM (#33612029)
There is. Bad is doing what you want, good is doing what I want.
Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by Spivak on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:44PM (#33612481)
Depends, is the funding literally just for “fuck these people in particular who have social justice missions” or do you really mean “donating to groups whose missions I don’t agree with and who in due course end up opposing social justice groups.” Because the former is just mean while the latter is fine.
Re:Wikipedians are rebelling against “unethical” Wikipedia f... by subradios on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @01:02AM (#33619458)
That depends , if they took a principled position that, say trans rights groups were censoring notable science re: gender and sexuality and donated to FIRE - an organization that is specifically devoted to maintaining the academy as a place of inquiry, but incidentally opposes social justice missions, that seems like it could be in keeping with Wikipedia's wider mission and legitimate.

However, I'd feel like sponsoring the Ben Shapiro superpac would be obviously over the line - not because they're "conservative" or "against social justice", but because the way in which it opposes "social justice" is not an incidental aspect of protecting freedom of information.

Similarly, funding the pre-2015 ACLU could have a similar argument made - even though they had a liberal bent well before the Harvard amicus brief.