News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by z9znz on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:58AM (#33608082)
I have had limited but direct experience with CFTC (because of a cryptocurrency related project I did for a client), and I was not impressed.

In this case, CFTC came at us with claims that we were breaking rules and then required us to prove that we were not. Just looking at our website it was very clear what we were doing and what we were selling (education content), and there was not a hint of anything to suggest that we were selling investments or commodities. Even still, we had to give our corp attorney annotated screenshots of our website, illustrating exactly what our business was, and have that sent back to CFTC.

After doing so, we heard nothing back from them. They should have been satisifed by what we sent (presumably they were), but they didn't even both to say, "Ok, you may go."

The whole thing felt really arbitrary and amateur.

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by practice9 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:14AM (#33608191)
I think this experience could be replicated anywhere in the world. This type of agency (as well as tax offices) will pursue low-hanging fruit while overlooking more complex and critical situations. And the lack of actionable feedback really underscores their inefficiency.

> The whole thing felt really arbitrary and amateur.

Lack of domain knowledge + corruption + a lack of incentives to improve (because they are part of the government, it is difficult to hold them accountable for their claims)

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by asah on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:49AM (#33608487)
-1: this is often how regulatory bodies work. In particular, their non-response gives them better CYA in case there's malfeasance vs an explicit approval.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by bo1024 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:13AM (#33608722)
What does the -1 part of your comment mean and how does it relate to the rest?
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by psychlops on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:48AM (#33609086)
He means he downvoted the comment. The original comment wasn't notable. I've also dealt with regulators and they primarily gather information and review it on their own.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by bo1024 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:12PM (#33615080)
Ok, odd to downvote a comment because you agree with it and then to go on to provide more support for why the comment is correct...
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by themoonisachees on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:08AM (#33608694)
Then they are not good at regulating, are they not? A regulatory body should be able to say who they think is doing it wrong and who isn't.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by psychlops on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:53AM (#33609152)
Do you actually mean to say that a regulatory body should publish who they suspect is committing fraud or am I mis-reading your comment? Given they have a limited time to review select entities and a limited view into them, that would be an impossible feat, not to mention the legal liability if/when they were wrong.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by blitzar on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:22AM (#33609463)
As far as I can tell - FTX (at least international / not FTX.us) broke only 1 law - they broke their own terms and conditions :-

8.2.6 All Digital Assets are held in your Account on the following basis: (A) Title to your Digital Assets shall at all times remain with you and shall not transfer to FTX Trading ...

Excluding this stipulation, which they will be prosecuted for - what exactly the CFTC/SEC/NYSE/NASDAQ/Secret Service/DEA/Texas Rangers were meant to do about a company in the Bahamas is beyond me.

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by hef19898 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:36AM (#33610429)
You mean the law(s) they broke involved stealing users assets? Reminder so, terms and conditions are not law nor is there any guarantee they hold up in court if challenged.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by blitzar on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:03AM (#33610872)
If their terms and conditions said "by depositing your assets on our exchange you are signing them over to us" then there would be no crime at all.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by greatwave1 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:13PM (#33613568)
Terms and conditions aren't necessarily enforceable, and they really aren't necessarily enforceable when it comes to financial services, and they really really aren't necessarily enforceable when it comes to blatant fraud.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by bhawks on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:44AM (#33610567)
> Excluding this stipulation, which they will be prosecuted for - what exactly the CFTC/SEC/NYSE/NASDAQ/Secret Service/DEA/Texas Rangers were meant to do about a company in the Bahamas is beyond me.

The point is to look tough on crypto, so they can garner support for expanding budgets to deal with a new mandate. It's pure show.

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by SilasX on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:25AM (#33609492)
Parent in context was saying the regulator should communicate to the party under investigation, not to the general public.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by Swenrekcah on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:56PM (#33616369)
I think the problem is that, let’s say the police drives past your house and sees a pile of bodies.

Then they check on you and find you are a serial killer and arrest you.

Now, if you were smart and buried the bodies, is the police supposed to knock on your door and say: “Good job, keep doing what you are doing because you are obviously doing nothing wrong, as evidenced by the lack of bodies on your lawn.”

They don’t do that, they simply drive past and probably assume you’re honest but reserve judgement until later.

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by frankfrankfrank on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:07AM (#33608675)
Welcome to dealing with the bureaucracy. You described it well and you are very likely correct in your assumption of how it went. I say that from my own deep and high level experience. What you essentially became a part of was someone’s justification for their loyalists payoff job, where the job itself is basically all about justifying its existence not actually achieving any purported objectives, and actually even actively avoiding achieving such objectives for both political and practical reasons.

You essentially, through the process you described, did the job of the bureaucrat for him (or her, to not hurt feelings) and at the same time filled the space of the job by producing the documentation that then required additional time to process, which then filled more space and time in the bureaucrat’s day. It’s essentially the vaunted self-licking ice cream cone, you feed the beast with which you came in contact with.

What makes it worse, is that you likely spent a lot more time and resources and probably money on satisfying this drive-by form of corruption, than the bureaucrat ever spent on doing any work. In many ways it’s an age old story of paying off the corruption in government, only a new instance of it Rather than the cop or person at a counter you pay off with cash.

I hope you look forward to more of such instances, with the federal government bloating its ranks of regime goons, there will be more and more bureaucrats seeking justification for their existence by making you do their work for them.

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by RunSet on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:54AM (#33609823)
> the job itself is basically all about justifying its existence not actually achieving any purported objectives

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-licking_ice_cream_cone

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by skybrian on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:19PM (#33612109)
Why should the bureaucrat be doing more work? That increases expenses for taxpayers, or alternately means the regulator can't do other things. In principle, there's nothing wrong with making the business being regulated pay the costs, assuming the work needs doing at all.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by Geee on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:11AM (#33608707)
Well, it's quite popular in the MLM scene to wrap investments into some type of educational material. I believe OneCoin did just that, you paid for education packages and then got tokens as a gift. Maybe that's what they were looking at.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by hayd on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:26AM (#33608861)
Perhaps the trick is to donate to politicians who oversee these agencies...
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by TacticalCoder on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:48AM (#33609083)
But if you plan to do it guys, only do it when the fundraiser raising tens of millions happens to be your well-connected-to-the-elite mom, a lawyer and teacher at Stanford teaching tax laws!
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by cma on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:36AM (#33610431)
Don't ignore the Ryan Salame part of the donations, they covered both parties.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:34AM (#33608937)
> it was very clear what we were doing and what we were selling (education content), and there was not a hint of anything to suggest that we were selling investments or commodities

Lots of “educational” crypto content is thinly-veiled sales.

> we had to give our corp attorney annotated screenshots of our website, illustrating exactly what our business was

An attorney signing to your business being bona fide informational, and not one that e.g. profits from affiliate sales or coin drops, is material. What looks irrelevant at first glance is germane, at least for a regulator doing a first pass for further action.

> they didn't even both to say, "Ok, you may go."

Not sure about commodities and futures, but for securities you may never go. You are always under force of jurisdiction, a set-up intentionally more intrusive than most American regulation.

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by SilasX on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:35AM (#33611372)
>>they didn't even both to say, "Ok, you may go."

>Not sure about commodities and futures, but for securities you may never go.

Weird, the IRS didn't seem to have a problem notifying me when they were satisfied with my faxed explanation of a discrepancy they found. Maybe they're just unusually good at respecting their subjects as federal enforcement agencies go?

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by repomies69 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:42AM (#33611482)
I'm not from US, but in my experience the tax office is a different agency compared to many others. They are happy if you are "honest taxpayer" so to say. Other agencies have different incentives.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by panarky on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:02PM (#33611822)
"FTX" wasn't registered with the CFTC, only one of the 130 FTX-related entities was registered, specifically "FTX Derivatives US LLC".
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by gojomo on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:51PM (#33612574)
…which until recently was 'LedgerX' (still its domain name), & wasn't part of the bankruptcy filing, seems to be operating normally, & has reassured customers their assets are, per its regulated processes, separately custodied (not with the unlicensed/offshore FTX).

So while it takes some time for these things to unravel – it could be the next domino to fall! – there is at least a plausible story that the actual CFTC-licensed entity here (fka LedgerX) was spared the theft & bankruptcy.

That would be a credit to the CFTC's regime, rather than the knock portrayed here.

(I believe that this spin comes from a advocacy group for maximal regulations, firing a salvo to support its factions in DC, taking advantage of confusion about which related but legally-distinct entities are licensed.)

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by kevinpet on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:16PM (#33612857)
This comment undermines the whole story and shows that bettermarkets isn't interested in reality, only pushing their agenda.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by andsoitis on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:27AM (#33609523)
Do you mind sharing a link to the website (which is selling education content)?
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by jjtheblunt on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @09:56AM (#33609837)
i think you're describing an agency whose members don't feel sure what they're even supposed to do.

many people i know (most engineers, but not all) would say it's a symptom of "big government", the parts that exist and pay unmotivated employees as to their mission.

(i find myself wondering almost off topic how this might or might not be analogous with small kernels and big kernels in operating systems.)

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by hardolaf on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @10:38AM (#33610456)
The problem with the CFTC is that they should just be merged with the SEC. The wall between the two is just an odd historical oddity.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by jjtheblunt on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:19PM (#33612105)
that sounds too logical ! :)

seriously though, it's true, i realize, that the idea of refactoring doesn't happen well at government agency scale, does it?

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by dibt on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:17AM (#33611092)
> illustrating exactly what our business was, and have that sent back to CFTC.

Could it be that they were collecting data from you to build models for future analysis? Instead of paying people to research companies, and enter data into a system, force 20% of all companies to provide this data regardless of suspicions of wrongdoing?

There's that saying "looks like a duck, quacks like a duck." Maybe they start from the position "I don't know what a duck looks like, or what it sounds like. I think you're a duck. What do you look like? What do you sound like?"

That's just a guess. I have experience working elsewhere in the federal government. They often just throw darts at the wall to prove they are doing their job. New management will take over a department, and want to demonstrate change of some kind. Don't try to attach any rational thought to these actions.

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by jlarocco on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:25PM (#33612214)
> In this case, CFTC came at us with claims that we were breaking rules and then required us to prove that we were not. Just looking at our website it was very clear what we were doing and what we were selling (education content), and there was not a hint of anything to suggest that we were selling investments or commodities. Even still, we had to give our corp attorney annotated screenshots of our website, illustrating exactly what our business was, and have that sent back to CFTC.

Obviously I don't know the full story, but there really should be more diligence than just reading your website and taking your word for it, so I can't fault them just for requesting more information.