News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @08:34AM (#33608937)
> it was very clear what we were doing and what we were selling (education content), and there was not a hint of anything to suggest that we were selling investments or commodities

Lots of “educational” crypto content is thinly-veiled sales.

> we had to give our corp attorney annotated screenshots of our website, illustrating exactly what our business was

An attorney signing to your business being bona fide informational, and not one that e.g. profits from affiliate sales or coin drops, is material. What looks irrelevant at first glance is germane, at least for a regulator doing a first pass for further action.

> they didn't even both to say, "Ok, you may go."

Not sure about commodities and futures, but for securities you may never go. You are always under force of jurisdiction, a set-up intentionally more intrusive than most American regulation.

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by SilasX on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:35AM (#33611372)
>>they didn't even both to say, "Ok, you may go."

>Not sure about commodities and futures, but for securities you may never go.

Weird, the IRS didn't seem to have a problem notifying me when they were satisfied with my faxed explanation of a discrepancy they found. Maybe they're just unusually good at respecting their subjects as federal enforcement agencies go?

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by repomies69 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @11:42AM (#33611482)
I'm not from US, but in my experience the tax office is a different agency compared to many others. They are happy if you are "honest taxpayer" so to say. Other agencies have different incentives.
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by panarky on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:02PM (#33611822)
"FTX" wasn't registered with the CFTC, only one of the 130 FTX-related entities was registered, specifically "FTX Derivatives US LLC".
Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by gojomo on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @12:51PM (#33612574)
…which until recently was 'LedgerX' (still its domain name), & wasn't part of the bankruptcy filing, seems to be operating normally, & has reassured customers their assets are, per its regulated processes, separately custodied (not with the unlicensed/offshore FTX).

So while it takes some time for these things to unravel – it could be the next domino to fall! – there is at least a plausible story that the actual CFTC-licensed entity here (fka LedgerX) was spared the theft & bankruptcy.

That would be a credit to the CFTC's regime, rather than the knock portrayed here.

(I believe that this spin comes from a advocacy group for maximal regulations, firing a salvo to support its factions in DC, taking advantage of confusion about which related but legally-distinct entities are licensed.)

Re:FTX Was Registered with and Licensed by the CFTC, Which F... by kevinpet on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @01:16PM (#33612857)
This comment undermines the whole story and shows that bettermarkets isn't interested in reality, only pushing their agenda.