News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by peterhadlaw on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:29AM (#33596516)
Being somewhat skeptic myself in my younger years and coming closer to God through my relationship with my girlfriend (who isn't even a believer herself)... I just recently came up with a hypothesis why so many Math and CS people were famously Atheist.

I grew closer to God through just observing the natural world, and my natural relationship (affection, friendship, etc.).

My hypothesis is that so many of these (incredibly genius, and logical) people maybe dug a little too deep into man-made reality. Numbers, computers, etc. Everything that goes through a processor is the result of a human invention. It's easy to think you are God, or at the very least, see YOUR creation and totally discredit and influence of God as a result. However if you just look away from the pixels or numbers for a second. The seemingly random, yet beautiful grain, in wood. Or the way tree leaves rustle in the wind.. etc etc, you can see an immense beauty and goodness, not possible without a divine, all-giving power.

No malice on my end towards Atheists, just my opinion (faith) <3

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by leephillips on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:59AM (#33597109)
Others find belief in the “goodness” of a supernatural creator impossible because of their knowledge of the natural world:

https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/494183-i-don-t-know-why-we-...

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by jessermeyer on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:07PM (#33597213)
Mathematicians I personally know well are stoutly religious. They describe the world of number and form and structure with the same kind of language the clergy describe God, and so there is some sense in which these are felt as aspects of the same thing.

I also know a number of engineers who are deeply religious, perhaps encouraged by recognizing "design" in nature, seemingly requiring a designer.

In my conversations with these people, their faith, while socially speaking is Christian, the specifics have hardly anything to do with traditional or orthodox theology. It's, as I perceive this, the only acceptable social structure available to them to live out these deep feelings of beauty and harmony in community.

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by leephillips on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:31PM (#33597632)
I always found Donald Knuth’s professed Christianity somewhat curious. Then I watched a small bit of his interview with Lex Fridman, and happened to catch the part where he speculates that maybe God is a big computer. So, OK.
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by jessermeyer on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:44PM (#33597886)
Knuth had serious doubts in his college days, but ultimately decided it was "OK to believe in something unprovable." Which to me speaks to his humility.
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by JackFr on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:45PM (#33597901)
> where he speculates that maybe God is a big computer.

I cringe at phrases like that. It's empty theologically and technologically. It represents a complete inability in imagining what God could be, and a naive, childish pride in our little creations, these computers. While in his internal driven world view it might make sense, to me it has no more or less truth than "maybe God is a big steam engine"

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by leephillips on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:58PM (#33598089)
Please don’t judge DEK based on my hasty summary; check out the interview for the context. My only point was that the Christianity in the head of someone like Knuth is probably a bit more fluid and creative than whatever’s in the heads of the people who come to your door on Sunday morning to save your soul.
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by JackFr on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:00PM (#33599083)
Yeah - indeed I probably was a little hasty and uncharitable. I have a ton of respect for Knuth both as a computer scientist and as a religious believer. I will try to look up the interview, because I am curious to get the context around the quote.
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by scotty79 on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:19PM (#33602819)
> It represents a complete inability in imagining what God could be, and a naive, childish pride in our little creations [...]

Aren't all religious statements just like that?

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by latexr on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:18PM (#33597415)
> The seemingly random, yet beautiful grain, in wood. Or the way tree leaves rustle in the wind.. etc etc, you can see an immense beauty and goodness, not possible without a divine, all-giving power.

That is quite the statement on the nature of reality, yet it’s entirely based on personal opinion. You don’t know from observation if the “beauty and goodness” of the world is impossible without a divine power, you choose to believe so.

I also pay close attention to the natural world and my relationships, yet don’t feel the slightest inclination to believe in a higher power. If anything, I share Richard Feynman’s view that being analytical about the world makes its beauty shine more, not less: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZbFM3rn4ldo

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by cauefcr on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:19PM (#33597431)
Hey, nice comment, just offering the opposite view here: Disagreeing with faith is the point for many of us atheists, not out of arrogance about knowing the truth about the world, but skepticism about what it means to know a thing for certain, and how far away we are from that certainty.
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by Shorel on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:57PM (#33598071)
And here I am thinking the exact opposite. I think that religion comes from the experience of man made reality, and it is very limited precisely because of that.

The mandate of 'controlling the creation'. The parent-child relationship with the deity. The excessive focus on sexual and parental relationships between humans. All these are human activities, and religion seems to care too much about humans and too little about the rest of the species living on the planet.

Reality is different from religion. It is indifferent to us. Any meaning is just some myth in our heads to try and explain it.

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by DeathArrow on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:38PM (#33598760)
Most of the great mathematicians were religious. As to why is that, we can only speculate. I personally think that while exploring the beautiful worlds of numbers they discovered order and perfection and that got them thinking about Divinity.
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by diehunde on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:05PM (#33604744)
I think it's because they hadn't heard of evolution or big bang theory yet. There are probably way less religious scientist today than there were in the previous centuries.
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by LouisSayers on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:46PM (#33598879)
> not possible without a divine, all-giving power.

I would say the atheist view is actually the same as yours with the exception that "god" isn't a man in the sky.

The way I see religion is as a coping mechanism for dealing with emotion.

When things get hard or tough who can you turn to? What can help ease emotional pain, give you hope when there is none or look out for you when noone else will?

It's simple, let's create an imaginary figure that always has your best interest at heart => God.

Let's now utilise this to help drive the behaviours we want in our tribe => Religious scripture / Church.

Personally I find it much more satisfying to simply admit that we don't know what's out there. Noone on earth has the answers because we're still learning, and we're also stuck in our bubble which we call the universe. Death is just a part of life and a way to recycle our bodies, we're not all that special and that's OK.

Anyone that finds it emotionally helpful to believe in fairytales is free to do so, but I feel like you're missing something even more magical if you can bring yourself to search for it, which is reality itself.

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by fsloth on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:09PM (#33599230)
A fairly long and rambling monologue follows. I don’t think in general atheism or non-religiosity necessarily means what you imply thinking it means.

I was pretty religious as a kid. Then around 12 I realized how broken at least the view of the standard issue christianity was in it’s stern insistence there can be only one god and that other religions must be wrong. That felt completely contradictory to the message of universal love that I felt (as a child) was part of any just form of belief in a higher force. Why would a higher force demand petulant obedience and an obscure message of salvation when there lived countless people untouched by christian message. So either I had to believe all non-christians were wrong and lost (this felt to a 12 year old me an incredibly cruel, unjust and self centered view of the world) or that christianity in fact was not a complete explanation to the spiritual component of our existence, a poor guide in cross cultural panhumanism and - if those parts were broken was there actually anything whole left?

I am not a christian. I respect the spiritual guidance of many prophets, including Jesus and Buddha. I have felt the presence of something holy when trekking in nature. So, yes, I consider spiritual and mystical component of out existence very relevant. I just don’t need to believe that there is anything we can give a name to or bargain with that would be necessarily relevant to these components. Maybe I’m a daoist but I would not go that far. I’m atheist in the sense I don’t see the point in deism. I don’t believe we are the masters of universe and that we must be humble in this life towards the grandeur of existence. I share much of christian ethics because I’ve learned that as a kid, and it mostly makes sense to me as a guide to a wholesome life. I just don’t feel the need to earn salvation points and am content that my spirit is bound to my flesh and will turn to dust as life leaves this body.

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by otikik on Monday November 14, 2022 @04:36PM (#33601510)
> The seemingly random, yet beautiful grain, in wood.

Fractals, my friend.

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by xutopia on Monday November 14, 2022 @08:07PM (#33603870)
I am still in awe at what time and nature is capable of producing and whenever I look at beauty or get contemplative and just take in what is in my surroundings. It's just that there are really great explanations for all of it without requiring the supernatural.

I bet you anything that you read those 2 books back to back and it will shake the foundation of your worldview to the core... of course that's if you actually feel like it can be challenged.

Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by poulpy123 on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:45AM (#33607175)
Which God ? As someone who grew up with the choice of believe or not believe, one of the reason that I stayed atheist was because there was no religion that looks more right than any of the other dozen ones (and thousands when we count branches)
Re:Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topi... by zentr1c on Wednesday November 16, 2022 @12:52AM (#33619401)
I choose atheism when 16 and rediscovered religion at 35. How? whats the difference between a religion and believing in atheism, psychology, social science? in this sense i overcame atheism and started looking at the interesting concepts of religions, introduced geografically and sequentially in time. naturally i decided to dig deeper in my cultures religion at hand instead of idealising the grass is greener far away. my conclusion is that sciences and religions is just a approach to understand and model the world. it would be stupid to ignore the knowledge embeeded in both and there are wrong conclusions embedded that are not easy to identify in both. maybe it seems easier to identify them with! science but still social "science" nowadays seems to me not much more like a new cult trying new approaches challenging thousand year old cults and knowledge embedded in their religion. Like a kid who challenges the parents. In the end it's a natural selection process that will decide what knowledge / models survive through time. Isn't it a beautiful creation process. No need to condemn either approach. The Bible teaches, you shouldnt use gods name in vain. Exodus 20:7. Isnt it true for science, too?