News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by gavinray on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:49AM (#33594712)
Am I the only person who feels like billionaires should do whatever they want with their money and that they earned it?

I feel like a lunatic from what I hear from my wife + social circle + peers.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by happytoexplain on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:51AM (#33594748)
Surely you have heard opposite opinions to your own that are not reductive (as you have written yours)? I.e. I understand that you might disagree with the opinions of others, but I don't understand the implication that you should feel "like a lunatic", since that usually implies that you don't comprehend the opinions of others (which is different from disagreeing).
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by eloisant on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:53AM (#33594788)
No you're not the only one, plenty of people think like that which is why they keep capturing most of the value created by their employees and getting away with it.
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by malfist on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:02AM (#33594927)
I totally agree. They also overlook that this wealth isn't entirely "earned" by the billionaire. After all, wage theft is the most common form of theft.

For a comparison, an amazon warehouse employee making $15 an hour, would have to work 40hrs a week, 52 weeks a year for almost 4 million years to accumulate the wealth Jeff has. Personally, I don't think that's equitable.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by fy20 on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:24AM (#33595300)
Honest question: What is the alternative?

We could apply a really high tax rate to billionaires, but that has its own set of problems and doesn't guarantee anything will change for the warehouse workers. Governments are much less efficient than private companies at spending; a lot of the taxes will go towards 'defense'; which government should tax global companies like Amazon?

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by pmoriarty on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:32AM (#33595440)
"We could apply a really high tax rate to billionaires, but that has its own set of problems"

What problems?

For whom?

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by malfist on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:58PM (#33600053)
For billionaires.

It sounds like "We've tried nothing and we're all out of ideas"

If someone is starving, and you have food to give them, you don't say "We could give them food, but that has it's own set of problems. I guess there's no way to solve the problem"

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by fallingfrog on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:26AM (#33596456)
The employees could vote and decide themselves what to do with the money. After all, they're the ones who do all the work.
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by antisthenes on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:34AM (#33596614)
> Governments are much less efficient than private companies at spending;

This is frequently touted as an axiom, but usually 0 evidence is provided. Can you back this up in any way or form? Or is this just something you've heard as a political talking point?

Looking at the VC craze and company overspending during the Remove/Covid craze, it's completely not evident that private companies are 'better' at spending money than governments. If anything, many of them displayed poor fiscal discipline through overhiring and basing long-term strategies off of a limited-time pandemic.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by Sir_Son_Son on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:34PM (#33598691)
Socialism/communism.
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by nicoburns on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:03AM (#33594965)
I don’t understand how you can possibly think that someone’s contribution to the world is so outsized as to be worth millions of times that of say a teacher or a care worker. Would the world really be that much a worse place without bezos? I actually think there’s a decent argument to be made that it would be better…

Have you just swallowed the idea that the market value of something is equal to its value to society?

I guess I would like to hear your justification that billionaire’s deserve their wealth, bearing in mind that this typically does come at the expense of others.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by Workaccount2 on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:27AM (#33595361)
They deserve their wealth because you keep buying and using their products. If everyone who hated billionaires stopped using amazon tomorrow, Bezos would be in serious trouble.

But alas, Bezos offers a service that enormous amounts of people seemingly can't quit using, which to me (and the market that prices it), is infact worth hundreds of billions.

I haven't used amazon in 2 years. I'm sick of sitting in peoples apartments listening to them cry about billionaires while I'm tripping over prime boxes to get to the bathroom. Wake up.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by pmoriarty on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:39AM (#33595558)
"They deserve their wealth because you keep buying and using their products."

Their products or the products of the people who work for them?

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by Workaccount2 on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:57AM (#33595881)
It's their products.

Fixing wealth inequality doesn't necessitate throwing out the entire legal and economic system we have. Workers can form unions if they they are not being recognized. There is no need to topple capitalism so that amazon can become a nationalized business with an inverted pay hierarchy.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by nicoburns on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:41AM (#33596742)
> Fixing wealth inequality doesn't necessitate throwing out the entire legal and economic system we have

I don't think anyone's suggesting that. More likely they are advocating for higher taxation on the highest earners and perhaps on the largest businesses (notably, we already had this in the 60s/70s/80s). This would leave us with largely the same economic system, except with a counterbalance to a key a flaw in the current setup: that in a given time period, those who already control capital can typically turn that into more capital with much less effort than those who don't start out with that capital.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by pmoriarty on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:59AM (#33595929)
"It's their products."

Amazon as we know it today wasn't made by Bezos, but by the thousands of people that work for him.

It's their company, not his. If anyone has a right to Bezos' billions it's them.

He, of course, deserves a nominal fee... maybe on par with the lowest-paid worker at Amazon.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by Workaccount2 on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:29AM (#33596515)
Legally, no. The company belongs to investors and the workers signed a contractual agreement with those investors.

Any single one of those workers could have spun off and sold their value to any other buyer willing to pay the price they(the worker) wanted. Most don't do this though because they are willing to take a lower pay in order to (greatly) mitigate risk.

Also, as you might be surprised to learn, workers already keep the majority of value they produce. Quick example: Gold mine owner lets workers keep 90% of everything they mine. Gold mine owner doesn't mine at all, but is by far the wealthiest person in the operation.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by happytoexplain on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:51AM (#33595751)
>They deserve their wealth because you keep buying and using their products.

Can you elaborate on this? It doesn't follow at all to me. If somebody makes billions and another person makes thousands, but the billionaire does not work proportionally hard or deliver proportional value to society or does not behave morally, and I buy products from both people, you may (and should) criticize me. However, there's no logical reason that means the billionaire "deserves" all their wealth, if we are using the word "deserve" by its normal conversational definition. The offloading of 100% of responsibility to the consumer seems like a really weak scape-goat based on emotions.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by carapace on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:34PM (#33605330)
Everyone involved was acting voluntarily. No one's forcing people to work at Amazon, nor to buy from Amazon. We all set up these rules of the game, and he played and won.

Don't get me wrong, I think he's an ass. He took Captain Kirk to space, but then dissed him on the ground to pour champagne on the desert. Also I really miss used book stores.

But as a businessman I don't see how he doesn't deserve what he has, he's earned it, eh?

I very much do put the blame on "the consumer", they are the ones who keep giving Bezos money!

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by debacle on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:53AM (#33594768)
The global income distribution model (farmers in India -> Jeff Bezos) is problematic.

But it's such a chaotic system that anyone claiming to have the solution (similar to anyone claiming there is no problem) is likely lying.

The only solution (to me) that even starts to make sense is some sort of forced worker ownership, but lord knows what the details of that might look like.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by ada1981 on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:04AM (#33594981)
We know pretty well what forced worker ownership looks like. Hundreds of millions of people dead.

Needs to be opt-in.

The next wave of famous business people will likely be the Platform Coop-ists.

Activists building unicorns not for the $$$ but for the Klout of taking on the status quo model.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by pmoriarty on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:36AM (#33595514)
There's a difference between brutal totalitarian regimes in which an elite exercise absolute power over millions of people and actual ownership by workers themselves.

It's the elites of those countries which owned everything and controlled everything.

If you weren't part of the elite you had to follow orders.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by debacle on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:20AM (#33595247)
I'm not talking about socialism, I'm talking about worker coops.
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by francisofascii on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:09AM (#33595071)
There isn't much that is admirable, heroic, or likable about keeping wealth to yourself. Should they be forced to give? No. But I think it is fine for your wife and friends to look down on it. Private beaches, ridiculous mansions, crazy car collections, our culture should criticize that.
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by Workaccount2 on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:19AM (#33595220)
What's frustrating to me is that seemingly no one who complains about billionaires actually understands why they are billionaires and what the difference between a checking account and a 20% equity stake are.

I've spent a lot of time trying to think of ways to remedy wealth inequality, and the best I can come up with is "If you hate Bezos so much, you should probably quit your addiction to Amazon Prime."

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by happytoexplain on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:14AM (#33596224)
Yes, there is probably no way to remedy wealth inequality that is easy or even that doesn't have serious downsides and an enormously volatile period of acclimatization. But that doesn't mean there is definitely no realistic way to accomplish it in the long run. Of course we should try to get consumers to stop participating, but making it 100% their responsibility is highly unrealistic/reductionist. Consequences are incredibly abstracted away from consumer behavior, and the good to the consumer's life is so immediately felt, and consumers are understandably desperate for good in life (even something as simple as convenience has a huge impact). It is not entirely, or even mostly, their fault.
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by pmoriarty on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:31AM (#33595419)
Did they actually earn it, or did the people who worked for them earn it?
Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by atonse on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:55AM (#33594830)
Nope you’re not the only lunatic. Add to that the fact that most billionaires don’t “have” wealth the way we think of wealth.

In that, most of it isn’t in some bank account sitting there waiting to be used. What they’re more likely to have truly liquid is probably on the order of many (MANY) millions.

It’s the value of stuff they have like stocks. Yes they can borrow money against those assets but it is never just “why can’t Bezos just do an ACH transfer to ____ nonprofit?”

It’s “just” the size of his stock portfolio in the way your stock portfolio looks if you had put all your money into one stock.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by antisthenes on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:36AM (#33596660)
> Add to that the fact that most billionaires don’t “have” wealth the way we think of wealth.

While it's true that if they were to instantly liquidate all of their stocks/assets, the real number of their "wealth" would be significantly reduced, they still operate with insane amounts of money.

The question still remains though whether at that level of ownership they are still generating enough value as a CEO/board member for the outsized returns they are receiving as an owner.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by alistairSH on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:09AM (#33595059)
During their life, yeah, sure do whatever they want.

Once they pass on? There should be massive impediments to passing on that level of wealth.

Re:Amazon founder Jeff Bezos pledges to give away most of hi... by ryandrake on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:52AM (#33595777)
Here's how I think about it: Would you be OK if a handful of people in the world suddenly became septillionaires? A septillionaire could give $1trillion to every person on the planet every year for 100 years and still have 99.99% of his money left. How much power and influence over the world would someone like that have, while the rest of us have comparatively close to zero net worth and zero income? There are currently no upper limits in our capitalist system, so it's entirely possible for a person to have $1e24 or one day accumulate it.

I think almost everyone would think this should not be allowed, for obvious reasons. So, therefore there is some wealth threshold beyond which it is not good for society to let a few people accumulate. So, what is that threshold?