Now whether it does respect my choice or still record but disable triggering is another matter, but that's sadly the world we got into with our purchasing choices of phones, and why I support the EU going after such privacy issues.
These are tools that should be serving their users, not their creators.
A task it can do, but choose to do a different task, that is better in the intereet of the corporation.
It is a quite harmles example, but it is zelling of the general state of things and where we are heading.
If I buy a device I assume I own it. Thats how it should be. Not that I rent it and the rules to rent change all the time.
The reasonable expectation is that a digital assistant will work for its user and not the corporation that sold it. The corporation is trading on this expectation to exploit its users.
"If you can't freely do anything on the device you own, you're the one owned."
The first step to a better world is acknowledging the prime driver of self interest in human action and designing systems that support that while protecting from too much power. This historically meant strong property rights, strong speech rights and strong antitrust regulation. Wishing that someone would exercise their property and speech rights differently isn't an effective system and regulating them into right think and right action robs us of innovation because there's no reason for anyone to put in the extra effort to make something better beyond trivial improvements since they won't get to keep that benefit while they pay the cost of development, it is far easier to just stay mediocre and not stick your head out.
Correct. Siri is Apple's tool, not yours despite appearences:
Settings -> Privacy & Security -> Analytics & Improvements -> Improve Siri and Dictation switch.
It has the explanatory text ‘Help improve Siri and Dictation by allowing Apple to store and review audio of your Siri and Dictation interactions from this device.’ next to it.
I’m pretty sure the initial state of this is set by your response to a specific question about it during phone setup.
Apple is currently being sued because they only apply their "do not use analytics" setting to other companies analytics. Apple analytics still track you.
Given that, I would not trust any privacy setting from this company.
The complaint alleges, I think, that if you switch off ‘device analytics’ on your phone (the ‘Share iPhone Analytics’ setting?), the App Store app will still send some data about your device to Apple.
At least according to these researchers and this lawsuit.
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/jul/26/apple-con...
Digital assistants do not exist to serve you or your interests. You should assume that your every interaction with one will be exploited in some way for someone else's benefit, or leaked and/or sold to some third party without your knowledge, or both.
I'm not saying apple isn't wrong for what they're doing to sneakily drive more traffic to their own services for profit, but this is exactly the sort of thing you should expect.