Re:On CAD: OnShape is to FreeCAD as FreeCAD is to SolveSpace
by rjsw on Saturday November 12, 2022 @05:54AM
(#33571954)
Siemens is currently trying to make the XT exchange file format into an international standard, perhaps they could overcome the objections to this by making Parasolid open source.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:On CAD: OnShape is to FreeCAD as FreeCAD is to SolveSpace
by phkahler on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:16AM
(#33573828)
Parasolid is really good and that's probably because it's a licensed product used in many commercial programs, so it's well supported. Maybe going GPL plus commercial could work, but it might just kill it.
Re:On CAD: OnShape is to FreeCAD as FreeCAD is to SolveSpace
by rjsw on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:41AM
(#33574077)
They tried to standardize a previous version and were voted down, the reasons for negative votes have not changed, one of them is that the proposed specification isn't enough to implement a clean-room copy.
I will follow up on the open-source idea when we start discussing the next vote.
Re:On CAD: OnShape is to FreeCAD as FreeCAD is to SolveSpace
by Ruthalas on Sunday November 13, 2022 @01:53AM
(#33580709)
Please do. That seems viable, and potentially very beneficial!
Re:On CAD: OnShape is to FreeCAD as FreeCAD is to SolveSpace
by moepstar on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:29PM
(#33585152)
X_T as in "Parasolid"?
Interesting, whats in it for them doing that? Also, considering JT which, as far as i know, is already an ISO standard?
Re:On CAD: OnShape is to FreeCAD as FreeCAD is to SolveSpace
by rjsw on Sunday November 13, 2022 @01:14PM
(#33585675)
The current ISO standard for JT just has an older version of XT as an informative annex, there is a proposal out for voting to make a newer version a normative (required) part of the standard.
Maybe it is intended as a marketing feature "Our exchange file is an ISO standard but the CATIA one is not".