Re:Notmuch
by throwawayiionqz on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:54PM
(#33569509)
Why tag anything at all? If the query is fast you may run the query again. This avoids migrating tags if the query gets modified/improved etc.
i use tags for annotations and actions: this email i need to reply to. that one links to a story i want to read later. etc. it's not possible to search for that without tags, because those states change and don't depend on the actual emails
AFAIK, you need tags at least for read/unread.
I don't really use tags, but have a few searches to archive email from mailing lists without seeing it in my inbox.
For other usecases, I do as you suggested.
Now I'm confused. notmuch does tags while mu does not. If you do NOT need tags, then you want mu. That's the one that doesn't have tags.
mu using standard IMAP folders means it can interoperate with other mail tools. That's the biggest consideration, I think
neomutt's main selling point was that it has first class integration with notmuch and that because that it has a unified inbox like the desktop clients.
One thing I could never figure out with the folderless approach like neomutt is how to make per account compose and responses. In mutt I would set the account based on the folder I'm in and depending on what I'm responding to, but I don't know how to do that in neomutt or rather how to do it when using notmuch in neomutt.
I do use mu4e, which seems to be a bit easier to configure for multiple accounts.
Furthermore, notmuch never ever touches your mail storage. It just operates on tags. It is up to you how to turn tag changes into actions. I find this incredibly elegant and flexible.
I do not tag things manually. I tag incoming messages automatically using searches. Since search is so powerful and quick, I do not really feel I need tags. If you do, mu or mutt/neomutt might be better suited.