News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by gruez on Friday November 11, 2022 @06:52PM (#33568391)
>If they are owned by Bitfinex can they not front-run the Bitfinex order book to guarantee their stops will hit their target? They know the bitfinex order depth for every asset so they can for example buy into bitcoin and then calculate exactly when they must get out.

This makes no sense to me. Can you rephrase/elaborate what you mean by this?

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by djbusby on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:18PM (#33568560)
Bitfinex (B) sees orders incoming for BTC or other currency. Then B acquires for $X. Then B fills the order to clients at $X.03

Boom, $0.03 free money. Multiply by scale of their client base.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by wskinner on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:25PM (#33568615)
1. This only applies to market orders. 2. Bitfinex is not the only exchange where people can trade BTC or other crypto. 3. How does B acquire BTC for $X at scale?
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by dangero on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:08PM (#33568926)
1. They can see an order match for a limit order and preempt it with a better offer before pushing it through by a micro-fraction of a penny

2. They can run trading bots on all major exchanges to keep USDT pegged —- while not foolproof it will hold in most situations provided there is enough liquidity in their accounts on every exchange.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by grey-area on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:26PM (#33568628)
Even more profitable is printing their own currency with nothing backing it, then lying about having it fully backed to set the value at or just below $1.

Each USDT printed and sold to a sucker = $1 USD free money.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by raven105x on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:38PM (#33568710)
You're describing post-1971 USD. It's getting difficult to tell which currency is the bigger scam at this point.
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by tartoran on Friday November 11, 2022 @07:49PM (#33568786)
Except the latter is backed by an army and you can actually buy stuff with it. The former is so volatile that you don’t know if it’ll exist next year or not
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by andirk on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:01PM (#33568856)
8% of every dollar in your pocket a year ago no longer exists.
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by djbusby on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:30PM (#33569078)
Military still there tho.

Edit: happy Veterans Day (USA) to those who served.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by wizeman on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:38PM (#33569433)
What does the military have to do with the USD?

Many countries had a military and that didn't stop their currencies from completely collapsing.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by Dylan16807 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @10:52AM (#33584118)
The power of a major government behind a currency is like the framing of a building.

A building with a frame can collapse, but the odds are much worse if you don't have one.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by wizeman on Sunday November 13, 2022 @03:42PM (#33587123)
> The power of a major government behind a currency is like the framing of a building.

Only if the frame were able to make decisions that devalue or collapse the building without anyone being able to stop it (and quite a few "frames" have done that). As you can see, not a good analogy.

> A building with a frame can collapse, but the odds are much worse if you don't have one.

Well, actually the "frame" is the cause of the collapse. A "building" without the "frame" wouldn't actually collapse due to hyperinflation.

Although I'm not sure what "being backed by the military" has anything to do with what you said. It's not like the military is going to do something when a currency is devalued by a government or when it collapses.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by Dylan16807 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:43PM (#33587658)
Uh, plenty of currencies not tied to governments have collapsed.

And the military is part of keeping the country going and enforcing the currency as legal tender.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by wizeman on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:56PM (#33587782)
> Uh, plenty of currencies not tied to governments have collapsed.

Widely used currencies? Which ones?

> And the military is part of keeping the country going and enforcing the currency as legal tender.

No, actually it isn't. The courts and law enforcement are. And legal tender doesn't mean that a citizen or company has to accept the currency (unless it's for a payment of a debt, and even then there are several restrictions).

Which is why even if we're both in the US, I could sell you something for bitcoins (or EUR or whatever) and neither the military, nor the courts nor law enforcement would do anything to enforce that I sell you things for the USD instead.

So saying that a currency is "backed by the military" means nothing.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by Smithalicious on Saturday November 12, 2022 @03:06AM (#33571120)
I've asked this before and every time it's been ignored and downvoted, but it's a genuine question that I do want answered, so I'll ask again: what does this mean? how does the US military guarantee the value of the dollar? It seems to me like the main capability of the military is killing people, and the definition of the "the dollar has value" is "people will accept dollars in exchange for goods and services". Is the military going to kill people who refuse to accept dollars as payment? What does the scenario where the military gets involved in this look like?

If this is somehow an offensive question or reads as trolling I would love to know, because I don't understand the statement and I don't understand why nobody is willing to answer me.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by rsj_hn on Saturday November 12, 2022 @04:54AM (#33571677)
This is a good question!

There are two sources of demand for a currency: consumption demand - you want to buy American-made goods -- and investment demand - you want to buy American capital.

In terms of consumption demand, as long as the US produces large quantities of goods for sale that the rest of the world wants, there will be this demand for dollars.

Similarly, as long as the US is a safe haven for other countries to store their wealth, knowing that we will not confiscate their investment and maintain the purchasing power of the dollar over time, there will be this investment demand. When people talk about the dollar being a "reserve currency", what they refer to is this investment demand. It's good to invest in the US because your money will be safe here. Many focus on, say, oil being priced in dollars, but what matters more is where you store the proceeds of your sale, and that's a decision based on where you think your money will be safe to store over the long term.

Therefore operationally, the US military has nothing to do with the desirability of the dollar -- except to undermine it with excess military spending :)

However one observes that the U.S. tends to fight a major war every 25 years or so, and invades/bombs a country every year or two, and all of this is done to promote US interests, of which we assume that economic interests play an important role. Those who try to interpret US geopolitical strategy in terms of serving business interests assume that we will use our military to ensure a steady supply of cheap raw materials and open markets for our goods, and therefore this indirectly supports the consumption demand for the dollar.

To a lesser degree, having a large army protect the country tells investors that the factory they buy wont be bombed or taken over by a rival power, which supports the investment demand as well.

In this way, the US military is said to support the dollar.

However I am skeptical of this interpretation of US geopolitical behavior. It may have been the case in the 1900s, and to a lesser degree in the 1980s, but I don't think it's the case today. Today, the US military - on balance - is a drag on the dollar. Getting into a detailed debate about this would require taking a long inventory of US interventions over the last few decades, which is over 100 interventions -- and then decide whether they promoted the investment and consumption demands, on net.

But just to sketch an idea of the argument, now we have sanctions against Venezuela, Iran, and Russia, which are a good chunk of the world's oil supply. Far from using our military to ensure a steady supply of raw materials, we are actually cutting ourselves off from raw materials. Moreover the purpose of sanctions is to prevent selling our goods in other countries. Therefore clearly the purpose of the sanctions policy is not to support the consumption demand for dollars, either via protecting inputs, nor via keeping markets open.

Finally, we are busy gearing up for a conflict with China, which again would not be good for the business community.

Really US geopolitics is difficult to understand at the moment - whatever goals or grand strategy we have, it's no longer the case that safeguarding the dollar is one of these goals. I believe that, during the cold war, this was a goal, because fighting communism could be justified as keeping markets open to the US. But since the 1990s, things began to change.

Honestly I don't even understand why we are still bombing Yemen(*) or still have troops in Syria, or what the point of occupying Afghanistan was. Maybe making defense contractors richer, but that doesn't support either the consumption or investment demand for the dollar.

Therefore although our military is a powerful tool, it's not the case that we are still using this tool to support the dollar.

Long term, this is bad news for the dollar.

- - -

(*) Technically, Saudi Arabia is bombing Yemen with US planes and US ammunition. However, we also send US pilots in the planes to "advise" the Saudi pilots, and they often do the bombing. There is a lot of sheep-dipping going on as well here and in other proxy wars.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by shuckles on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:09PM (#33568928)
Not only is that adjacent to, but itself, a wrong statement, what does it even have to do with anything?
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by andirk on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:14PM (#33568978)
It's an absolute, direct and very obvious reply to the comment "that you don’t know if it’ll exist next year or not".

Current inflation causes each dollar to have a noticeable less value. I though ppl on HN and in 2nd grade knew this.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by tartoran on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:40PM (#33569132)
Inflation is horrible but what alternatives does crypto provide? It seems like 7-10 is still more acceptable than 90% or even 100% loss. I did buy some crypto and its value tanked so much it’s not even worth selling it anymore. Wish I just left the money in my banking account or done something with it… I did buy into the hype but fully admit I was an idiot for doing so. At least I learned that it’s best to stay as far away as possible from this space. What’s even more interesting is that Im adverse to gambling and all that…
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by shuckles on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:25PM (#33569034)
Inflation is a measure of purchasing power. I have all the dollars in my pocket and, depending on what I'm trying to buy like shipments of containers from Shanghai to Los Angeles, I could possibly buy more goods and services from last year.

I think your comments are below the level of quality the HN community demands.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by andirk on Friday November 18, 2022 @08:12PM (#33665527)
For most consumers, 8% of the dollars in your pocket are gone. It means you have less money now than you did a year ago.

> I have all the dollars in my pocket

OK, you must be talking physical paper?

> I could possibly buy more goods

Most consumers are currently hurting from inflation.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by pyinstallwoes on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:49PM (#33569182)
If you have 100,000 BTC and it goes down to 0, you still have 100,000 btc.
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by amluto on Friday November 11, 2022 @09:35PM (#33569416)
What’s the bitcoin ecosystem worth as a collectible?

(Keep in mind that BTC at a low enough valuation is either unmineable and thus can’t be transacted or is mineable for very little money and thus subject to 51% attacks by anyone who is inspired to do so.)

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by pyinstallwoes on Friday November 11, 2022 @10:04PM (#33569556)
If you had 100,000 shells and the shells are worth 0, you still have 100,000 shells.
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by sireat on Saturday November 12, 2022 @04:12AM (#33571455)
Beanie babies, tulips, German marks from 1920s at least have some physical properties just like shells.

If you have 100,000 cryptocurrency tokens worth 0, that presumably means there is no activity (no transactions, no validations, no mining).

I suppose one could set up a few validators and attempt to restart the chain.

The problem is that for many worthless coins that no one wants to mine, the difficulty is too high to restart.

So that leaves forking the chain with lower difficulty requirements, which is just as pointless.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by amluto on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:37AM (#33572919)
Indeed. If you have 100k shells, you can at least sell them on Craigslist. With a fully collapsed Bitcoin valuation, the last “good” state of the chain is public knowledge, and you may know the private key associated with 100k BTC as indicated by the last good chain, but you can’t reliably do anything with that knowledge.

So the chain itself could become a fascinating artifact, but the magic that made it possible to move Bitcoin around would be gone.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by pyinstallwoes on Sunday November 13, 2022 @10:10AM (#33583702)
Just because you have the 100k shells doesn't mean you can sell them.
Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by Stention314 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @04:43PM (#33577409)
I love this.

That's such a beautiful example why Bitcoin is garbage.

If you have 100.000k shells and have 0 value you still have physically 100.000k shells you can still do things with.

While you have literally a private key representing 100.000k bitcoins with no value.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by rhino369 on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:04PM (#33568891)
It's not a scam if everyone knows how the system works. The Federal Reserve doesn't pretend like the dollar is backed by anything. The Federal Reserve also manipulates supply to try to keep prices stable. They've messed that up the last two years, but rather just continuing to print money they are reducing the supply on purpose.

It's nothing like Tether.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by roenxi on Friday November 11, 2022 @08:14PM (#33568973)
Everyone knows how Tether works. I bought some after the de-peg before the most recent one anyway because I needed something worth about $1 USD to buy Monero. And I'd still be happy to point out that USDT is unbacked and extremely risky (ie, going to collapse eventually by design).

It is obvious that the people who own "wealth" in Tether will lose it sooner or later. If there are a large pool of people who believe Tether is 1:1 backed they:

1. Haven't read any news about Tether.

2. Haven't researched it at all.

3. Aren't a member of any social network like HN where Tether's flaws are trumpeted.

4. Are quite gullible.

EDIT 5. Haven't looked at a price chart of Tether showing it's regular de-pegs.

Such a person will fall for any scam, Crypto-related or otherwise. Regulated industries will still have people willing to take all their money since they aren't financially literate.

> The Federal Reserve also manipulates supply to try to keep prices stable.

Prices rise continuously, that isn't stable. The Fed tries to keep the rate that the US dollar loses value stable. The backers of Tether are making better guarantees than the Fed are - actual stability. They have less power to force people to go along with them though.

Re:Tether's Troubles in November 2022 by gruez on Saturday November 12, 2022 @02:59PM (#33576448)
That's just front running though? I'm not sure how tether has to do with it. You can pull that off with or without creating a stablecoin with questionable backing.