News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Prospects for War with China by rsj_hn on Sunday November 06, 2022 @03:01PM (#33496441)
counterpoint:

The US is free at any time to stop invading other countries, trying to overthrow other countries, and enter into conflicts thousands of miles from their borders. But really, it doesn't seem that they do.

The US has invaded or attacked over 120 countries since 1991[1]. Absolutely none of them were a threat to the United States. How many countries has China invaded in the same period? How many has it bombed? Imposed sanctions on? Occupied?

[1]https://sites.tufts.edu/css/mip-research/

Re:The Prospects for War with China by stale2002 on Sunday November 06, 2022 @03:30PM (#33496751)
How does US invasions have anything to do with the fact that China is publicly saying that they want to invade the independent country of Taiwan?
Re:The Prospects for War with China by CogitoCogito on Sunday November 06, 2022 @03:17PM (#33496613)
The US isn’t threatening to invade Taiwan. China is.
Re:The Prospects for War with China by rsj_hn on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:18PM (#33497300)
The article is about prospects of war between the US and China. According to official US policy, which is the One China policy, Taiwan and mainland China are the same country, and any disputes between the mainland and Taiwan is an intra-chinese dispute, not a dispute between two separate countries, and not anything that involves the U.S. at all.

Now if, for some reason, Taiwan declares independence, then it will be up to other nations to recognize that declaration of independence or not. But that has not happened.

Let me ask you, did you recognize the independence of Donetsk People's Republic, Lugansk People's Republic, South Ossetia, Kurdish Republic in Iraq, or The Republic of Tigray? Each of these had de facto control -- they have their own police, flag, they control their territory, etc. Some even have oil. These actually declared independence whereas Taiwan never did.

But you will respond, other nations didn't recognize their independence, to which I will ask, who recognizes Taiwanese independence?

Moreover, Do you think it was unwarranted aggression when Georgia invaded South Ossetia, or when Ukraine attacked the DNR and LPR or when Ethiopia attacked Tigray? Or did you view that as an internal matter, of putting down a rebellious breakaway region? Think carefully before you answer, as we are looking for consistency.

It does seem like there is a whole lot of cherry picking going on here, where if there is an enemy of the U.S. fighting a breakaway region, then we have to honor the bold independence movement, but when there is a friend of the US fighting a breakaway republic, then we condemn the evil separatists. In both cases, the US ends up fighting on one side of what is really a civil war we have no business involving ourselves in, and because we choose sides purely based on friend/enemy distinctions and not according to any consistent principles, it sure looks a lot like more international meddling.

Therefore I reject any moral impetus that forces the US to get itself involved in trying to support or oppose separatist movements half way around the world, or to pick sides in civil wars. We lack the military capability, we lack popular support, and we need to stop adopting these self-destructive and globally destructive policies.

Re:The Prospects for War with China by CogitoCogito on Sunday November 06, 2022 @06:05PM (#33498519)
> The article is about prospects of war between the US and China. According to official US policy, which is the One China policy, Taiwan and mainland China are the same country, and any disputes between the mainland and Taiwan is an intra-chinese dispute, not a dispute between two separate countries, and not anything that involves the U.S. at all.

The US has never recognized PRC claims to Taiwan. The US “One China Policy” does not include “Taiwan is part of PRC territory”.

But I’ll admit the US policy is a bit vague and confusing so many people (including apparently you) don’t understand US policy in this matter.

Re:The Prospects for War with China by Apocryphon on Sunday November 06, 2022 @06:42PM (#33498911)
> The US has never recognized PRC claims to Taiwan. The US “One China Policy” does not include “Taiwan is part of PRC territory”.

The U.S. does not have to do that to do what the GP says -

"> According to official US policy, which is the One China policy, Taiwan and mainland China are the same country, and any disputes between the mainland and Taiwan is an intra-chinese dispute, not a dispute between two separate countries"

- rather they have historically recognized the ROC's claims to Taiwan, and to the mainland as well, which of course is a diplomatic fig leaf at this point.

Re:The Prospects for War with China by CogitoCogito on Sunday November 06, 2022 @06:54PM (#33499054)
If we’re all clear that US policy does not consider Taiwan a part of China (i.e. the PRC), I don’t have more to add.
Re:The Prospects for War with China by Apocryphon on Sunday November 06, 2022 @06:57PM (#33499092)
U.S. policy officially considers it as a part of China (i.e. the ROC). That is de facto not a viable reality for many decades now, but it is the de jure legal fiction. As such, your criticism of the GP is incorrect. Because they were correct in asserting "According to official US policy, which is the One China policy, Taiwan and mainland China are the same country", Washington just disagrees with Beijing which that same country is.
Re:The Prospects for War with China by CogitoCogito on Sunday November 06, 2022 @07:07PM (#33499207)
You seem to refer to some fictional country when you use “China”. Basically all people refer to an actual country that does exist: the PRC. So when I say the US policy is not that Taiwan is part of China, I mean that US policy is not that Taiwan is part of the PRC.

So I’m not really sure what your point is. Is your point that US policy states that Taiwan is part of the PRC? If you’re not staying that, you’re not disagreeing with me.

Re:The Prospects for War with China by Apocryphon on Sunday November 06, 2022 @07:12PM (#33499260)
> You seem to refer to some fictional country when you use “China”.

That's precisely how the One China policy works. That's literally what strategic ambiguity is about.

In a 1972 joint communiqué with the PRC, the United States "acknowledges that all Chinese on either side of the Taiwan Strait maintain there is but one China and that Taiwan is a part of China" and "does not challenge that position."

So it's talking about a hypothetical sovereign authority that extends over both the Chinese mainland and Taiwan. At present, the U.S. government recognizes the ROC, based in Taipei, as that government. It's a legal fiction, yes, but one that remains unchanged since 1972.

> Is your point that US policy states that Taiwan is part of the PRC?

The point is U.S. policy states that mainland China is part of the ROC!

Notes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Policy_of_deliberate_ambiguity...

Re:The Prospects for War with China by philliphaydon on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @11:39AM (#33520973)
No. The US does NOT consider Taiwan part of China. The US acknowledges China's position that it believes Taiwan is part of China.

This is like saying "i accept that you think the sky is neon yellow".

Re:The Prospects for War with China by rsj_hn on Sunday November 06, 2022 @08:32PM (#33499914)
> The US has never recognized PRC claims to Taiwan.

This is wildly false.

Here is the Shanghai communique:

https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Shanghai_Communiqu%C3%A9

"11. The Chinese side reaffirmed its position: the Taiwan question is the crucial question obstructing the normalization of relations between China and the United States; the Government of the People's Republic of China is the sole legal government of China; Taiwan is a province of China which has long been returned to the motherland; the liberation of Taiwan is China's internal affair in which no other country has the right to interfere; and all US forces and military installations must be withdrawn from Taiwan. The Chinese Government firmly opposes any activities which aim at the creation of "one China, one Taiwan", "one China, two governments", "two Chinas", an "independent Taiwan" or advocate that "the status of Taiwan remains to be determined".

12.The US side declared: The United States acknowledges that all Chinese on either side of the Taiwan Strait maintain there is but one China and that Taiwan is a part of China. The United States Government does not challenge that position. It reaffirms its interest in a peaceful settlement of the Taiwan question by the Chinese themselves. With this prospect in mind, it affirms the ultimate objective of the withdrawal of all US forces and military installations from Taiwan. In the meantime, it will progressively reduce its forces and military installations on Taiwan as the tension in the area diminishes. The two sides agreed that it is desirable to broaden the understanding between the two peoples. To this end, they discussed specific areas in such fields as science, technology, culture, sports and journalism, in which people-to-people contacts and exchanges would be mutually beneficial. Each side undertakes to facilitate the further development of such contacts and exchanges."

Re:The Prospects for War with China by stale2002 on Sunday November 06, 2022 @04:06PM (#33497147)
US invasions have nothing to do with the fact that China is publicly saying that they want to invade the independent country of Taiwan.
Re:The Prospects for War with China by UltraViolence on Monday November 07, 2022 @09:21AM (#33506073)
The U.S. doesn't even recognize Taiwan as an independent nation, so your remark is moot.
Re:The Prospects for War with China by stale2002 on Monday November 07, 2022 @12:57PM (#33509465)
Its not moot, no. Because Taiwan has its own laws, taxes, border, and military, and this has been the case for 70 years.

It is already independent because of those facts, no matter what words are written on a piece of paper.

And, it is related, because china constantly makes threats to invade Taiwan.

Re:The Prospects for War with China by UltraViolence on Monday November 07, 2022 @01:29PM (#33509994)
The U.S. betrayed Taiwan 50 years ago by accepting China's rule over Taiwan and ceasing to recognize it as an independent nation.

Threatening to try to dissuade the Chinese from invading is the only thing Biden can do. When Xi finally gives the "go" he'll make up some excuse not to intervene militarily. He'll slap sanctions on China, for sure , but those will merely be a pinprick.

Re:The Prospects for War with China by stale2002 on Monday November 07, 2022 @11:50PM (#33515965)
You are ignoring the point.

The original post you were replying to was attacking China for it's threats to invade, and was defending sanctions.

That point is valid.

So yes, sanctions against china are justified, which was the original context, and they are justified because of the points about China threatening to invade.

> is the only thing Biden can do

Actually, the US can continue what we have been doing for a while, which is continue to sell more and more weapons to Taiwan.

The more weapons we give to Taiwan, the more invaders will die in any invasion.

Maximizing their ability to increase invader death numbers, by continuing to do this, is also a good plan.

Re:The Prospects for War with China by philliphaydon on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @11:49AM (#33521133)
The US voted against replacing the ROC with PRC in the UN.

The position of the US has never changed. It has always maintained that any unification must be peaceful and that Taiwan cannot be forced. It gets to decide for itself.

Taiwan has changed in the last 100 years. Majority of the ROC is gone, those here now have no desire to be part of China, don't consider themselves as part of China or Chinese. They just want to continue to live their lives as they are now.

The US does not consider Taiwan as part of China. The One China Policy states that they acknowledge the position of China that Taiwan is part of it. The equiv of me saying to you "i accept that you think the sky looks like the inside of a watermelon".

All of this ignores that Mao and the CCP considered Taiwan an independent nation and nationality prior to Taiwan being handed to the ROC.