https://www.private-eye.co.uk/crossword
Private eye crossword, with downloadable version for use in apps, which references british (and world) politics.
like the default isn't to just briefly explain it, the default is to genuinely confused for the next 5 minutes and derail the whole conversation
No kidding. I've been seeing puzzles lately where so many answers are so completely obscure that finding half of their letters isn't enough. Unsolveable. Which leads me to wonder (who could know all this stuff?) if the answers aren't being filled in by machine.
To me, a word is a word and I struggle with piecemealing them.
I do NYT despite being British and I had to learn more than I ever wanted about the US and baseball, but it was a subconscious process. It is frustrating when they mention some obscure 70s TV show but I can usually get it from the crossings.
Seems purposefully obscure to me, though I enjoy them and make a point of explaining there's rules to anyone who shows some interest.
Googling now, it seems the guardian has a blog for beginners that covers this:
https://www.theguardian.com/crosswords/series/cryptic-crossw...
I have seen the Guardians solutions and even their explanations, but they depend on things I don't understand, dated references, how tiny parts of the UK talk or worse, sports or celebrity crap I don't want to know.
I have trouble when I catch it today because it often has a lot of modern pop culture references that are apparently not to my taste. People or songs I've not only not heard, but not heard of.
Then again, maybe I'm just getting old and yelling at the clouds.
There were questions from shows that ended in the 80's. Random political questions about nonsense. None of the questions seemed fair or reasonable. It's like going to a meetup but everyone except you have been best friends for 40 years and just keeps talking over you.
I immediately gave up and never even attempted to try again. I absolutely know I made the right call.
There's just too much art, too many books, too many TV shows, and too much access to it all, to go back to the mostly-shared corpus of mostly-mutually-understandable cultural references we had in the 20th century. You would think that people would at least have read the really famous books, or seen the super popular TV shows, but I am regularly surprised to meet people who haven't.
Fair clues are foundational to crosswords, and foundational to fairness is understanding what the solver can be expected to know.
A Guardian crossword last week referenced The Beatles, Anthony Eden, and the Russian revolution. Fair game? All part of a standard British upbringing, surely? Perhaps for now, but for how long?