News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by zdragnar on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:37AM (#33468476)
This seems rather strange to me, having immersed myself in the rocket mass heater community a bit.

Sand is generally the last option to choose for thermal mass, because it is so inefficient at storing heat; the very air between the grains acts as insulation.

Instead, clay (or clay mixed with straw to form cob) is the preferred medium for storing heat, as it is a significantly better conductor and stores much more heat energy than the air between the grains of sand.

It seems like they are using the air as a medium here- the article states that they blow air through the sand, and the resistive bands heat up the air, which then sheds some of the heat onto the sand (or picks some heat up off the sand, depending on if it is storing or discharging).

I guess the cheapness and simplicity of construction makes this a better option at the scale they're operating at, but it's pretty wild to imagine how much more efficient the system could be if it had been designed differently.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by LordHeini on Friday November 04, 2022 @11:55AM (#33468740)
Don't confuse heat capacity with conductivity.

And the air is blown through pipes in the sand, which means you need something which will easily surround the pipes.

Solid materials would suffer from thermal expansion problems (like cracking), while liquids evaporate so sand seem to be a reasonable choice.

For their application the conductivity does not really matter and the cheap reject sand was chosen because it has the best mass to price ratio.

It is heated to 600°C so it would be not the best idea to use clay with straw ;)

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by zdragnar on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:07PM (#33469003)
Ah, I missed the pipes bit. Yes, that is exactly how the mass storage heaters I am familiar with work- pipes run through clay, which does need to be fully dried before you heat it to avoid cracking.

I did overlook the 600*C bit at first- straw would definitely be a bad idea, lol. I still would guess that the additional cost of clay would be worth it. Clay is both more conductive AND has better capacity- the air between the grains of sand is an insulator, and has significantly lower storage capacity than the grains of sand themselves.

Another option some people use if they don't want a permanent installation (or just need occasional portability) is large stones with gravel for fill. It's quite a bit less efficient than clay, but the larger size of the gravel and rocks inside make it a better option than sand.

I imagine they have done the math on the cost of the sand and the efficiency they are getting out of it, it just goes against everything I have ever learned about thermal mass storage from the permie / rocket heater mass storage community.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by LordHeini on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:46PM (#33469705)
Yep.

I have not seen a picture of the filler but they said its the cheapest sand they could get (probably even free).

So i assume it is mostly rocks and gravel anyway.

Not sure about the math here, but it is surely cheaper to build a bigger tank with crappy sand than a smaller one with more expensive clay.

I would say rocket heaters have more constraints on space while for a large industrial tank you would not really care about it being large and heavy.

From an efficiency standpoint you will not run into many problems, since the efficiency of heat based systems is based on the thermal loss.

Thermal loss occurs on the walls and in processing (like the rest heat in the air venting out of the system).

The process losses are independent of your storage material and often unavoidable.

And since those are large installations, the mass to wall ratio is really really good (square–cube law).

If you make them big enough not much insulation is required and the overall efficiency is high.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by 0cf8612b2e1e on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:59PM (#33471942)
>… but they said its the cheapest sand they could get (probably even free).

For a one time capex on an industrial installation, what would it matter? As long as the material is not liquid gold, it seems like the material is a drop in the bucket for everything else you have to maintain (personal, pumps, generators, etc).

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by simplotek on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:37PM (#33474942)
> Not sure about the math here, but it is surely cheaper to build a bigger tank with crappy sand than a smaller one with more expensive clay.

It's also interesting that the sand is heated with energy generated from wind turbines and solar panels, which means that as long as enough energy is being thrown into the thermal capacitor, it will heat up with little cost. From this point onward, it's an economics problem. Either money is thrown at the efficiency of these heating capacitors, which brings at most small gains, or money is thrown in building additional storage capacity for cheap along with increasing how much energy is fed into the system. Would it be more cost effective in replacing sand with more efficient materials, or spend the money in, say, another cheap thermal energy source?

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by zdragnar on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:59PM (#33475212)
> Either money is thrown at the efficiency of these heating capacitors, which brings at most small gains,

It really depends on whether the air in the system is a closed loop or not while they are building up the heat in the device. Sand is, at best, going to be about 1/3 as efficient as clay in an open system (hot air goes in, travels through some pipes, then comes back out as waste exhaust). This number is based on experiments with rocket mass heaters I've seen. It could actually be worse- I honestly can't remember if the 1/3 number was for sand, or the large rock (think bowling ball sized) + gravel mix, which was more efficient than sand.

In this scenario, since your input energy is basically free, more storage capacity = more money, and switching to clay could triple your effective capacity.

If, on the other hand, air is blown in a closed loop, you really only risk burning out your fan and resistive heating elements faster (they don't get cooled down by fresh air). In this scenario, 100% of the energy eventually transfers into the sand, so you're really only losing money if you need to spend more on land for setting up additional units.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by simplotek on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:31PM (#33475602)
> In this scenario, since your input energy is basically free, more storage capacity = more money, and switching to clay could triple your effective capacity.

That's all fine and dandy, but the whole point is that projects are evaluated in terms of money and not joules. This means that if a material like clay is , as you claim, 3 times more efficient but ends up costing twice or more to replace and more to maintain, you are in reality looking at a prospective best-case scenario that lies somewhere significant losses or irrelevant gains.

Meanwhile, building the exact same sand-based prototype right next to the original one would literally double the capacity at a far smaller cost.

People want to get warm, not discuss whether clay or sand pack as much heat. Half the world could not care less about what goes into AA batteries.

Projects are evaluated in financial and economical terms. It matters nothing if there's a theoretical possibility that some other material or design is more efficient, if it's savings are irrelevant. The world rides Volkswagens, not Formula 1 cars.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by zdragnar on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:13PM (#33476592)
What makes you think any part of this conversation is theoretical? I'm speaking with the experiences of people who do this for a living.

A few tons of clay are not doing to cost more than the benefit from an operating lifetime of triple returns.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by isoprophlex on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:10PM (#33469049)
No in fact this is a bloody brilliant design: they turn it into a huge fluidized bed reactor and extract the heat with air!

See this fun fluidized sand-filled jacuzzi if you're not grokking my too brief explanation:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=My4RA5I0FKs

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by Havoc on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:48PM (#33469777)
>the very air between the grains acts as insulation.

That seems like a benefit if you're looking to stretch release of energy over many hours?

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by sharedfrog on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:07PM (#33471279)
Weeks, in their case.
Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by zdragnar on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:17PM (#33471416)
It also actively prevents heat from transferring into the sand, and stores far less heat than the sand itself. If you really want mass heated to 600C to be stretched as long as possible, you need as little air in the mass as possible. That's why in residential mass storage, the preference goes in order of:

- rock / gravel mix (lowest preference unless portability is a requirement)

- clay / cob mix (super fine particles, little to no air)

- water

where water is held separately from the heat source and some form of heat exchanger is used. Aside from the mess caused by leaks, accidental pressurization turns water thermal mass storage into a bit of a bomb (much like a vastly oversized pressure cooker) so it's really only used in outdoor wood-fired boilers. Also, the temp is usually capped at 180F, so nowhere near what these guys are getting.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by sfink on Friday November 04, 2022 @03:33PM (#33472519)
> It also actively prevents heat from transferring into the sand

So it's slower to charge. And the charge speed is presumably adjustable by circulating more air (or moving it through faster). It's unclear whether this is a problem for its intended application. It may charge fast enough.

> and stores far less heat than the sand itself.

That would only be relevant if you were comparing an equal volume. The same mass of clay and sand should store roughly the same amount of energy, it's just that the sand one would be bigger to accommodate more air. And being bigger isn't even a drawback here, since bigger means proportionally less surface area to volume that you're losing heat through.

> That's why in residential mass storage, ...

"Residential" could imply that you don't want a giant sand silo in the middle of some housing units, so I agree there. You would need to put this somewhere that size doesn't matter much.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by Someone on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:32PM (#33474098)
> “Residential" could imply that you don't want a giant sand silo in the middle of some housing units, so I agree there. You would need to put this somewhere that size doesn't matter much.

Can’t you build that silo underground? If so, size wouldn’t matter much. You could have a playground, communal garden or, if you must, parking spaces on top of it, so it wouldn’t really use any area.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by zdragnar on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:17PM (#33475437)
Digging out, building retaining walls and waterproofing (you really don't want ground water or rain water getting into your 600 degree C sand) and so forth make it much cheaper and more practical to build above ground.
Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by zdragnar on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:15PM (#33475412)
A few things:

Clay weighs significantly more than sand. For the same volume of material, clay will store significantly more thermal energy. The big question is- is the hot air on a closed loop or an open loop? I don't know of too many fans comfortable cycling 600C air, which means that you need an open loop of air (fresh air > fan > heater > sand > exhaust). If the sand isn't drawing heat off of the hot air fast enough, the heat won't actually "sink" in through the sand. If we are talking a closed loop of air (fan > heater > sand > fan) then the sand will get fully heated.

My reference to "residential" is the aformentioned rocket stove mass heater- see https://richsoil.com/rocket-stove-mass-heater.jsp or https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fwCz8Ris79g and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ptwncPImuo if you prefer videos. These types of things typically stay warm for about 24 hours, so they're burned once a day, maybe once every other day depending on how the house is insulated.

Since these are all wood fired, they must be open loop, and sand is almost universally acknowledged as a terrible idea to use for thermal storage.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by Someone on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:43PM (#33474235)
> Also, the temp is usually capped at 180F, so nowhere near what these guys are getting.

I think that’s a good reason for them to not use water. _If_ you’re designing for 600°C, I would think using water is quite risky.

I would also think sand at 600°C stores more energy per volume or mass than water at 180°F.

Re:A sand battery could transform clean energy by sharedfrog on Friday November 04, 2022 @01:57PM (#33471093)
They rely on sand to provide some insulation, alongside whatever they use in the walls of the containers. They heat the centre of the sand higher than the outside.