News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by rippercushions on Friday November 04, 2022 @04:55AM (#33463661)
I lost access to a PayPal account I had used for years, because one day they decided they needed to know the CVV of a long-expired credit card, and refused to let me log in without it.

Surprisingly, customer support was very helpful and let me transfer out the (minimal) balance in the account to another, completely unconnected PayPal business account I happened to have. Which is even more disconcerting, because it meant they were sufficiently convinced about my identity to let me transfer money out, but not enough to let me login in. Insane.

I'm still (very, very occasionally) using that business account today, even though the underlying business also ceased to exist years ago. I wonder when the banhammer will drop?

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by xnorswap on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:35AM (#33463921)
Transferring money out is far lower risk than unauthorised account access.

If they transfer money out and it turns out it was fraud they can easily compensate the original account holder by putting the money back in their account and there's little harm done, especially if the sums are small.

If they give unauthorised account access then there's far greater harm including risk they'll get penalised by regulators over data security as well as the damage being potentially hard to undo if further changes are made to the account.

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by P5fRxh5kUvp2th on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:52AM (#33465740)
The point is that requiring cvv for a login is stupid, not that the risk levels are different.

Does it become acceptable to require the blood of my first-born because the risk levels are different?

Of course not. They're not even allowed to store that in the US (PCI-DSS), so the other poster must not be in the US.

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by jefftk on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:07AM (#33465980)
Your GP had "it meant they were sufficiently convinced about my identity to let me transfer money out, but not enough to let me login in. Insane", and your parent is explaining why that's a non-insane thing.
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by rippercushions on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:24AM (#33466252)
GP here. I found every part of the process insane. To enumerate:

1) getting locked out for not having the CVV of some random card that expired a decade earlier

2) being allowed to transfer money out, but not to login into the account

3) being allowed to keep my second account, even though they don't trust me enough to give me access to the first

None of these make sense individually, and they make even less sense as a whole.

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by ballenf on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:54AM (#33466706)
They probably couldn't see the CVV but were going to run the card and see if it verified.
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by P5fRxh5kUvp2th on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:06PM (#33471267)
fair enough
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by markwkw on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:10AM (#33466034)
In a large corporation, different precesses can be handled and developed by separate teams often working in silos.

After many years, there may not be a force to assure these processes are consistent, have rules that make sense in relation to one a other. I think the answer may just be it’s “dumb” because no one cares or has the power or will to look at things holistically.

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by adolph on Friday November 04, 2022 @12:00PM (#33468851)
> If they transfer money out and it turns out it was fraud they can easily compensate the original account holder by putting the money back in their account and there's little harm done, especially if the sums are small.

But, once he'd learned that all of the other ½ cents are left floating around inside the megacorporation's database, Gorman hacked into the company's computer system and funneled them all into his next check, accruing the amount of $85,789.90, (a crime that would be later be known in slang as "salami slicing").

https://superman.fandom.com/wiki/Gus_Gorman

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by tluyben2 on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:02AM (#33463700)
Maybe for your account they registered the wrong number as well?

I could’ve gone on using it if I hadn’t told them. But in NL this is an issue (hence I tried so hard); bank accounts to companies need to be closed asap when the company gets closed and you definitely cannot pay or receive money with them as that will anger the tax office.

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by jeromegv on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:21AM (#33465392)
But PayPal is not a bank or registered as a bank, so would that matter?
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by Tijdreiziger on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:27AM (#33465453)
They certainly are. From their NL terms and conditions [1]:

> Who provides the Service?

> The Service is provided by PayPal (Europe) S.à r.l.et Cie, S.C.A. (R.C.S. Luxembourg B 118 349) (“PayPal”) to registered users in the European Economic Area. For details on how to reach PayPal, please refer to this page on Customer Service, or in an emergency, see “What to do” below.

> PayPal is duly licensed in Luxembourg as a bank (or “credit institution” in legal terms). We are under the prudential supervision of the Luxembourg financial regulatory authority, the Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier or CSSF. The CSSF maintains a register of the organisations that it regulates at https://supervisedentities.apps.cssf.lu/index.html?language=.... PayPal is number B00000351 on the register, but you can also look us up on the register by our name.

[1] https://www.paypal.com/nl/webapps/mpp/ua/servicedescription-...

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by missedthecue on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:03AM (#33463707)
Does "very very occasionally" mean you use it frequently or infrequently?
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by kingofpandora on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:42AM (#33463970)
It means infrequently.
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by xphx on Friday November 04, 2022 @10:20AM (#33467119)
Does "frequently" mean once a year on Jan 1? Does "infrequently" mean a hundred times today at truly random intervals?
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by mihaaly on Friday November 04, 2022 @05:55AM (#33464064)
I closed my account when they discovered suspicious activity in my account, at least claimed so but apart from locking me out until I prove I am me with photo ID copy and independent sources about my address (bank statement, utility bill, ...), basically collecting more data on me, they did not make any steps tracking down this suspicious activity, not even explaining what it was, they did not report it to the authorities! It was complete unresponsiveness when I asked for details on the event, asking about reference to the case at the authorities, told them that I will report it myself to the authorities (someone doing something to my money!!) and need some info, nothing, complete silence!

My conclusion that they simply lied to my face!

I was around the time when PayPal got some bank like regulatory status in Ireland and might have needed some more data so they forced me to provide through a bullst claim. At least this is the only scenario I find feasible. I had very little money there, after gaining access again (giving them a lot of data on me) there was no sign of any activity there that not belonged to me, nothing.

I decided that their practices are shady and I will never ever trust them!

(I did not report it eventually to the authorities, even the preparation for it took time with little supporting material, and I already had an unrelated matter to tackle, it was simpler leaving them and spread their reputation. PayPal definitely did not bother reporting it as I was never approached or questioned about the suspicious activity in my account ever. It was about 10 years ago btw.)

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by tluyben2 on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:17AM (#33464225)
This is normal for almost all (all?) large corps; they don't have to tell you why the account was terminated/blocked so it could be anything; something you said online (about them / founders etc), something you paid they don't agree with, just ROI vs TCO for your spending habits etc etc. They don't have to tell you and 'suspicious activities' is an easy one: adsense/adwords uses it as well. They use 'if we would tell you what it is exactly and how we measure it, it will allow evil actors to use that against us'.
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by tinus_hn on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:17AM (#33465344)
Same happened to me. Did they keep sending emails you need to agree to their new terms of service and to refuse you need to agree to their new terms?
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by The_SamminAter on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:21AM (#33465389)
Same here, someone tried to transfer money to me and PayPal decided that they didn’t like that, and that they wanted my ID. Then, they wouldn’t let me close my account, and when I finally provided some sort of ID they claimed that my name is wrong and as such can’t do anything until I provide more ID with an account name change request. All of which apparently makes the account impossible to close. Or so I presume, having talked with support four separate times, receiving completely different reasons/answers, and then finally saying that they’ll force-close my account, which they never did.

Now when I do absolutely need to use PayPal, I use my card on a friend’s account (with their permission).

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by lozenge on Friday November 04, 2022 @08:55AM (#33465775)
It's actually illegal to tell clients when a Suspicious Activity Report is filed. It's quite possible they filed one. It wouldn't necessarily trigger any investigation but it would be kept on file.
Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by wsc981 on Friday November 04, 2022 @07:54AM (#33465126)
> I lost access to a PayPal account I had used for years, because one day they decided they needed to know the CVV of a long-expired credit card, and refused to let me log in without it.

LOL, I kinda had the same issue, but I had to remember the last 4 numbers of some old credit card. Couldn't find it in any email, so yeah ... couldn't use my Paypal anymore.

Re:I fought the PayPal and I won by rippercushions on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:25AM (#33466290)
This was a while ago, so maybe it was the four digits and not the CVV for me as we? Not sure, but I do recall that the card was waaaaay expired (as in, a decade ago) and it took me a while to figure out what card they were even referring to.