> Due to the nature of Codex, Copilot, and AI in general, Plaintiffs cannot be certain these examples would produce the same results if attempted following additional trainings of Codex and/or Copilot.
The offending solution from the AI included extra lines that are reasonably understood to come straight from Eloquent JavaScript:
console.log(isEven(50));
// → true
console.log(isEven(75));
// → false
console.log(isEven(‐1));
// → ??There’s not even a single mention of any established legal doctrines around copyright and software, such as abstract-filter-compare, idea-expression dichotomy, etc.
I assume they want some kind of broad relief, such as an injunction to take down copilot. They are not going to get it, they are not going to get anything at all, if they can’t even provide examples of violating code.
Perhaps that is why they are reaching out to potential class members
> if they can’t even provide examples of violating code.
This is the very beginning of a very long process. I wouldn't rule out a settlement where class members get $10-100, which is a common resolution for class action suits.
The lawyers defending the founders did try to make the argument that no infringement had been proven, and that the list itself was not proof of any infringement. It was just a list on a website, and they even presented evidence that the counter on the list was algorithm faulty. The judges was not convinced and applied the common sense approach that taken as a whole, it was not believable that no infringement had occurred by the website given the context of the site (the name, the top list, the overall perspective of how the site was designed).
AI/ML will change every field just as the Internet and smartphones did. It doesn't show any indication of peaking, either.
If the US chooses the wrong path here, we'll only tie our hands behind our backs. Other countries won't be so foolish.
We should be able to train on any media a child could see, hear, or read.
Otherwise they would create the ultimate "copyright laundry machine".[1]
I'm very sure at least Hollywood and the big music labels would not like that… ;-)
Chill dude, all they have to do is include the licenses on their generated code.
If anything, this is going to generate even more progress. The copilot team would have to create some kind of feature that would connect the generated output the the relevant training data. That'd be pretty incredible to see in the field of AI/ML in general.
Of course, end user could just strip the license/attribution off their generated output, but that's a different story.
Copilot losing the lawsuit is evidence it’s a case of overfitting, not true ML.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstraction-Filtration-Compari...
"In computer programs, concerns for efficiency may limit the possible ways to achieve a particular function, making a particular expression necessary to achieving the idea. In this case, the expression is not protected by copyright."
"Finally, material that exists in the public domain can not be copyrighted and is also removed from the analysis."
That code is specifically optimized for efficiency and there were similar approaches floating (get it?) around in the 1980s.
On the other hand, Microsoft may only need to show "Hey, we got this code from FooBar under this license and this license and ..."
The essence of the algorithm takes 4 lines: function declaration, declaration of 'y', one line for calculating the exponent in log-space, one line for returning the root finding.
The rest is fluff. Every line of the snippet has creative input with the chosen names ('threehalfs' for 1.5F), the order of declarations and instructions, the redundancy. There have been internet-wars around indentations and newlines, these are style choices.
((And it is public -- GPL more specifically, which is a restrictive license that should be respected. I think this snippets makes a perfect example of the dangers of copilot. But not one to litigate details with.))
I think they intentionally picked (literal) textbook examples because they're short and easy for non-experts to grasp and have some understanding of. But I don't think we've seen any of the code from the respective J. Doe's yet, and I would assume we would in the trial (possibly in addition to more cases).
" Showing 1 - 20 of 66 files found (in 76 milliseconds)"
So, if this lawsuit succeeds in some way shape or form, does the author have a case against the 66 people that reproduced these lines in their own repository?
IIRC, that is wrong. What you are describing is trademarks, not copyright.
So it isn't too hard to prove the case.