News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by UncleMeat on Thursday November 03, 2022 @03:59PM (#33456641)
IIRC, np was the norm for many years and it just didn't actually change anything. Oodles of people do get banned from SRD for commenting in linked threads. The easiest way to see this is when month+ old threads get linked. Only the admins can see downvoting patterns.

Is simply linking to other threads on reddit sufficient for you to consider something promoting brigading?

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by bnralt on Thursday November 03, 2022 @04:22PM (#33456941)
> Is simply linking to other threads on reddit sufficient for you to consider something promoting brigading?

As I mentioned previously, linking to other subs, or even simply _talking_ about /r/StarTrek, was enough for admins to accuse /r/Star_Trek of brigading. They threatened to shut them down unless they stopped members from doing that, and so you're not allowed to do it in the sub anymore.

Whether you think that linking to other subs is brigading or not, it's clear that admins call it brigading when they want to shut down subs, yet then let continue on much larger subs dedicated to the act as long as the admins like the sub.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by bombcar on Thursday November 03, 2022 @04:37PM (#33457150)
The big difference with Reddit is if posters get banned, or if the subreddit gets banned.

The "good" subreddits will get posters banned left and right, but accounts are cheap and they return.

The "bad" subreddits get banned.