News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by digitalsushi on Thursday November 03, 2022 @02:20PM (#33455161)
I can speak only at a Star Trek technobabble level on this, but I'd like it if I could mark other random accounts as "friends" or "trusted". Anything they upvote or downvote becomes a factor in whether I see a post or not. I'd also be upvoting/downvoting things, and being a possible friend/trusted.

I'd like a little metadata with my posts, such as how controversial my network voted it. The ones that are out of calibration, I can view, see their responses, and then I could see if my network has changed. It would be nice to click on a friend and get a report across months of how similar we vote. If we started drift, I can easily cull them and get my feed cleaned up.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by billyjobob on Thursday November 03, 2022 @02:41PM (#33455453)
Slashdot started introducing features like this 20 years ago. We thought ”web of trust” would be the future of content moderation, but subsequent forums have moved further and further away from empowering users to choose what they want to see and towards simple top down censorship.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by bombcar on Thursday November 03, 2022 @04:17PM (#33456880)
Web of trust works too well and unfortunate ideas can be entertained by someone you trust, which is a no-no once you have top-down ideas.

Almost everyone has someone they trust so much that even the most insane conspiracy theory would be entertained at least for awhile if that trusted person brought it up.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by SV_BubbleTime on Thursday November 03, 2022 @04:29PM (#33457043)
Can't have people being exposed to diversity of thought! Not by people they like, what if someone is wrong!

... I'm all about low hanging fruit in moderation, and not trying to fix human behavior. I'll keep waiting to see when that is back in vogue.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by TMWNN on Thursday November 03, 2022 @05:53PM (#33458301)
>Almost everyone has someone they trust so much that even the most insane conspiracy theory would be entertained at least for awhile if that trusted person brought it up.

What's wrong with that?

If someone you trust brings up a crazy idea, it should be considered. Maybe for a day, maybe for an hour, maybe for a half second, but it shouldn't be dismissed immediately no matter what.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by bombcar on Friday November 04, 2022 @09:35AM (#33466420)
There's nothing wrong with it, but it is NOT desired at scale.

And as individuals we should build up those relationships in reality (not online) because they're incredibly helpful.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by rdtwo on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:21PM (#33458699)
I mean remember when the wuhan lab thing was a total conspiracy theory. Or when masks were supposedly (not airborne) not needed and you just had to wash your hands more. All sorts of fringe stuff sometimes turns out to be true. But you know sometimes you get pizzagate but it’s the price we pay.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by guelo on Thursday November 03, 2022 @04:26PM (#33457003)
It's not censorship, it's about optimizing for advertisers instead of users. Which means users can't have too much control.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by rewgs on Thursday November 03, 2022 @05:47PM (#33458218)
I wish we'd just stopped at "users won't pay" and realized that, if people aren't willing to pay for it, maybe it's not a product worth building.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by rdtwo on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:23PM (#33458718)
True you don’t want to advertise on anti China stuff (even if true)
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by chupchap on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:40PM (#33459551)
Doesn't that just create echo-chambers?
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by robocat on Thursday November 03, 2022 @02:50PM (#33455588)
I would frame it more the opposite: I can easily see comments that are worthless to me, and I want to automatically downvote any comments by the same user (perhaps needs tags: there are users whose technical opinions are great, but I’m not interested at all in their jokes or politics).

One problem with your idea is that moderation votes are anonymous, but ranking up positively or negatively depending on another users votes would allow their votes to be deanonymised.

Perhaps adding in deterministic noise would be enough to offset that? Or to prevent deanonimisation you need a minimum number of posting friends?

In fact I would love to see more noise added to the HN comments and a factor to offset early voting. Late comments get few votes because they have low visibility, which means many great comments don’t bubble to the top.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by mjamesaustin on Thursday November 03, 2022 @02:59PM (#33455726)
In this thread, Yishan promotes an app called Block Party that lets you block anyone, or even all accounts that liked or retweeted something.

https://twitter.com/blockpartyapp_

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by bombcar on Thursday November 03, 2022 @04:20PM (#33456909)
BlockParty is almost the definition of echo chamber construction.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by Melatonic on Thursday November 03, 2022 @03:39PM (#33456326)
Very interesting idea and I think this could definitely be useful. Then again users could just create new accounts.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by cauthon on Thursday November 03, 2022 @04:02PM (#33456693)
Unfortunately this is antithetical to the advertising-based revenue model these sites operate on. There's no incentive for the site to relinquish their control over what you see and return it to the user.

On an anecdotal level, the fraction of tweets in my feed that are "recommended topics" or "liked by people I follow" or simply "promoted" has risen astronomically over the past few months. I have a pretty curated list of follows (~100), I had the "show me tweets in chronological order" box checked back when that was an option, and the signal to noise ratio has still become overwhelmingly unusable.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by makeitdouble on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:04PM (#33459201)
This would become hard to manage as you expand to users you “trust” but don’t agree with. Or users that have extremely good views in one topic they spend most of their time talking about, and the few rare posts about other topics that express extremely bad views. Users with high trust networks also become a target for spam and low brow accounts: anything they get to engage with will be boosted exponentially.

I think this comes back to the “focus on bad behaviors, not bad actors” discussion, but in reverse: focusing on “good actors” (“trusted” users) assumes people have fixed patterns, when there’s a lot of nuance and variability to be taken into account.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by jb_s on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:11PM (#33459268)
It's a great way to create a bubble.

Amusingly, a subreddit I frequent has one notorious user who has abused the 'block' feature to ensure their frequent posts on a particular topic are free of dissenting commenters. They block anyone who even slightly disagrees with their position, this prevents them from seeing his threads, and the comments on each thread become entirely one-sided as a result - and the growing list of blocked people have no idea that those threads even exist.

Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by doubleunplussed on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:34PM (#33460616)
Are you talking about /r/AusFinance?
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by o10449366 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:40PM (#33460147)
Honestly, the voting sorts on Reddit are an underrated feature. Being able to sort comments not by total number of upvotes (which I feel panders to low-effort content) but by highest ratio of upvotes to downvotes produces an extremely different experience. I also enjoy being able to see "controversial" comments because sometimes those can be quite insightful.
Re:Ex-Reddit CEO on Twitter moderation by emodendroket on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:25AM (#33462856)
If you use Twitter long enough you'll find that some people you thought were interesting will either take an interest in a new topic ("yeah, I liked your discussions of music, but I actually don't ever wish to hear your political opinions") or just have some kind of epiphany that alienates you from them.