Re:1959 Chevy Corvette Seized by Police Returned to Owner Af...
by bombcar on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @07:34PM
(#33444372)
Laws around cars are exceptionally strict to prevent manufacturers and car thieves from pulling fast ones, and if they are excessively applied you get insane results.
Re:1959 Chevy Corvette Seized by Police Returned to Owner Af...
by pencilguin on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @08:50PM
(#33445157)
Seems like state employees could be sued personally for exceeding their legal authority. There should be a lot more of that, especially on cops and prosecutors, particularly southern ones.
Re:1959 Chevy Corvette Seized by Police Returned to Owner Af...
by mdmglr on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @09:17PM
(#33445416)
Great example of how govt works. As a gov’t contracted I’ve learned first had- gov’t employees have no critical thinking skills nor understanding of nuance. Does a guy with a 50k 1959 Chevy look like a thief?
Re:1959 Chevy Corvette Seized by Police Returned to Owner Af...
by more_corn on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @09:24PM
(#33445499)
This pisses me off too. But after thinking about it for a moment I can see the state’s point. The only way to know this car isn’t stolen is the vin. The vin shows signs of tampering. Therefore I don’t know this car is the correct one matching the vin.
This case is absurd and terrible, but the rule is there to protect us all from car theft so I get being strict.
When restoring a car if you remove the vin you best put it back on with the correct fasteners. The root of the problem was the restorer’s shoddy work. Then the error was compounded by the state’s inflexibility. They should also be held liable for harm that came to the car while in their custody.
Re:1959 Chevy Corvette Seized by Police Returned to Owner Af...
by UncleEntity on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @11:56PM
(#33446805)
The vin is stamped all over cars oftentimes in places where it is very hard to get to. Classic car folks will check them all to make sure they aren’t paying top dollar for a car that has been pieced together from parts of different cars.
I saw one video on the YouTubes where they were talking about how highly illegal it is to mess with the vin plate so its not like a random Kansas MVD employee just pulled some law out of their ass because they were having a bad day. Specifically, iirc, they were saying in the video it was illegal to even sell replacement rivets for vin plates.
One would think they would try to figure out who the rightful owner of a car with an altered vin before taking it to the crusher though.
Re:1959 Chevy Corvette Seized by Police Returned to Owner Af...
by ratg13 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @03:45AM
(#33448151)
That's just the Dashboard VIN.
The VIN is stamped all over the car. If the dashboard VIN matches the VINs all over the rest of the car, there is no reason to go zero tolerance over the wrong screws used in one location.
Re:1959 Chevy Corvette Seized by Police Returned to Owner Af...
by playeren on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @10:51PM
(#33446370)
The important point of this story is not whether VIN plates should or shouldn't be affixed with rivets. It is whether the state should be able to _administratively_ confiscate personal and valuable property without a court order. Civil forfeiture laws have no place in democratic societies.
Seeing the owner crying in the YouTube video, heartbroken and angry made me feel sad.
All over two rivets.
Apparently dreams go to Kansas die by a crusher.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marvin_Heemeyer#The_bulldozer
https://youtu.be/Xmr6jIpXSmg
Rivets indicated the VIN might be faked I guess.
State legislators changed the law to get him his car back.
Care to elaborate?
This case is absurd and terrible, but the rule is there to protect us all from car theft so I get being strict.
When restoring a car if you remove the vin you best put it back on with the correct fasteners. The root of the problem was the restorer’s shoddy work. Then the error was compounded by the state’s inflexibility. They should also be held liable for harm that came to the car while in their custody.
I saw one video on the YouTubes where they were talking about how highly illegal it is to mess with the vin plate so its not like a random Kansas MVD employee just pulled some law out of their ass because they were having a bad day. Specifically, iirc, they were saying in the video it was illegal to even sell replacement rivets for vin plates.
One would think they would try to figure out who the rightful owner of a car with an altered vin before taking it to the crusher though.
The VIN is stamped all over the car. If the dashboard VIN matches the VINs all over the rest of the car, there is no reason to go zero tolerance over the wrong screws used in one location.