I found the book "Self Awareness" by Red Hawk pretty helpful in disentangling and disambiguating some of this stuff.
If you need courage to face your demons but only facing those demons will give you the courage to do the thing in the first place, then how to solve that circular dependency?
Preparing the mind is crucial to using psychedelics responsibly and avoiding that the negative emotions that come up take over you
If someone wants to say "I dropped acid and it helped me," fine. People are allowed to share personal experiences, though it's a mistake to universalize them.
But this "oh you didn't meditate enough" or whatever is such nonsense. It's a claim about these drugs and how they work that you have no grounds to make.
I haven't taken any hallucinogens in over a decade, but my HPPD symptoms still persist to this day. I have visual snow syndrome, warping, palinopsia/tracers, and phosphenes. They're not debilitating, but extremely annoying and for a lot of people it sends them into suicidal ideation or panic.
As with everything else, YMMV. You might be perfectly fine or you might be one of the rare ones like me that acquire unexpected side effects despite the fact that many people tout these drugs as having mild or temporary effects. Choose wisely.
I also did a lot of meditation, and pretty extensive sessions (40-60m) of it for a few months.
Some things to consider if you're interested.
Andrew Callaghan of "ALL GAS NO BRAKES" suffers from HPPD and has started to discuss it openly: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zUbod5t_2oM&t=1247s
I think hearing HPPD stories from popular media figures like Callaghan can help seed healthy discussions about the risks of psychedelic use. In the past few years, the media has been way too optimistic about the potential positives of psychedelics while almost ignoring the risks and downsides.
I'm just making this up, and have zero studies to quote, but may it be that HPPD is actually a positive sign, on a path to healed trauma?
I think you need to worry if you're getting into depersonalization-derealization, otherwise you might just have some minor visual artifacts.
It's your decision if the pros outweigh the cons in your situation, but in my experience tackling trauma head-on in a safe environment has measurably improved my overall health.
But regarding mushrooms: on their own, I believe they're not that useful for healing. I have a (layman's) theory that post-trip therapy is probably more successful due to increased neuroplasticity of the brain[1]. There was also some research that suggested the DMN gets a bit "scrambled"[2], so another of my layman's theories is that it's able to reach a new "equilibrium" once it was kicked into this unstable state.
[1]: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.02.17.431629v1...., and a more easily digested version is here https://www.sciencealert.com/one-dose-of-psilocybin-regrows-...
[2]: Can't find the thing I was thinking of now, but googling "psilocybin dmn" will yield some interesting reads regardless!
Like OP, for me personally it has profound effects on me and helps me improve and maintain my mental health.
Everyone is different.
After 2-3 months and giving it another try did not replicate that experience. In addition to it, if anything it lasted for that trip only.
Maybe I should have done something during the trip. I was just watching a movie being cozy at home.
Mushrooms pulled me back from the precipace of suicide, I will never stop advocating for their usage and legalisation - but this is dangerously wrong.
At worst they can shoot you into a horror space from which you will not return, and that needs to be considered before taking them.
There's also a danger zone (Lana) in between a medium dose and a large dose, in which you're not so incapacitated as to be immobile, but too incapacitated to accurately judge reality.
I find that often times the extraordinary ability to be introspective on mushrooms is a detriment. I have the same issue with a lot of the push to be introspective lately. It keeps me in my head and away from properly enjoying things.
I think mushrooms can be a good tool, and at worst a fun drug but they're not a cure all and they don't work for everyone.