News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by rayiner on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:32PM (#33416232)
What a self own:

> On the one hand, if all embryos and fetuses that are destroyed, miscarried, or aborted go to hell for eternity, one cannot reasonably believe that our universe was created by a morally perfect, all-knowing, and all-powerful god. This means that pro-life Christians must abandon the traditional Christian view of God in favor of some alternative, and doing this may weaken or undermine their reasons for opposing abortion in the first place.

Under this reasoning, there is no moral justification for opposing infanticide, because the exact same logic applies to infants as well.

I’m not categorically against abortion, but I think the pro-abortion people have the burden of proof here. I think it’s fair to take as axiomatic that you can’t kill newborns for convenience. So what justifies doing so N weeks earlier? This analysis provides no insight.

Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by etrautmann on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:52PM (#33416363)
This who debate boils down to drawing hard lines on top of gradients. I find it uncomplicated to argue that a blastula is not a human (yet) and the potential for life is not a useful moral metric either (otherwise it'd be immoral not to maximize fertilization and child output).

Everything in between a few cells and a baby is a gradient between next to nothing and complete humanness, and somehow we need to agree where lines should be drawn to binarize this gray area for moral and legal decision making. It's clearly an impossible task, so the fight will persist.

Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by rayiner on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:23AM (#33416885)
I generally agree, but to nitpick: I’d say a blastula is a “human” insofar as the term identifies a distinct organism of the human species. But it may not be a “person.”
Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by allturtles on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:26AM (#33420861)
If the moral logic of heaven mean that we shouldn't condemn infanticide (after all it just gets souls to heaven faster, and heaven is way better than earth), isn't that a problem for Christian doctrine, not the author of this paper?
Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by rayiner on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:31PM (#33424442)
No, because that paraphrasing is the author’s logic, not Christian doctrine.
Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by boxed on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:48AM (#33433361)
It's not the doctrine. But it's the logical extrapolation.
Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by rayiner on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @07:03AM (#33433898)
It’s not, because it assumes all sorts of things about the purpose of life and the afterlife, what’s “better,” and applies a utilitarian definition to the morality of killing.
Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by boxed on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @04:25PM (#33442467)
Sure. It assumes torturing innocents is bad for example. Many religious people seem to not 100% back that assumption. I think that's a problem :P
Re:The Afterlife Dilemma: A Problem for the Christian Pro-Li... by boxed on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @05:44AM (#33433321)
> Under this reasoning, there is no moral justification for opposing infanticide

...if they go to heaven yes. If they go to hell then there's a huge reason to oppose it. But of course, this causes another moral hazard for Christians.

This IS the consequence of taking Christian beliefs seriously. The good thing about Christians is that they don't really take their beliefs seriously. That's a huge strength. There's a reason "fundamentalist" literally means "believes in the basic ideas" and also means "a crazy person".