The government effectively established monopolies in phone service. Telephone numbering was not even close to seamless and painless. When dialing was introduced there was pushback and plenty of need for education of consumers, not to mention concerns about the loss of jobs for telephone operators. Establishing international numbering and the ITU has been a costly and slow diplomatic process.
The result is a system which is now almost useless because of the lack of spam prevention that facilitates elder abuse at a large scale.
If it wasn’t a legacy technology, I certainly wouldn’t recommend the telephone to my mother as a product.
The reason we have alternatives now is that there was no regulation preventing us from developing VoIP and other communications services via the internet.
Frankly it’s weird that we would even consider the telephone as a model for current regulation. It’s an antiquated legacy stepping stone from the time before computers.
That was the example that was brought up.
Yes, some government regulations are bad. But some are good.
And this example of being able to port your phone number... seems to be a pretty simple, uncontroversial, and good feature, that could possibly be applied to social media companies as well.
No, it can’t because social media isn’t based on phone numbers, and social networks aren’t telephone networks, and each one works differently.
Honestly, it's hard to quantify how well it worked because we got so used to it; it stopped being "technology" and just became "part of life."
The internet did grow out of telephony so perhaps it's not surprising that it shares many of the same qualities, however I think these government vs private debates often ignore that the failures and shortcomings of these systems are usually a result of both bad government intervention and bad private actors, not solely one or the other
Yes, many similar problems have indeed arisen, but the point is that they are being solved by many private actors, and not by regulation.
Email spam is solved by spam filtering. To the extent that spam filtering isn’t adequate, communications simply move away from email to other messaging services that have better permission models. To the extent that messaging services are not private enough, communications shift to E2E encryption. To the extent that domains are confusing, people shift to search and apps. The list goes on.
Phone spam however, continues unabated.
This is no different from say, assault, which doesn’t regulate hammers and baseball bats, but makes it illegal to hit people with them without their permission.
My understanding of phone spam regulation is there is some that legislates technology, namely forbidding completion of connections of spoofed phone numbers.
When the phone service was a monopoly in the USA it had five nines of uptime and close to zero latency.
It's been downhill since then.
I agree that the telephone isn't a great example of where regulation has worked, but I think the specific example of phone number portability is a good one: something that no carrier would ever implement, but something that is great to help customers avoid being locked in to a single provider.
We already have portability. When you sign up to a new network, you provide your phone number and email address, and your friends can find you.
What if your friends only know you online, and do not know your phone number or email address?
But social media is not a utility, in the traditional sense.
The government regulation of the phone system works well because the government regulations are well designed, not because there's a limit to how many wires you can hang from a pole.
Edit: I say this as someone who loved the dial telephone era. I really want one of these: https://skysedge.com/unsmartphones/RUSP/index.html
I would have bought one, but then I realized that the phone is useless now.
Now you're just being absurd. Do you think we had iphones decades ago? A few decades ago rotary dial phones were still common, cellphones were virtually unheard of, VoIP was a dream, nobody expected a resurgence of the telegraph (e.g. SMS), and switching was still done with in-band signaling.
Virtually everything about telephones has changed over the past few decades. It's easier to list the things which haven't changed: we still use phone numbers (kind of... because actually almost everybody uses the contacts app built into their phones.) We still pay phone companies for the service, except now there's tons of phone companies and you aren't stuck with one.
The iPhone is not primarily a telephone. If you are going to argue that it is, you really aren’t being reasonable.
Also, if you look at the history, you’ll discover that these innovations were all held back by regulation and the fixed nature of the phone system.
Nonsensical distinction. The common person sends and receives SMS using their telephone, using the same phone numbers used to call people, with the same disregard for whether they and the recipient use the same phone company because, like telephone calls, SMS works across companies. When you port your phone number to a new phone company, you continue to receive SMS sent to your number just as you do phone calls.
(And in actual fact, there are phone companies that do offer SMS service to landline phones.)
That your definition of ‘phone’ is meaningless. If phones can have any capability you like, then ‘phone’ doesn’t mean anything.
Once you are playing that game you may as well just declare that social networks can be regulated because they are a ‘capability some things that can also communicate with phones have’, and phones are already regulated.
So not actually part of what it means to be a phone then.
> Now you're just being absurd. Do you think we had iphones decades ago?
An iphone is an implementation detail, it's not the phone system.
The great thing about phones is the longevity. My parents have had the same phone number since the late 60s. Anyone who's known them for the past ~50 years can still reach out via the same number. That's awesome.
No proprietay social network will ever match that because they come and go on the back of the controlling company revenue performance.
The only way to stay in touch for the long haul is open standards, in the case of internet that means: email
I've had the same email since the mid 90s and will have it for the rest of my life. If you've ever known me, you can still reach me on the same email now and into the future.
Anyone can buy their own domain and there are many providers who will provide email service.
The vast majority of email is hosted by one of the large providers these days and if people can't reply to you the utility of your address is lessened.
Fortunately that's not at all what having a personal email is like.
First of all, you can always receive email no matter what. Nobody is blocking that.
Sending it to some larger providers requires configuring everything correctly, but it's not rocket science. Lots of people (including me) do it with minimal effort.
Finally, having your own email (domain) doesn't require self-hosting it if you don't want. You can always delegate that part to some provider. But you control the domain so you can switch providers (or switch to self-hosting) any moment. You can also do a hybrid option where you self-host receiving but farm out the sending, if you prefer. So many options, all of them work!
There are 16 tier 1 ISPs which basically hold the entire internet in their control. Arguably these companies should be required to route any legal traffic.
It's not as though the premise is without precedent. It's easy to port your phone number to a new telephone company and all your friends can still call you. That's thanks to government "control" (aka regulation.) Maybe it's even too easy from a security perspective, but it's not as though you have to navigate a byzantine and capricious government bureaucracy to get it done. For the common person it generally works very well, seamless and painless.