News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Open-source user onboarding and KYC flow made wi... by Msw242 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:55PM (#33397430)
hilariously, it is because of increasing regulation that users will need to upload more sensitive data to more services.

Even requesting to delete your data in the EU requires the submission of sensitive data in order to verify your identity and fulfill the request.

Re:Show HN: Open-source user onboarding and KYC flow made wi... by encryptluks2 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:00PM (#33397476)
Of course it is. They regulate what information you have to collect and then how you're supposed to collect it, while trying to make sure you don't collect too much or store it in the wrong way and that you you show the correct messages on your website.
Re:Show HN: Open-source user onboarding and KYC flow made wi... by Jon_Lowtek on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:29PM (#33401403)
> EU requires the submission of sensitive data in order to verify your identity

The EU created eIDAS to enable people to authenticate without submission of sensitive data by using digital signatures, based on public key cryptography, using an id card with an embedded security module and a pin. When interacting with companies in a kyc flow, or to claim rights under gdpr, the people could sign a statement of purpose and a timestamp, creating data that can't be re-used to authenticate as them at a later time for a different purpose.

But no one implements that. Instead companies implement the worst possible authentication, the bottom of the barrel solution that is only legal in the EU due to the industry lobbying for backwards compatibility with existing manual workflows from the age of snail mail: uploading photos of identity documents and smiling into a webcam.

In the worst case the collected data is then stored raw, without timestamp and purpose watermarks, leaving the customers vulnerable to identity theft should their data ever be stolen. In the worst-worst case it's also accessible by anyone with even the weakest and most far fetched claim to need to know, without so much as rate limiting or misuse detection, so that phishing any internal account is enough to put all this sensitive data on sale at a darknet market.