News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by D13Fd on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:34AM (#33391415)
I think touch screens are ok right now for two things: settings menus that you set once and never touch again, and Apple CarPlay.

I recently moved backwards from a CarPlay car to a non-CarPlay car. Even with a very convenient MagSafe phone mount right where the CarPlay screen used to be, I still miss CarPlay. It was just easier and more convenient for controlling phone media, gps, etc.

On the settings app, the choice is between a crappy touchscreen UI and a crappy non-touchscreen UI, so I’m kind of neutral.

But otherwise I agree. Nothing having anything to do with actively controlling the car should be on a touchscreen.

Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by sand500 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:40AM (#33391466)
Mazda disables touch for Android auto and carplay and I think that's awesome. The wheel is much better to use.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by schuke on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:50AM (#33391520)
I have never driven a Mazda but I watch a lot of car reviews. It seems to me they're the only car manufacturer that gets car interactions right. They actually have a philosophy how human-cars should interact and design everything based on it. Hence everything comes natural and consistent and logical.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by CornCobs on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:12AM (#33391651)
Dad has a Mazda. Can vouch for this 100%. It's very clear to me when I drive it that their car interfaces are very deliberate and properly designed. That rolling knob thing which controls the screen is amazing and I wish it were standard
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by para_parolu on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:56AM (#33391894)
It may sound strange but UX is main reason why I drive mazda. I have no other requirements (besides basic safety).
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by pintxo on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:37AM (#33392094)
Driver UX was the reason of my initial focus on BMW over other makers.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by joecool1029 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:38AM (#33392440)
You say this but their drivers still can't figure out how to operate turn signals.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by lisper on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:27AM (#33393106)
BMW is not bad (I own one) but try turning off the air conditioner some time.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by prepend on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:57PM (#33397441)
I’ve got an off button in the center of my controls. The only oddity is that I have to press it to lower the airflow from 5 to 0 (off) but otherwise pretty easy to find and use. It says “OFF.”
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by lisper on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:07PM (#33397524)
That turns off the entire climate control system, not just the air conditioner.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by prepend on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:47PM (#33397921)
I misunderstood what you were looking for. AC seems easier for me as there’s a button labeled “A/C” that is lit up when AC is turned on and not lit up when it is off.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by lisper on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:00PM (#33398062)
Really? What model do you have? I have a 330e and it does not have an A/C button, only a "MAX A/C" button. I can turn the A/C on with this button, but I can't turn it back off.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by prepend on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:06PM (#33413122)
2018 330. That’s weird you don’t have an AC button. What I find curious is that “Max AC” is on the left side on a big round button but “AC” is on the right side on a square button with another square above it.

I don’t understand the layout sense but at least I’m lucky enough to have buttons.

Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by smolder on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:22AM (#33393800)
They've had their hits and misses over the years. Not at all typical, I'm sure, but a fun anecdote: I had a 90s bmw at one point, with electronic controls for the adjustable driver's seat down near the floor between the seat and door. The buttons got wet one time when it was raining, and it led to the seat coming alive and trying to crush me against the steering wheel while in highway traffic. Mashing on the controls didn't work and the motor was quite powerful. I was barely able to pull over with the room I had to move. If I wasn't as thin as I am, I might have been pinned down and crashed.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by lloeki on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:39AM (#33392796)
I can't say it's the main reason I would choose a car, but bad UX (the whole thing, from UI to knobs) is certainly one of the no-compromise ones I would bail a car on.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by kennend3 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:16AM (#33393752)
I moved from a Mazda to Hyundai and find my Elantra very much like my Mazda 6 in terms of ease-of-use.

It has android auto/carplay. To change songs, increase the volume, mute you use buttons on the steering wheel. There is a physical volume up/down knob as well in case the passenger wants to use it and these can be done via the touch screen as well.

They have done an excellent job blending new technology and continuing to use "what works" from the past.

Too many of these touch screens in cars requires accessing menue's and sub-menu's to do basic things that should be on the steering wheel. My ex-wife's Lexus which cost 5x what i paid for my Elantra wont let her access the navigation system unless it is stopped and in park?? I can simply hold a button on the steering wheel to access Siri and state where i want to go. Far too often if you touch the screen on her lexis you get "vehicle is in motion".. Great.. and i'm in the passenger seat confused as to why this is an issue?

this is such a problem that there are instructions on how to override it? https://www.wikihow.com/Override-Lexus-Navigation-Motion-Loc...

perhaps they should have done a better job planning this out before releasing it to the public?

Personally i feel Hyundai provides better "value for your money". By not having the incredibly complicated model and options packages you find in North American cars they keep their costs down and the variations on their products low.

No need to deal with the NA style "you want package A, you need to get packages B and C as well" crap.

Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by oktwtf on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:14AM (#33391673)
This was the first thing I disable when I got my 2016 Mazda 3. SSH'd into the infotainment and locked the GPS position. Now the car thinks I'm always parked, even when rolling. I also reduced the warning/notice on boot to about 500ms.

Considering this, I don't think I've ever even had to touch the screen since; the wheel is just so nice. The volume knob down in that cluster is also very ergonomic.

Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by ah27182 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:35AM (#33392424)
I dont get locking the GPS. Was is to your car from keep beeping if your seatbelt was unbuckled?
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by kennend3 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:24AM (#33393824)
Some cars like My ex-wife's lexus wont let you access the navigation system unless the vehicle is stopped.

This is VERY VERY stupid and TBH dangerous. Should se find herself lost on the highway she would need to leave the highway or stop on the side of the road to access the navigation system??

If you attempt to access the nav system while the vehicle is not stopped it simply displays some sort of "vehicle is in motion" alarm.

My Elantra wont let me use the keyboard to enter an address while the vehicle is in motion, but it will let me use Siri so i can make changes while moving if needed.

Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by digitallyfree on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:14AM (#33394672)
Is the system still disabled if someone is present in the front passenger seat (modern vehicles have sensors for this)? Oftentimes the passenger acts as the navigator and it wouldn't make sense for them to be locked out of the system.
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by kennend3 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:27AM (#33394765)
Yes, it has been a while since i've been in her car.. i think you actually need to put it in park to "unlock" it, not just be stopped.

This is why I said the system is very stupid.. one would think that a passenger can access the navigation system given they are not driving.

The lesson I took away from this is: Never buy a car with a built-in GPS system.

Android auto/carplay are a much better - They are not likely to hold your car "ransom" for map updates or such, and don't have stupid rules like must be in park.

Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by userbinator on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:52PM (#33397977)
It's weird that they didn't think of the simplest solution, which is to use the speedometer, and instead chose to use GPS. I suppose that makes it so you can't even use the nav if you happen to be riding on a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roll-on/roll-off .
Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by lloeki on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:20AM (#33392675)
I have a Mazda 2, touch is disabled as soon as the car starts rolling, but is available at a stop.

I like their rotating joyknob implementation, which can be used without looking nor stretching arms, and integrates well with CarPlay as well. It's so good I skip on touch even when touch would be a good fit.

Even their homegrown UI isn't that bad, which is actually praise given the crap automakers can come up with.

Side node: touch is useful for the passenger though, as reaching to the knob can be annoying for the driver, even at a stop.

Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by tallytarik on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:54AM (#33392894)
The previous gen Mazdas would disable the touch screen when the car was moving.

The latest models go one further - the screen is not touch capable at all. It’s honestly great.

Re:Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches by sneak on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:32AM (#33392058)
CarPlay cannot be used at all if you do not have Siri enabled on the device.